3 ms·
And by a similar token, it's totally reasonable to have a "must be viewable in a theatre" requirement, for the same reason. If you view going to a theatre essen
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
And by a similar token, it's totally reasonable to have a "must be viewable in a theatre" requirement, for the same reason. If you view going to a theatre essential to the experience of seeing a movie—even if it's an ephemeral opportunity—you should be able to set criteria based on that.
- jerf 8y agoI wouldn't agree that's a similar requirement to the one I laid out; a critical aspect of what I said is the ability to archive, and, at least officially, you can't archive a theater presentation. Unofficially, of course, we (for suitable values of "we") have a taxonomy of terms for the precise type of theater-based archiving one can do. But I'd like to make the archive requirement publicly-available.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoMy point is, in both cases, you're making a requirement based on what part of cinema you feel is important. You see "ability for the public to see this movie in X years" as important for cinema. Steven Spielberg sees "ability for the public to see this movie in a theatre" (at some point) as important for cinema. Both are valid criteria.
- cjhopman 8y agoThe rules already require that films are first publicly exhibited in a theatre, and so you are misrepresenting Spielberg's view. He, for some reason, doesn't want people to be able to see the movies on streaming services for some period after they are first shown in theatres. I don't quite understand the justification for wanted that though I have my guesses.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThis is true, insofar as (it seems to me) Spielberg is specifying the wrong criteria. However, if you believe that the theatre experience is critical to a film, I think it's also fair to be annoyed at what Netflix is doing. Only a select few have the ability to see Netflix's films in a theatre, because they're only released to a couple theatres in a handful of major cities.
- hrktb 8y agoI’d argue that the theatre limitation would be detrimental as it’s a entranched industry that has not been shown to be moving forward for a long time. Cannes’ festival makes it an actual requirement to be shown in theaters, and I think it discredit lot of the prestige that it had, now that truely excelent pieces are tv only or streaming only. All the more so, showing in theatres has legal ramifications that go beyond art and movie making.