3 ms·
Genuine Question: Does this thought process of summarizing the shenanigans we see in the world from entities like FB not serve to drive home a quick idea, witho
by samstave 8y ago
Genuine Question: Does this thought process of summarizing the shenanigans we see in the world from entities like FB not serve to drive home a quick idea, without having to read pages and pages of text to get the point across not have a place.
I have been on HN for more than a decade. I tire of the higher-than-thou bullshit where a dialog of context for various subjects is shunned from some taboo on delivery of the premise.
So I reject your position.
Would you like me to cite things that I know personally about FB, or cite every single compacted reference made in that comment at great length so you can feel superior in your understanding that you may not have?
I mean -- FFS - understand that there are people who want to make a condensed comment on shit that happens in the tech field but I don't want to write a diatribe wit ha bibliography on why "because screw, them, that's why" is a salient summary.
(See: on HN "google deep-sixes usenet" on FP today)
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoWith FB in particular, many HN denizens owe much of their wealth to the company either directly or indirectly (through acquisitions, seed capital from former employees, etc), so many of the criticisms that point to Zuckerberg in specific are frowned upon. In short, "don't bite the hand that feeds you"
- rootusrootus 8y agoI don't see that too much, to be honest. If there is any sort of corporate love here, it feels more like it's Google that enjoys it, not Facebook.
- Loughla 8y agoYeah - there are many comments about Facebook's lack of ethics on this site. I'm betting more than any other large tech company. Hell there was even a poster in a different facebook story talking about how it was fun to tell headhunters they refused to apply to facebook because of ethics.
- tsunamifury 8y agoI think the nuance is actually critically important, because degrading people -- even powerful ones -- down to caricatures robs us of the understanding we need to solve these problems.
- shawnz 8y agoExactly. If it were so obvious then we wouldn't be in this situation in the first place. There are reasons why things got to be this way and we have to understand them to progress.
- crististm 8y agoCaricatures do not rob you of anything. They emphasize grotesques or background features to the point of extracting them from invisibility.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- urNotImportant 8y agoTrying to hijack my attention just means I throw everything you say right into the garbage. I'm not even going to refer to you by name.
- frenchy 8y ago> Does this thought process of summarizing the shenanigans we see in the world from entities like FB not serve to drive home a quick idea, without having to read pages and pages of text to get the point across not have a place. Maybe for some people. I'm honestly not at all sure what you hoped to communicate with your previous post.
- camjohnson26 8y agoYour post has an extremely pretentious tone, use the words everyone else uses if you want to be clear. You don’t sound smart using words like salient or diatribe when the simple words can do the trick.