17 ms·
I'm not disagreeing with any of this. But I think there's additional perspective to be had. I see a lot of conversation about early Internet and the health of
by Waterluvian 8y ago
I'm not disagreeing with any of this. But I think there's additional perspective to be had.
I see a lot of conversation about early Internet and the health of the Internet. I think some of this is just because those of us who remember it, are starting to ache over it a bit for all kinds of reasons, one of which is because that's what old people do.
Today I got lunch with my 17 year old nephew. I asked him about what he does on the Internet and if he misses the "old Internet". First off, he has no context of what the old Internet is. He doesn't really care nor seem to feel like he's missing out. Second, he showed me what he mainly does. Basically it was a handful of group chats via Signal and WhatsApp, a whole bunch of web comic websites, and some YouTube series.
I felt like a dad of a teenager for a fleeting moment and my generalized conclusion was that he's consuming a ton of independently developed creative content. I was actually pretty proud of what the Internet looks like for him.
I asked him about curation and the ability to hold on to his favourites. How does he ensure that something he loves isn't gone in 10 years? This concept really didn't seem to matter to him. His perspective seemed to be that there's so many webcomics and the "memes" and conversations he has with his friends are ever evolving, there's not really a lot of time to care about the old stuff. Made me wonder if attachment to nostalgia may be fleeting as well.
Is this the full story? Of course not. But it made me feel a bit better about things and a bit more skeptical of the doomsaying I often hear and sometimes take part in.
- ghaff 8y agoConsider instead of YouTube though broadcast TV in the old days. If you were sitting in front of the TV at the right time, you could watch the latest episode of Star Trek. (OK. I'm dating myself. Work with me here.) You might have been aware that repeats would probably air on some unknown schedule some day. But, really, maybe you'd never be able to watch that particular show again.
- darksaints 8y agoAnd because of it, entire television writing styles have changed, morphing into strong season-long narratives instead of loosely related miniplots. Before, writers always had to take into account the fact that a viewer may not have seen the previous episode, or even any episodes at all. I much prefer what TV has become, to the point where I now prefer the medium over feature length films...something I never would have expected 20 years ago.
- ghaff 8y agoIn all fairness, only some TV is like that and TBH I have a pretty limited appetite for highly-serialized complex shows that require a lot of attention and focus. The ones I like I really like. They're just not a daily diet for me. The were miniseries back in the day. But they were an exception that required really driving a big audience to TV on a schedule.
- nicoburns 8y ago> The ones I like I really like. They're just not a daily diet for me. When I watch TV, it's the complex shows, but I don't watch anything daily...
- monetus 8y agoDid you break your addiction, or just never develop one?
- derekp7 8y agoI can answer for my own situation -- I broke my addiction when I started attending a couple night classes at local community college in the late 80's / early 90's. Then I started hanging out with friends at places on thursday / friday nights, and realized that I really didn't miss the new fall seasons.
- nicoburns 8y agoI used to watch TV a bit when I still lived with my parents. I've never owned one since. I watch shows online when I want to, but there's no "just put the telly on" function. Makes it pretty easy...
- ghaff 8y agoFrom my perspective upthread, when I wrote day to day I didn't actually mean that literally. I guess I've never really had an addiction. I've never been one to turn on the TV as background. I did used to watch more than I do now but it was still maybe 1 hr. a day on average.
- a1369209993 8y agoThat's what VCRs were for. (Today it's what youtube-dl, wget, etc are for.)
- Rebelgecko 8y agoUnfortunately a lot of old TV shows were still lost. It can be similarly difficult to find old youtube videos that aren't there anymore. It can take some archeology on archive.org to find a working copy of a video.
- CamperBob2 8y agoGood example of this: a channel I subscribe to was recently banned from YouTube for no apparent reason, at least according to its proprietor (Jeff Quitney): https://twitter.com/quickfoundnet/status/1109314006919970816 https://twitter.com/quickfoundnet/status/1109314006919970816 This channel was a treasury of carefully-curated public-domain films from the 1930s onward, many of them restored by Quitney. Most of the films were originally for government and military training purposes. If you needed to know how to do a preflight check on a B-29, or if you wanted to catch up on Armed Forces Network newsreels from Korea, this was a good place to look. Neither copyright nor content issues should have been a problem as far as I can imagine, yet one day a couple of weeks ago Google dropped the axe. No appeal, no redress, and no way forward, since the channel wasn't popular enough to generate a big stink on social media. As far as I can tell, leaving Google in charge of this stuff is like inviting Great White to play at the Library of Alexandria.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoCan't say I'm surprised. I've had public domain videos on my channel taken down for copyright issues. All it takes is one jerk to spam takedown requests.
- sigstoat 8y agothere were a lot of years between the introduction of TV, and betamax.
- 8y ago
- JohnBooty 8y agoOh my god, this. There was a cartoon on air when I was young (Star Blazers) and it used a fully serial format. There were about 52 episodes, but I could only watch them in the summer because of conflict with school time. I knew when my favorite episodes were coming and it was really rough to miss one. Generally I had to wait until the next year to see it, which is effectively forever when you're like seven years old. VCRs existed, of course, but were far from ubiquitous in the early 80s. They were still sort of a rich person toy at that point. Home video was expensive. Late 80s, early 90s is when video rental joints and cheap VCRs flourished and at that point you pretty much could assume every home had one.
- jamesgeck0 8y agoIts early use of the serial format is one of the big reasons Star Blazers is still a notable anime. That, and the excellent remake _Star Blazers: Space Battleship Yamato 2199_.
- JohnBooty 8y agoYeah, that looks pretty good! I've been "saving" it, so to speak - I'll watch it someday as a treat. =) By the way, I met Amy Howard (American voice of Yuki/Nova) some years ago and she's a very sweet and friendly lady. Also shared an airport shuttle with Ken Messerol (Kodai/Wildstar) and said hello, but declined to pester him beyond that out of respect. Didn't want to bug him.
- the_af 8y agoNot caring about the future is something a 17 year old would do. Not worrying about whether the stuff he loves now will endure tomorrow is typical of that age. He simply hasn't lived long enough and matured enough to feel nostalgic about stuff. I promise you he will miss things when he's 30 or 40. I think this reflects more on teenagers and grownups than on the internet :) > His perspective seemed to be that there's so many webcomics and the "memes" and conversations he has with his friends are ever evolving, there's not really a lot of time to care about the old stuff. He's missing on old stuff like Calvin & Hobbes, to name just one example.
- magic_beans 8y ago> He's missing on old stuff like Calvin & Hobbes, to name just one example. And what new stuff are you missing out on? Everyone is always missing out on something. It's no great crime.
- the_af 8y agoAgreed that it's no great crime. And of course, I'm missing out on all kinds of stuff. Not because I'm too busy with ever evolving memes to pay attention, I hope. The mentality that only today matters, that the past is old and boring, that only the "ever evolving" should grasp your attention, and that who cares if what interests you today will exist tomorrow is distinctly a teenager's mentality. It's something adults usually -- but not always, of course -- grow out of. This is no criticism, by the way. It's ok that teenagers think and feel this way. It's also expected that they grow out of it as they mature and become adults.
- magic_beans 8y agoYou missed the point. I'm not saying that the past is old and boring, or that teenagers even believe it is (not all of them do!). I'm saying that every generation produces outstanding media and art (somewhere among the clutter), and that it's ridiculous for older people or younger people to dismiss the art that does not belong to their generation.
- ljm 8y agoI've seen this play out outside of the internet too, in a way that didn't immediately connect with nostalgia. There's often a time where a startup takes investment and then ramps up the hiring. They take on more people, move to a brand new office, and start adding in things to help deal with the sudden scaling. This will push many of the early employees away or at least contribute to a feeling that they're no longer working for the same company. Meanwhile, all of the new hires are coming in and they've only seen the sparkly new office and the adjusted culture, and they love it! They have no notion of what the business was like when it was smaller and more intimate. I remind myself of this when I start comparing the present to the past, because I feel like that longing for what once was is a source of great misery if you leave it unchecked. Things might actually be better, yet still you yearn for the old and the familiar.
- JohnBooty 8y agoEven moreso than "caring about preserving content for the future" versus "not caring about it" there's another interesting perspective shift here. Second, he showed me what he mainly does. Basically it was a handful of group chats via Signal and WhatsApp, a whole bunch of web comic websites, and some YouTube series. The "early internet" was in part based around those lofty ideas baked into the original World Wide Web: a giant, ever-growing hyperlinked network of information. It wasn't just a way to communicate; you were contributing to something larger than yourself. Even if you merely made blog posts about your favorite breakfast cereals, you felt as though you were adding to this public, global network of knowledge. Everything on the web was public by default. And even if your content was bad, or simply banal, you were still doing something positive by adding to this giant mass of information. Bad or banal content wasn't inherently a problem, because others would simply choose not to link to it. Maybe somebody would find your cereal musings useful some day and if not, no harm done. Now, for better or worse, people view the internet "only" as a publishing and/or communication and/or shopping tool. Nothing wrong with that but it is definitely a paradigm shift back to something a little less ambitious than we aimed for in the 90s.
- username223 8y agoWhen I look at the camera-equipped billboard we've created in its place, I miss the pre-commercial internet. Thanks for reminding me that we hoped for something better.
- icedchai 8y agoI wish I had kept my Amiga, hard drive, and all my floppies from that age. I sold it for what is now a pittance, compared to the sentimental value.
- Kenji 8y ago> I think some of this is just because those of us who remember it, are starting to ache over it a bit for all kinds of reasons, one of which is because that's what old people do. Bullshit. Don't you ever dismiss serious concerns as nostalgia and old man worries. I remember the old internet. The old internet NEVER told me that I cannot watch content because I'm in Europe. The old internet NEVER told me that this video was taken down due to a DMCA/(insert your favourite copyright law here) claim. The old internet NEVER told me that the content is not available in my country. The old internet NEVER imposed DNS blocking on me. The old internet NEVER forced me to enter my phone number. The old internet NEVER made me solve arcane google CAPTCHAS that could not be solved by god himself. The old internet NEVER broke when I deactivated JavaScript. The old internet NEVER had cookie or GDPR banners. I could go on. Don't you dare dismiss that the web got worse in many ways.