3 ms·
> When social order collapses, for instance due to a natural disaster, we turn to some pretty nasty behavior quite quickly even when it's in no way necessary.
by pessimizer 8y ago
> When social order collapses, for instance due to a natural disaster, we turn to some pretty nasty behavior quite quickly even when it's in no way necessary.
Only in misanthropist fiction and television shows. When social order collapses in real life previously equal people organize, cooperate, and protect the weak.
That being said, if there's some extreme social stratification in the group already, and there was previously a wider authority explicitly restraining the more powerful group from completely enslaving the weak group, of course that would change if the wider authority were eliminated.
During the flooding of New Orleans, the footage exemplifying "nasty behavior" broadcast on television were generally starving people looting grocery stores, cold, wet people foraging for clothing, blankets and bedding, or at the worst (and rarest) impoverished people looking for things they might be able to sell. The really scary thing was how police, both alone and as hastily-assembled white citizens' councils, started looting the town and threatening and killing flood survivors with impunity, and how the media cheered them on with a narrative of "nasty behavior."
Almost the entire source of nasty behavior in the case of that disaster was from people who were completely secure - the New Orleans police, police in nearby towns, and the national media.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_Hurricane_Katrina_in_New_Orleans#Civil_disturbances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_Hurricane_Katrina_i...
> Civil disturbances in post-Hurricane Katrina were consistent with all existing research on disaster sociology, which concludes that “[post-disaster] widespread looting [is] a myth”,[51] and were vastly overstated by the media, ultimately fueling a climate of suspicion and paranoia which greatly hampered rescue efforts and further worsened the conditions of the survivors.[52]
> Some initial reports of mass chaos, particularly in stories about the Superdome, were later found to be exaggerated or rumor.[53] In the Superdome for example, the New Orleans sex crimes unit investigated every report of rape or atrocity and found only two verifiable incidents, both of sexual assault. The department head told reporters, "I think it was an urban myth. Any time you put 25,000 people under one roof, with no running water, no electricity and no information, stories get told." Based on these reports, government officials expected hundreds of dead to be found in the Superdome, but instead found only six dead: four natural deaths, one drug overdose, and one suicide.[43][54] In a case of reported sniper fire, the "sniper" turned out to be the relief valve of a gas tank popping every few minutes.[53]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danziger_Bridge_shootings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danziger_Bridge_shootings
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Henry_Glover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Henry_Glover
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretna,_Louisiana#Hurricane_Katrina_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretna,_Louisiana#Hurricane_Ka...
- rjf72 8y agoI'm not referring to any incident in particular. This is a regular pattern. One problem is that conclusive data collection is lacking and suffers from severe underreporting. For instance NPR was able to find more victims of sexual violence following Katrina than the entirety of the officially reported figures. [1] But there have been some efforts at collating what studies do exist. Citing a study that carried out an overview of available evidence (across various disasters - this is not unique to Katrina) [2] : "The literature review also highlight that there are only a few studies, which focus on the relation between being exposed to a natural disaster and the rates of interpersonal violence.[16] The results of these studies reveal that being exposed to natural disasters such as tsunami, hurricane, earthquake, and flood increases the violence against women and girls, e.g., rape and sexual abuse,[39,40,41] intimate partner violence,[32,42,43,44] child PTSD,[45] child abuse,[46,47] and inflicted traumatic brain injury.[48]" Significant increases in nasty behavior is not mutually exclusive with other people aiming to work together. And is in fact rather significant evidence of the stated hypothesis demonstrating the varying calculus between groups. Its people all simply doing what they feel is in their best interest. And cooperation, often for personal protection, emerges directly from this. --- As one aside, I completely and absolutely respect that you cited your comments. Not enough people do this, others don't even concern themselves with evidence. But one point I would make is that Wiki tends to have issues with impartiality on issues that have political undertones, are relatively recent, or deal with social issues. And in this case you hit 3 quite hard. This makes Wiki a particularly unreliable source for topics such as this. As one very overt example, the Wiki page on effects of Katrina repeatedly implies official figures on rape incidents are accurate and representative of what actually happened. That is in spite of the fact that the same official behind said reporting acknowledging, "I admit that rapes are underreported. I know more sexual assaults took place." [1] - https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5063796 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=506379... [2] - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3908534/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3908534/