8 ms·
I'd say the primary problem with this argument on its own terms is that one of the natural questions to ask is "OK, then, how much are these companies stealing
by jerf 8y ago
I'd say the primary problem with this argument on its own terms is that one of the natural questions to ask is "OK, then, how much are these companies stealing from me?" and the answer is roughly "At the upper end, probably on the order of $10/month". That's going to be hard to build a social movement around. I could argue that if we were being paid a fair price, it would be worth more, but that's a chicken & egg problem; until we have such a free market, we can't really know what will happen with enough confidence to make a strong argument that we need a market of some sort.
The real problem with all this surveillance isn't the direct impact to me, it's the impact to society. It merely turns it into a sick joke that my social order is being upended and social contracts rewritten for an amount of money I'd happily hand to them to just... not. (I mean, that has it's own issues if it actually came to be, but in its current form, yes, I'd happily pay $10/month in hard cash for them to just leave me entirely alone.)
In the long term, I'm much more concerned about the fact that knowledge is power. I don't particularly look forward to the era of "SELECT name, current_location FROM citizens WHERE dissidence_level >= .6 ORDER BY dissidence_level DESC". But until that happens, to a much greater extent than it has, and it visibly manifests in the real world, it's going to be hard to get people to care, until it happens and it's too late.
What really scares me is idea that the reason why it hasn't happened yet is precisely that the people who want to do that are deliberately waiting until it would be too late.
- floe 8y agoYes, you hit the nail on the head! The societal impacts have to be considered. If you rely on each person to rationally decide whether or not to sell 'their own' data, you'll have a tragedy of the commons situation. Maybe we will see a health insurance company that costs half as much as the rest, but to apply you have to give them all your social data and they run "CREATE TABLE rejected_applicants AS SELECT name, id FROM insurance_applicants WHERE health_risk_level >= .7". All the healthy people will rationally sell their data and try to join this company, and all the other companies will have sicker pools and have to double their prices. For a person who couldn't get accepted into the cheaper company, the fact that they can sell their own data is cold comfort. Privacy harms will always fall disproportionately on the marginalized: the poor, the sick, dissidents, and minorities. The framework of 'data ownership' can never make these harms right because it fails to recognize that half the people selling their data often hurts the other half.
- scarejunba 8y agoEnough with the paternalism. Let me use my data as I see fit. It's mine. Not yours. Stop putting limits on it. If I want to trade my information for money I should be allowed to. The problem with you guys is not that your ultimate goal isn't data ownership. The problem with you is that your ultimate goal is that you own and control everyone's data. You want to make the rules as to what they can do with it.
- jerf 8y agoAre you using your data as you see fit? By your own choice? Even if the first answer was "yes" (and, to be honest, it still isn't; if you had control I virtually guarantee that you would choose to change something about how it is distributed), this answer is certainly "no". You're not choosing right now. You're having done to you. If you want to complain about people making choices about what to do with your data, I can't fathom why you'd file that complaint against someone who wants to give you vastly more control than you have now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 8y agoWhat do you mean? Sure, currently personal data is being used without much control by the person. But the GP is not proposing more control, they're saying people should still not have choice, as that may harm the marginalized.
- floe 8y agoI'm not saying that people shouldn't have the choice whether or not to sell their data - I'm saying that even if they have that choice, it doesn't prevent many society-wide harms. (Edit: Which implies that we do need to restrict some uses of large datasets that would cause these harms.) I'm not sure how you would characterize my position in terms of increasing or decreasing 'control' or 'choice' - I find those terms tricky to apply in this case, so I prefer to apply concrete concepts like 'harm'.
- zepearl 8y ago> * I don't particularly look forward to the era of "SELECT name, current_location FROM citizens WHERE dissidence_level >= .6 ORDER BY dissidence_level DESC". But until that happens...* Well, that kind of already happened at least during WWII when e.g. documents had to be burned in city halls to avoid that they would fall into the German's hands, e.g.: On 27 March 1943, a cell of the Dutch resistance committed an attack on the municipal register of Amsterdam. The German occupier had found this register to be extremely convenient: it contained the details of 70.000 Jews in Amsterdam. Also, it proved useful as a means of cross-checking information on identity cards. https://medium.com/@hansdezwart/during-world-war-ii-we-did-have-something-to-hide-40689565c550 https://medium.com/@hansdezwart/during-world-war-ii-we-did-h... But apparently people have forgotten this or did not abstract/expand such events to apply them to current tech (but I was reminded about this by my father, who is german [now some DB will store that zepearl's father is german, damn...], when I was having a discussion about Facebook with him many years ago). The Yugoslavian (ethnical) conflict was too early from a technological point of view, but more recently, for Erdogan (Turkey) having access to a local company (DB) that tracked preferences/relationships/commentaries of a majority of its population would have been pure gold to identify people against him, puah.
- slg 8y agoI just recently argued this on HN, but this is a bad example because it ends up vilifying the census takers as if they were complicit in the crimes of the Nazis. Censuses are a hugely important part of the basic infrastructure of democracy and knowing the size and makeup of the citizenry is paramount to serving the needs of that citizenry. The remote possibility that this information can eventually be used by a totalitarian regime shouldn't be the sole reason that this information isn't collected. Instead there should be an assessment done on whether the value of having that information outweighs that potentially remote downside. I think the census is one area in which that is the case. Blaming the census for assisting in the Nazis crimes would be like blaming the transportation infrastructure. Sure, it made things easier, but no one in the US would ever suggest we get rid of the interstate highway system because "What happens if Nazis take over the US?"
- 8y ago
- kaxline 8y agoYou bring up some good points and I don't have an answer for how data ownership would affect every industry or product category. On the $10/month figure, I would point out that this is likely per data silo. So Facebook's data on you may be around $10/month, but also Google's, which is a different data set. And so on. It's not much money now because it's only available to advertisers who want to buy ads on a specific platform. If you owned and controlled your data, you may have 100 different buyers at $10/mo, ranging from medical researchers to product marketers, which starts adding up. I don't have figures to back this up, but my intuition is that all the data we've been creating for decades will only have more and more value as we try to feed our machine learning algorithms with more data, to get more insights.
- m463 8y agoBut your two points are connected. You're valuing your privacy at $10/month? But what if critical information about you is used to get you to pay more for your next airline ticket? Or more for your next car? Or your next house? Or in a different fashion, what if it prevents you from seeing a job for younger people, or prevents you from getting an insurance or credit card offer that other people see? (this is the more likely scenario) This isn't your government checking to see if you're a dissident, but you're being sort of imprisoned in a different way. Not that the dissident thing can't happen, but nobody in the US will care because they've never lived under a change of government. The europeans are more concerned about privacy, because some of them HAVE witnessed a change of government.