3 ms·
The M4 tank is an underrated tank. It does have one major flaw: its main gun is undersized--but the tank crews themselves were saying "we don't want a bigger gu
by jcranmer 8y ago
The M4 tank is an underrated tank. It does have one major flaw: its main gun is undersized--but the tank crews themselves were saying "we don't want a bigger gun" when the tank was being designed, and no one realized the mistake until late 1944. It also excels in other areas, most notably reliability and survivability (it's incredibly easy to exit the tank in a jiffy if it's on fire, especially compared to German tanks). German tanks notably had a deficiency in reliability--they may look powerful on paper, but if a tank is spending half its time awaiting repairs, it's not contributing to your actual war effort.
- arethuza 8y agoThe British Sherman Firefly fixed that particular problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Firefly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Firefly
- mcv 8y agoIt wasn't a mistake. US tank doctrine was to use specialised tank destroyers against Tigers; the Shermans were there to support the main army. And a few Shermans had the more powerful 76mm guns which were better against Tigers. But the 75mm guns were fine against the vast majority of targets they were likely to encounter. Tigers were incredibly rare. The Brits did put a 17 pounder gun on the Sherman to create the Firefly, which was much more powerful, but also too large for the small turret of the Sherman, making it a cramped, uncomfortable and impractical tank. The basic Sherman was fine. Arguably the best tank of the war.