3 ms·
If someone sees wild berries growing next to the road and takes some, are they stealing? Perhaps technically yes, but not rising to a level where invoking the c
by mindslight 8y ago
If someone sees wild berries growing next to the road and takes some, are they stealing? Perhaps technically yes, but not rising to a level where invoking the concept is worthwhile. If enough people do this that it bothers the owner so they put up a sign, only then does that paradigm start to matter.
We're in this small-scale realm when talking about access_logs and friends' lunch routes. For the hotdog vendor scenario, we've developed informal social ways of dealing with this that don't revolve around fundamentalist-style ownership and access control. "Hey, I just saw your friend! He was headed to the park" vs "That other guy is always inviting himself to lunch with me and I really just want to read, so if he comes asking can you pretend I wasn't here" (which is only necessary if the "friend" hasn't responded to the first round of social hints to stop inviting himself to your lunch).
But the small scale is not what we're talking about! In the berries analogy, what Google et al are doing is each sending around a crew at night to harvest a few "free" berries from each bush. Many bush owners put up signs (Do not track), but the companies keep right on harvesting under a theory that they're just doing the same thing as a hungry person taking berries for personal consumption.
But the total revenue and business model of the companies paint a much different picture. And that's what we're dealing with here - something that on a small scale appears worthless, but in aggregate is quite valuable. In fact, that's basically just the fundamental thesis of "big data". Myopically focusing on each individual fact in isolation is simply not an appropriate way to analyze society-level surveillance.