4 ms·
It is an open secret that you can click on a post's age to open a comment and reply immediately to avoid the cool down periods. I am not suggesting that remote
by slg 8y ago
It is an open secret that you can click on a post's age to open a comment and reply immediately to avoid the cool down periods.
I am not suggesting that remote potential outcomes should be ignored (which is what probably happened in your two examples). I am suggesting that remote outcomes should be kept in perspective.
Let's make numbers up for that second example. Let's say that the pipeline is guaranteed to generate $1 billion over its lifetime but has a .1% chance of failure that causes $10 billion in damage. Some people might view that $10 billion potential damage as disqualifying. However if you do the multiplication the expected negative value is only $10 million. Therefore the expected value of the pipeline is $990 million and the pipeline is probably still a good idea (I admit I am oversimplifying this issue). This is the same reason why a nuclear power plant is generally a better option over a coal plant even though the nuclear plant has the chance of a much greater catastrophic failure.
There is also always the question of who receives the positive and negative value. The census example was good because the positive and negative values both impact the general population. The Google/Facebook and Nigeria examples are a little different because the people bearing the brunt of the negative value likely don't benefit as much from the positive value as they should. That distorts incentives in a different way, but that is another debate entirely.