9 ms·
Wikileaks moves to Amazon's cloud to evade massive DDoS
- mh_ 16y agoMoving to an elastic infrastructure in the face of an attack that aims to increase usage, seems like a recipe for a huge bill.. The wikileaks guys are obviously uber smart and have thought through the pros and cons of the move, but it seems an unusual choice..
- risotto 16y agoAs it's mostly static content, they're likely just using Amazon as a CDN, which isn't very expensive at all. Makes perfect sense actually. It'll be interesting to see what Amazon has to say about this.
- ra 16y agoUsing CloudFront (Amazon's CDN) does promise to solve their immediate DDoS problem. I don't know much about wikileaks as an organisation but I expect most of their money comes as donations via the web site. So, clearly having wikileaks.org up at high traffic times is important.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoA competent hosting company - with a sufficiently fat upstream pipe - should be able to handle it. Amazon has the scale to absorb this attack.
- bradly 16y agoI'm not familiar with Amazon's content policies, but I couldn't see Amazon wanting this stuff hosted on their servers.
- d2viant 16y agoIt would depend on how Wikileaks designed their AWS infrastructure. Amazon's policies are specific to the territory in which they operate. They obey the local laws for the data they will store on their hardware and will only comply with local laws. For example, if you provision your services in the EU-Ireland region, it is governed by the laws of the EU, not by the United States. That being said, I don't know the specifics of the laws with regards to each of the different AWS regions.
- JoachimSchipper 16y ago> the laws of the EU We are, sadly, not quite that far along yet.
- jules 16y agoSadly? The things that come out of the EU are at least as stupid as local laws, especially wrt technology.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoThe US has a massive commercial advantage because its laws, while not better per se, are at least uniform. Also, European national states are mostly too weak to have any influence in the global problems of the 21st century. A smaller share of a larger (power) pie would still be an improvement.
- jules 16y agoEconomically, it would be an improvement. But look at laws like the data retention law that forces ISPs to keep access logs on all their users. The EU is also highly undemocratic, or at least very indirectly democratic. First install a working democratic process, then get more power. Not the other way around "lets give them insane power and then they will surely be nice to us and give us a good democratic process" as many people seem to want. Also I'm not even sure that if there were a good democracy that I'd want to give e.g. Italians the power to vote on what happens to me, given that they elect and keep electing Berlusconi.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoMeh, the Netherlands went further than the EU requirements on data retention. Yes, that's stupid, but... And yes, creating a "EU government" is almost certainly even harder than it appears. The current system seems to combine the speed of a multi-country democracy with the legitimacy of a multi-country oligarchy (of elected ministers, but still).
- risotto 16y agoAmazon is fine with it, according to the WSJ. http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2010/11/29/wikileaks-using-amazon-servers-after-attack/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2010/11/29/wikileaks-using-amazo...
- dtf 16y ago"Amazon and WikiLeaks did not return requests for comment."
- MichaelSalib 16y agoWhy not? The New York Times and many other newspapers published the same data, and surely there's no problem hosting the NYT, so why is Wikileaks special in this regard?
- brianr 16y agoThis is very interesting. If Wikileaks does in fact become designated a terrorist organization by the US, then it seems Amazon will have to shut them down or run the risk of providing them "material aid". The same would be true of any other cloud provider... are there any sizable cloud providers outside the US?
- ScottBurson 16y agoThe overheated rhetoric spewing from some politicians notwithstanding, I can hope that no court of law will be persuaded that there can be a terrorist organization without weapons, indeed without violence of any kind. (Even if Assange has committed some violent crime on his own -- and I am not saying he has -- this is clearly not the purpose of the organization.)
- yread 16y agoDoes the government still need to go through courts when dealing with "terrorists"?
- _delirium 16y agoThere is actually a bit of judicial review in the case of designating terrorist organizations, though I don't know how thorough. Here's Wikipedia on how terrorist organizations get designated, and how they can challenge it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._State_Department_list_of_Foreign_Terrorist_Organizations#Designation_process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._State_Department_list_of_F...
- teoruiz 16y agoCloudsigma is based in Zurich, Switzerland and seems to be fairly big. They should be able to cope with this kind of attack: http://www.cloudsigma.com/ http://www.cloudsigma.com/
- jonhendry 16y agoIf Wikileaks is a terrorist, then so too is the New York Times, and any other media outlet that has conveyed the same information Wikileaks released.
- hacjjjjjjjj 16y agoWhy don't they invest some of the donation money in P2P DNS and start hosting the site as torrent ? Many people would be happy to seed.
- drdaeman 16y agoBecause Bittorrent-powered P2P DNS is a weird buzzword, not yet really existing piece of technology. And, I'd guess, WikiLeaks probably want to publish (primarily) on the mass-accessible Internet, not at some obscure place where nobody except for crypto-geeks could access it. They could try popularizing Freenet (which is already existing and is a fairly stable technology), but, again, I'd guess they probably have their hands full of other tasks already. WikiLeaks hosts torrents. For example see the link "Click here to download full site in single archive" at the bottom of http://cablegate.wikileaks.org/ http://cablegate.wikileaks.org/. And, I believe, the content is already copied to (and being discussed at) Freenet and other similiar P2P networks.
- mambodog 16y agoIf they used Freenet I can imagine the mainstream media going straight for the fact that Freenet is full of child porn. I don't think they need any more of that kind of publicity.
- netmau5 16y agoI know DDOS is a difficult problem to solve, but I think using the cloud to out-scale your attacker doesn't solve the problem, it just increases the cost of it. The obvious solution for the bad guys (not gonna call them hackers, can't call them crackers can I?) is to use the cloud too. Generating an HTTP request is even cheaper than serving static content on a CDN.
- ceejayoz 16y ago> The obvious solution for the bad guys (not gonna call them hackers, can't call them crackers can I?) is to use the cloud too. I'd say a botnet already qualifies as "the cloud". Why pay Amazon when you can get a million desktop machines doing it for free?
- stcredzero 16y agoAt college, we were already talking about "the cloud" in 1990. That's a long time before AWS was even a twinkle in anyone's eye.
- to 16y agoon ec2? 10 bucks that site is gone by end of this week.
- to 16y agoand i was right! ;)
- jjoe 16y agoIt looks like it's hosted in the US (ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com). Also, the front end proxy is doing some heavy filtering to weed out the cheap hit-and-run nodes participating in the DDoS but still accepts legitimate browser-based requests (persistent). Notice how a Reset (R) is sent right away on the first try: 08:57:41.211436 IP managed.unixy.net.49467 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: S 1398247905:1398247905(0) win 5840 <mss 1460,sackOK,timestamp 2031832550 0,nop,wscale 7> 08:57:41.264403 IP ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http > managed.unixy.net.49467: S 1288073904:1288073904(0) ack 1398247906 win 16384 <mss 1460> 08:57:41.264424 IP managed.unixy.net.49467 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: . ack 1 win 5840 08:57:41.318642 IP ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http > managed.unixy.net.49467: R 1288073905:1288073905(0) win 16384 The Reset packet sent from the EC2 node to the initiating node is a probe to identified non-existent nodes (spoofed). Notice in the above handshake that the initiating node didn't send a packet-response to the Reset. On the second consecutive attempt though all appears well (because the EC2 node added the initiating node to the ACL). 08:57:42.961708 IP managed.unixy.net.49468 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: S 1394481180:1394481180(0) win 5840 <mss 1460,sackOK,timestamp 2031832989 0,nop,wscale 7> 08:57:43.016547 IP ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http > managed.unixy.net.49468: S 1406181195:1406181195(0) ack 1394481181 win 5792 <mss 1460,sackOK,timestamp 26523835 2031832989,nop,wscale 3> 08:57:43.016564 IP managed.unixy.net.49468 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: . ack 1 win 46 <nop,nop,timestamp 2031833002 26523835> 08:57:51.100914 IP managed.unixy.net.49468 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: P 1:18(17) ack 1 win 46 <nop,nop,timestamp 2031835023 26523835> 08:57:51.180674 IP ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http > managed.unixy.net.49468: . ack 18 win 724 <nop,nop,timestamp 26525876 2031835023> 08:57:56.206546 IP managed.unixy.net.49468 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: P 18:39(21) ack 1 win 46 <nop,nop,timestamp 2031836300 26525876> 08:57:56.261630 IP ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http > managed.unixy.net.49468: . ack 39 win 724 <nop,nop,timestamp 26527146 2031836300> 08:57:56.678942 IP managed.unixy.net.49468 > ec2-184-72-37-90.us-west-1.compute.amazonaws.com.http: P 39:41(2) ack 1 win 46 <nop,nop,timestamp 2031836418 26527146> But I wonder just how long they'll be able to evade the attack. Regards
- JoachimSchipper 16y ago
- mwg66 16y agoShouldn't we really be trying to get to the bottom of who is behind this DDoS attack? If Wikileaks is said to be a terrorist organisation, isn't this an act of war?
- jamesaguilar 16y agoI am curious who wants to attack Wikileaks and for what purpose. I think it's unlikely this is the USG because of the sheer pointlessness of it, plus the fallout that would occur if it were discovered. The likeliest major player I can think of is China, but I'm not sure I have a reason for that belief other than that they are the bogeyman du jour. An alternate possibility is that this is just some cracker flexing his muscle, or showing a potential client what he can do.
- burgerbrain 16y agoShear pointlessness has not been preventing thr USG from doing much of anything in the past decade or so. Or did you miss the past few years of security theatre and unwinnable wars?
- jamesaguilar 16y agoAre you actually trying to argue with me, or just taking a potshot at the USG? If the latter, please use someone else's comment as a platform and not mine. If the former . . . Sheer pointlessness is meant to encompass several reasons I believe the USG is an unlikely culprit. First, there's the risk of significant consequences if the USG's involvement comes to public light. There's another election in two years, so even the PR damage could cost them. Then there's the matter of this kind of action being illegal. Maybe no prosecution would occur, but maybe it would. Second, unlike your security theater example, there is literally zero chance of this doing any good for anyone. Every person who is even the least bit interested could obtain the documents with only minor effort considering how widely they have been distributed. Major news organizations have already collated them for the masses. On the other hand, "security theater" and "unwinnable wars" are only pointless in a debatable sense. There are obviously a large number of people who believe that airport security measures are having some positive effect. Similarly, by some metrics (not mine), the war in Iraq has been successful and the war in Afghanistan is heading in that direction too. I don't doubt in hindsight that they will prove to be mistakes, but that is not the same as their having a absolutely known "pointlessness" value now. So I think that objection of yours is incorrect as well. Also, you've only pointed out two pointless things the USG has done in the past decade. That's not the same as proving that the USG is equally inclined to do pointless things as pointful ones. In fact, it may be that the USG discards pointless courses of action at a much higher rate than pointful ones, but that certain pointless actions have been enacted nonetheless. In this case, it would still be predictive of the US not being involved that the Wikileaks DOS is pointless. Finally, I'm not aware that it is the USG's standard infosec policy to maintain batteries of compromised civilian computers with which to perform cyber warfare. Perhaps it is, but that would be quite a discovery in and of itself. So, there are a lot of problems with your line of reasoning. I could be wrong, but I think the odds are something like 80-20 that I am right and this is not the USG's doing.
- Garbage 16y agoI think after some days, WikiLeaks will publish documents using torrents. That way they can avoid (at least) DDoS.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoThey are already doing that. Not much good if people can't get to the .torrent file. (Yes, I know about DHT and that you can just mirror .torrent files. It's still inconvenient enough that most won't bother.)
- dtf 16y agoUnfortunately, once the big guns of the media and those opportunists in government find out, Amazon will be forced to make a statement one way or another. Do they support this kind of thing or not? I can even imagine calls for a boycott from some sectors - not a great thing for Amazon at this time of year.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- eru 16y agoEverything that embiggens this story is good news for Wikileaks. And Amazon taking a stance would be something big.
- piers888 16y agoOoh, gee, you don't think it could be Hilary directing it do ya? Or maybe the Chinese government. Pissed that they confirmed China is considering dumping Nth Korea? Lol!
- ars 16y agoDoesn't hosting with Amazon create a money trail? If the US were to prosecute them, they could subpoena Amazon, and find more members of the organization. Assange is knowingly putting himself in the line of fire, but isn't there a goal to make sure other members of wikileaks stay anonymous?
- sigzero 16y agoWhy should other members be anonymous? Isn't that hypocritical since Wikileaks is all about transparency?
- TallGuyShort 16y agoIt's also all about protecting whistle blowers. They've put a lot of thought into ways of covering the tracks of people who come to them to keep them safe - I don't think it's hypocritical. They're concerned for their safety, not their politics.
- metageek 16y agoIronically, Clinton expressed similar concerns about Wikileaks exposing people who speak privately to diplomats.
- chaostheory 16y agoThey asked the US gov to redact any sensitive sources. They didn't get any help. http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/08/20/wikileaks http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/08/20...
- metageek 16y agoPossibly because that would tell Wikileaks what they thought was sensitive.
- JoachimSchipper 16y ago
- known 16y agohttp://geo.flagfox.net/?search=wikileaks.org http://geo.flagfox.net/?search=wikileaks.org
- ajays 16y agoALL the more reason why Assange should stop prancing around like a f*ing queen and just release the entire trove in one big torrent. By dishing out the documents slowly (their own FAQ claims they'll release the docs over a period of months to maximize exposure), he's setting himself up for such attacks. They can always release their analysis and interesting findings later.
- o_nate 16y agoAccording to this, Wikileaks is no longer available on Amazon either: http://online.wsj.com/article/AP90b4520b2a9b455ea6e9d8d66fae1fec.html http://online.wsj.com/article/AP90b4520b2a9b455ea6e9d8d66fae...
- to 16y agohttp://e.businessinsider.com/nbl.2e8/TPa_4qqdbcEdB9HKA8022 http://e.businessinsider.com/nbl.2e8/TPa_4qqdbcEdB9HKA8022 there it is - i called it! http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1957189 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1957189