7 ms·
Maybe just jettison wings+engines+cargo? Though I agree that broadly safety is solved. And obviously we must heavily reduce air travel to combat global warming
by fulafel 8y ago
Maybe just jettison wings+engines+cargo?
Though I agree that broadly safety is solved. And obviously we must heavily reduce air travel to combat global warming.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThe question then becomes are can a plane fly with each of those attached by structural bulkheads & explosive bolts. The remaining ‘crew and passenger capsule’ would need to remain sealed.
- fulafel 8y agoMaybe solid forms could be explosively or electrically welded off.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoNo. This speculation is just pointless. It's simply not a solution given the engineering practicalities and cost constraints. It's also not a good way to solve what is essentially a software problem. Well-designed planes are ridiculously safe compared to almost any other mode of transport. And it's completely possible to design planes that handle all but the most extreme and unlikely edge cases. The problem here isn't that passengers didn't have a Rube-Goldberg escape route, but that Boeing made some serious design errors - and then apparently tried to cover them up.
- vfinn 8y agoI don't think speculating about the possibility of an emergency solution or escape route that is outside the reach of errors made in software/hardware/you name it is pointless. Speculating about this particular idea could be, if the idea doesn't expand to other directions. Saying that problems should be solved only within their respective domains, I don't agree with.
- saalweachter 8y agoSo let's say you've successfully engineered a plane with detachable wings. Congratulations! Now what happens when this system malfunctions and one wing pops off for no reason in normal flight?
- fulafel 8y agoYou pop the remaining parts and deploy the parachute ;)