4 ms·
It's only a criminal offence if you do it as part of trade. If you distribute those photos but don't ask for money you're committing a civil offence, and the re
by DanBC 8y ago
It's only a criminal offence if you do it as part of trade. If you distribute those photos but don't ask for money you're committing a civil offence, and the remedy is that you get sued (not prosecuted) and have to pay for the losses, and pay for the costs of the court case.
If you sell the photographs you're now trading and that tips it into a criminal offence.
- nybble41 8y agoThat is how the law is phrased. However, as I understand it, people have successfully managed to argue that simply receiving a copy of the work as part of the infringement is sufficient "trade" on its own to qualify the infringement as a criminal offense. Under that interpretation there is no effective distinction between civil and criminal infringement.
- DanBC 8y agoPlease link to even a single case where that actually happened. You'll find that either people are monetizing the distribution; or they're distributing so much content the rights-holders claim it distorted the market. I'd agree that neither of these should be criminal offences, but neither of them involve "simply receiving a copy".
- nybble41 8y ago> or they're distributing so much content the rights-holders claim it distorted the market Sorry, I heard about the case years ago and don't have a link handy. However, that point by itself would be enough to undermine the original claim that only for-profit distribution is considered criminal.