4 ms·
>We've seen our internet rights to speech and expression violated by companies imposing their values on their user base. >Bitcoin et al. are a very real promis
by slg 8y ago
>We've seen our internet rights to speech and expression violated by companies imposing their values on their user base.
>Bitcoin et al. are a very real promise that the future of banking and finance and money will be decentralized. Which as far as I'm concerned, is about freedom as much as speech is. You don't have any freedom if you have to beg VISA or PayPal for permission to spend your money.
The moral high ground you are trying to claim in your second argument is undercut by your first argument. If this was all about freedom, we would see similar sized investments in open and decentralized platforms focused on free speech. The reason we aren't seeing that is obvious. It is much easier to see a path to profitability in the cryptocurrency space.
Most cryptocurrency investments aren't about freedom, they are about carving out a piece of the pie from the existing financial services industry. There is nothing immoral about turning a profit, just be open about it. It is dishonest for cryptocurrency investors to claim their intent is to save the world especially considering how much electricity and therefore fossil fuels some of the popular cryptocurrencies waste.
Sell the tech on its own merits and accomplishments. There is a reason why the "making the world a better place" pitches have been parodied for years.
- stale2002 8y ago> we would see similar sized investments in open and decentralized platforms focused on free speech This is already a mostly solved problem. There are lots and lots of places on the internet, when I can engage in speech and it won't be censored. Yes, the big platforms might censor you, but there are still lots and lots of small platforms that won't or can't.
- dd36 8y agoWhat free speech is he referring to? The only speech I know of that has been censored is terrorist groups. It makes me uncomfortable when I see people here complaining about that.
- gruez 8y agoDaily stormer and Alex Jones? ...unless you think they are terrorists.
- dd36 8y agoThe KKK certainly is a terrorist group. Alex Jones is being sued and whatever platforms don't stop him from spreading malicious lies could be liable as well.
- slg 8y agoSince you brought it up, I would generally agree with you and am not too concerned about free speech on the internet. More than just terrorist groups are being censored, but all of the speech that I have seen disenfranchised has been speech that is in my opinion objectionable in one way or another. A lot of people in the US don't seem to realize how extreme we are as a country when it comes to free speech. We fetishize free speech in a way that I feel is not healthy. I don't think any country's laws are perfect in this regard, but all the other western democracies seem to be just fine with their laws against things like hate speech. I don't see how the US allowing hate speech is beneficial to the country or its people. This opinion tends to be an unpopular on HN and I figured I would meet the original OP on their terms.
- turkeysandwich 8y agoWestern democracies with hate speech laws are less democratic because the range of legally permissible opinions is smaller. If mere functioning is your goal for the country, then certainly countries without strong free speech protections can function. They can even function without democracy at all. But most people want more for their country. Western democracies with weaker free speech protections do function, but they also have a substantial pressure outlet in the form of websites hosted in other countries that don't kowtow to oppressive governments.
- slg 8y agoCross reference this list[1] with this one[2]. I just don't see any evidence for a claims like "Western democracies with hate speech laws are less democratic". [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech
- turkeysandwich 8y agoThe only thing the democracy index gets right are the broad strokes. But then again, so could a high schooler with wikipedia and a free afternoon. It's not implemented well enough to detect the fine differences between western countries. Hate speech laws reduce the range of discourse. They suppress dissent. That's inherently undemocratic.