4 ms·
So, the subtitle of this article is "The gender wage gap is really a child care penalty." But why is it seemed a "penalty"? People choose to do different things
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
So, the subtitle of this article is "The gender wage gap is really a child care penalty." But why is it seemed a "penalty"? People choose to do different things, and it seems quite normal to me that people who choose to take focus off of their work to focus on their family would end up in lower positions than people who stayed focused on their careers.
- Cenk 8y agoYes — but as you can very clearly see from the chart, only women’s earning drop significantly after a child. Men’s do not.
- treis 8y agoOnly women, generally, go through pregnancy and take significant time off of work to raise children.
- repolfx 8y agoIt's amazing that such an obvious statement has to be said! The title of the article is like something out of a comedy: it's "stunning" that people who drop out of work for a while earn less, and that more women than men drop out of work because of childcare? How many people on the street would really be stunned to "learn" that? It's the basics of how the species has always reproduced itself.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYes, I understand that, but I think a reasonable interpretation of that is "The person who provides the bulk of the childcare (i.e. the person who switches focus most from work to family) is the person whose income potential takes the hit." Now, I think it is a very reasonable and worthwhile discussion to have about whether women are unfairly expected to be the primary child caregivers in a relationship (though I still would worry that any natural tendencies that women may have a stronger desire to raise children than men would instantly be derided as some sort of societal bias in today's climate), but it still means that's the thing you should focus on, instead of the unrealistic expectation that focusing on your family instead of your career somehow means your wages should be the same as someone only focused on their career.
- michelledepeil 8y agoYes, but there is an implied preference by companies to have more focus on work and less on private life, which is why it's also an implied penalty for the inverse (= having kids as a woman). And the unfairness here is that only women are physically capable of putting children on the earth, so the penalty is applied to only women, even though both men and women are parents.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> so the penalty is applied to only women I don't think the data necessarily shows that. I would hypothesize that the penalty is applied to the person in the relationship who most switches focus to raising their children, which is currently most often the woman. > And the unfairness here is that only women are physically capable of putting children on the earth Well, yes, that is unfair, but blame God (or evolution) then?
- deogeo 8y agoBecause work is being sold as something you get to do, while raising children as something you have to do.
- ramphastidae 8y agoIs it really? From my perspective it's easily the other way around. Having a job is a necessity while having a child is a luxury.