6 ms·
Skepticism might be warranted, but it should be noted by now that decentralized finance has a place in the present and future of our planet and it's not going a
by chrisco255 8y ago
Skepticism might be warranted, but it should be noted by now that decentralized finance has a place in the present and future of our planet and it's not going away. I strongly encourage technologists to keep an open mind and do in depth research into the space.
Yes, 2017 was over-hyped. The tech was not mature then, and while it has matured some since then, there's still quite a ways to go.
Bitcoin Lightning network is growing. Ethereum has successfully navigated core upgrades and has a clear path to scalability. Other platforms are doing great innovative things.
But to the core of the argument that crypto has no use case. It's 2019. We've seen our internet rights to speech and expression violated by companies imposing their values on their user base. We've seen digital ghosting, deplatforming, fake news manipulation, propaganda and all kinds of insidious behaviors from corporate giants that are too big to be truly accountable anymore.
Bitcoin et al. are a very real promise that the future of banking and finance and money will be decentralized. Which as far as I'm concerned, is about freedom as much as speech is. You don't have any freedom if you have to beg VISA or PayPal for permission to spend your money. That alone should be enough to justify the existence of block chain technology and we should all be cheering on its eventual success.
But besides that, the tech is being used in novel ways. From gaming to loans to tokenized asset trading. Cryptocurrency is programmable in a way that is just not possible with dollars.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- seibelj 8y agoSome interesting players in the defi space: https://compound.finance/ https://compound.finance/ https://makerdao.com/en/ https://makerdao.com/en/ https://dydx.exchange/ https://dydx.exchange/ https://0x.org/ https://0x.org/
- sumshetty 8y agoNuo.network
- bachback 8y agoThe article doesn't say much about it in relation to a16z. There is a16zcrypto.com . I am very involved in this space, I am wondering how a16zcrypto is structured compared to traditional VC. For many crypto startups it probably doesn't make much sense to base in US.
- jasonvorhe 8y ago> We've seen our internet rights to speech and expression violated by companies imposing their values on their user base. You mean stuff like not supporting hate groups such as white supremacists, conspiracy theorists and anti-vaxxers or something else?
- liquidise 8y agoNot the OP but... yes, among countless others. 10 years ago, people who clamored about a subset of the NSA's dragnet could have been justifiably labeled "conspiracy theorists". Cultures and public opinions change over time. In America, and certainly for the most part on the internet, the ability to express opinions, including and especially controversial ones, is both a hallmark of and litmus test for freedom. Censoring controversial statements based on the current cultural temperament is antithetical to it.
- dd36 8y agoConspiracy theorists have limitations. See Alex Jones getting sued. If you’re actively promoting something false and malicious that harms people, your speech can be restricted. That’s not new.
- cjslep 8y ago> Ethereum has successfully navigated core upgrades and has a clear path to scalability. And for all this technical progress there's still the human problem that the core team/individuals decided exploiting vulnerable contracts' and hard forking the failed DAO were morally right ideas. As long as those team members are involved then the truth is that no one in the Ethereum ecosystem can escape the Spectre of their will. They've historically proven to be operating as simply a different centralized body of power that isn't a government issuing fiat.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThey've historically proven to be operating as simply a different centralized body of power that isn't a government issuing fiat. I can imagine at least a couple of scenarios where it might be in the interests of (some?) investors to spruik such a thing. There’s a lot of power being generated by, and flowing within and between, various organisations throughout the world. It’s probably possible to tap in to that a gather some of it close to you, especially if you are a group of tech minded wealthy folk.
- lifeisstillgood 8y ago>>> There’s a lot of power being generated by, and flowing within and between, various organisations throughout the world. Could you clarify? Do you mean flowing as in transactions between major banks or major manufacturers? Or something less obvious?
- sdfsdfsdfsdf3 8y agoThis is the Vitalik jump request. All the miners immediately ask how high. Centralized in a Slack channel.
- hopler 8y agoThat's democratic consensus. It's not centralized. You can fork if you want.
- slg 8y ago>We've seen our internet rights to speech and expression violated by companies imposing their values on their user base. >Bitcoin et al. are a very real promise that the future of banking and finance and money will be decentralized. Which as far as I'm concerned, is about freedom as much as speech is. You don't have any freedom if you have to beg VISA or PayPal for permission to spend your money. The moral high ground you are trying to claim in your second argument is undercut by your first argument. If this was all about freedom, we would see similar sized investments in open and decentralized platforms focused on free speech. The reason we aren't seeing that is obvious. It is much easier to see a path to profitability in the cryptocurrency space. Most cryptocurrency investments aren't about freedom, they are about carving out a piece of the pie from the existing financial services industry. There is nothing immoral about turning a profit, just be open about it. It is dishonest for cryptocurrency investors to claim their intent is to save the world especially considering how much electricity and therefore fossil fuels some of the popular cryptocurrencies waste. Sell the tech on its own merits and accomplishments. There is a reason why the "making the world a better place" pitches have been parodied for years.
- stale2002 8y ago> we would see similar sized investments in open and decentralized platforms focused on free speech This is already a mostly solved problem. There are lots and lots of places on the internet, when I can engage in speech and it won't be censored. Yes, the big platforms might censor you, but there are still lots and lots of small platforms that won't or can't.
- zby 8y agoThe problem with decentralized money is that there is no way to manage the supply - you can only commit to a given supply curve, but you cannot adjust it according to the state of the economy. Money is a collective action problem, a public good - it requires a solution that bounds everyone - just like defence.
- mbrock 8y agoWhy can’t you do that?
- zby 8y agoThe fundamental problem is probably with the possibility of fork - if it is decentralized then everyone can fork it if he disagrees with the way it works. But maybe there are some good in-between solutions, less dogmatic, more pragmatic.
- MusaTheRedGuard 8y agoForking is not a problem. It's users voting with their feet. The possibility of forking is a necessary deterrent in cryptonetwork governance. If the maintainers of a network become compromised or get coopted by special interests, the collective owners of the network(the holders of the cryptocurrency) have the right to exit. The right to exit is a necessary part of governance.
- zby 8y agoYou cannot have an binding agreement between everybody if anybody can get out at any time. My thesis is that managing money supply requires such an agreement. Of course you can have unmanaged money - historically we always had that - with gold standard and shells. But it is probably less efficient - because it means you cannot adjust money supply to the state of economy.
- beaner 8y agoSome people think this is a problem. Others, a feature. At least now we have the ability to see what happens.
- golergka 8y ago> But to the core of the argument that crypto has no use case. Oh come on, this american-centric meme has to die off already. Drugs. Every drug-related transaction I know or heard off for the last ~2 years have been done through bitcoin. In some aspects, US is ahead of the globe. In others, though - like having people such as drug dealers who meet their clients in person and make transactions in cash - it's way behind.
- blfr 8y agodecentralized finance has a place in the present and future of our planet There is no guarantee that decentralized anything has a place in the future. So far the trends have been depressingly centralizing, whether it's government, finance, manufacturing, or even our great hope, the Internet.
- MusaTheRedGuard 8y agoWhat do you think decentralized finance even is?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dmix 8y agoThe costs of centralization is starting to seep into people’s day to day life though. People tend not to act to abstract threats but rather tangible issues. Tech people have been warning about this forever because they have a strong grasp of the consequences and they also better understand what we have (or had) with the internet and other parts of the economy and politics. I’m starting to see far more ‘regular’ people outside of tech concerned about the top down centralization of communication and payment networks.
- hopler 8y agoIt's not a tech thing. "Small/big government" / hegemony / balance of power is an age old debate.
- floodyberry- 8y agoHow, exactly, does Bitcoin (and other shitcoins) being nominally 'decentralized', and whose main use after 10 years is still speculation and scams, relate to nazis and right wing trolls occasionally get kicked off twitter?
- navigatesol 8y ago>How, exactly, does Bitcoin (and other shitcoins) being nominally 'decentralized', and whose main use after 10 years is still speculation and scams, relate to nazis and right wing trolls occasionally get kicked off twitter? Perhaps because the people you label "right-wing trolls" are, sometimes, actually just people with different opinions, and deserve (at least in their minds) some protection? They aren't merely getting kicked off Twitter; in some cases they are being demonetized. It's all well and good to sit back and say, "too bad for them", but it would be diligent to at least concede your "side" may not win this fight, and one day you might be getting the label.
- floodyberry- 8y agoThat doesn't explain why Bitcoin is useful for anything other than relieving stupid people of their money?
- navigatesol 8y ago>You don't have any freedom if you have to beg VISA or PayPal for permission to spend your money. That alone should be enough to justify the existence of block chain technology and we should all be cheering on its eventual success. Where is it you live that Internet service is provided by a free market, that can't be disabled?
- paulgb 8y agoI can think of more cases of Visa and PayPal cutting off payments (e.g. to alt-right media organizations, Backpage, gambling) than ISPs. It's of course their right not to process payments for whomever they want, and I personally haven't shed any tears over the organizations I've mentioned, but I do wonder whether it is a good thing that payments are so centralized they effectively become an extragovernmental regulator, especially because their motive is loss prevention and public image rather than public interest.
- thinkmassive 8y agoMost of the inhabited Earth actually... https://blockstream.com/satellite/ https://blockstream.com/satellite/
- notyourday 8y agoDecentralized finance is a myth. Governments only exist because they control the money on behalf of the country. Decentralization of finance would remove that control and hence fundamentally undermine the governments control
- thinkmassive 8y agoSubstitute “religion” for “finance” and the Roman Catholic Church of the Middle Ages would agree with you.