4 ms·
I just recently argued this on HN, but this is a bad example because it ends up vilifying the census takers as if they were complicit in the crimes of the Nazis
by slg 8y ago
I just recently argued this on HN, but this is a bad example because it ends up vilifying the census takers as if they were complicit in the crimes of the Nazis. Censuses are a hugely important part of the basic infrastructure of democracy and knowing the size and makeup of the citizenry is paramount to serving the needs of that citizenry. The remote possibility that this information can eventually be used by a totalitarian regime shouldn't be the sole reason that this information isn't collected. Instead there should be an assessment done on whether the value of having that information outweighs that potentially remote downside. I think the census is one area in which that is the case.
Blaming the census for assisting in the Nazis crimes would be like blaming the transportation infrastructure. Sure, it made things easier, but no one in the US would ever suggest we get rid of the interstate highway system because "What happens if Nazis take over the US?"
- nostrademons 8y agoIronically, the interstate highway system exists because it was useful to the Nazis. Eisenhower authorized its construction because as a general in Europe, he saw firsthand how useful the German road network was in quickly deploying troops to wherever they were needed.
- slg 8y agoI realize that and that was partially my point. No one worries about the interstate highway system falling into the wrong hands even though it is much more linked to military power than the census. So why do we worry about the census falling into the wrong hands?
- zepearl 8y agoOk, I can agree with this :)
- chalst 8y agoInteresting. Deutsche Welle has a nice piece on how the Nazis made only limited and fitful progress in developing the existing Autobahn network: https://www.dw.com/en/the-myth-of-hitlers-role-in-building-the-autobahn/a-16144981 https://www.dw.com/en/the-myth-of-hitlers-role-in-building-t...
- zepearl 8y agoA documentary on one of the german channels said the same some months ago... .
- zepearl 8y agoWell, I think that you're wrong because you're focusing only on the "census" area - this reflects in my opinion the typical "black or white"-tendencies/extremes or today's times. I was trying to post a simple example - the event mentioned by the article is not the only occurrence and I guess that city halls had as well records about e.g. votes (which would relate a person to a specific party/movement/way-of-thinking), which would not be related directly to census but which had to be destructed as well. I do not blame the census (and I agree that the pros of census overweight the cons). It's just that the infos that we can release today are not gathered and administered by the national-census-authority and that the their detail go in some areas well beyond what the census would gather.
- slg 8y agoI was speaking about the census because that was your example, but the concept applies to all data. To be as general as possible, people focus too much on the negative value of data without considering the positive value. If the positive value is definite and the negative value is remote, we shouldn't let the existence of that negative value prevent us from receiving the positive value.
- zepearl 8y ago(wow, I just had one of those "cooldown-enforced"-moments here on YC that did not provide the "reply"-link...) > people focus too much on the negative value of data without considering the positive value. If the positive value is definite and the negative value is remote, we shouldn't let the existence of that negative value prevent us from receiving the positive value. Mmmhhh, I have personally the opposite feeling (people focus too much on the positive side of data/app and underestimate the negative side, which is how Facebook & Google & others can continue to thrive). > If the positive value is definite and the negative value is remote, we shouldn't let the existence of that negative value prevent us from receiving the positive value. E.g. those poor people in Nigeria definitely got a definite positive value while actively sucking oil from the ruptured pipeline, ignoring negative remote outcome (of blowing up), until it blew up. I cannot ignore remote potential outcomes... .
- dorgo 8y ago> Censuses are a hugely important part of the basic infrastructure of democracy and knowing the size and makeup of the citizenry is paramount to serving the needs of that citizenry Censuses should know much about population without knowing anything about a specific citizen. X% of population are yews, but is Jon Smith a jew?
- ucaetano 8y ago> Censuses should know much about population without knowing anything about a specific citizen. X% of population are yews, but is Jon Smith a jew? That's one of the reasons many countries are abolishing traditional censuses in favor of rolling surveys.