3 ms·
"Democracies don't work by doing the right or correct thing. They work by the consent of the governed." The question is "does our government listen to its peop
by chaostheory 16y ago
"Democracies don't work by doing the right or correct thing. They work by the consent of the governed."
The question is "does our government listen to its people anymore, regardless of elections"?
The bank bailouts were opposed by the majority of the population crossing party lines. I wouldn't be surprised if the new TSA procedures are equally as hated. I can go on about other subjects such as FISA, ACTA, torture, Iraq & Afghanistan occupation.
Are we now living in a more subtle version of Singapore or China?
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoWhy the generalizing? The question you pose is not something that you can prove one way or another. It's up to each citizen to make that decision for themselves. As broken as it all is, a minority of people can't rise up and take away the consent of the governed by the majority, no matter how good their logic or noble their cause. It doesn't work like that. It's not a mathematical proof. Systems of people are not like system of network nodes. Yes, there are similarities, but there are very important differences too. Europe already went down this road in the prelude to WWI. It didn't work out so well. I'm not opposed to going over all of this again, but these things have already been discussed and argued by people far wiser than us. If I understand what folks are saying, it's not like Assange has come up with some unique insight that somehow is going to make things better. This is just anarchism by another name.
- chaostheory 16y agoI wasn't that general. I did cite at least two cases where the majority of the governed wanted something other than what our government has provided us. Besides I don't see this toppling our representative democracy. If anything it'll just help keep our representatives a bit more honest and a bit more cautious. My point is that many people already see the social contract as broken.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI screwed that up, so let me restate: why are you making a general assessment of the state of the social contract and then taking action which effects me because of your analysis? I happen to agree with you that things suck. But I disagree with leaks of State Dept and tactical military intelligence. Others think things are great but don't mind the leaks. Still others are apathetic and encourage the leaks. Out of a dozen people, you'll find a dozen different opinions. We all -- each citizen -- have a unique relationship with our government. Who are you or anybody else to make a decision like that that effects billions of dollars spent and tens of thousands of lives? I didn't elect Assange. He doesn't represent me. And I have no recourse to remove him from his post if I feel he is acting maliciously or incompetently. You see, it's not enough to make the argument that things suck so much that anything would be better. It doesn't work that way. That's just waving your arms around in anger and exasperation. I also believe we need to get rid of 99.99% of the secrecy we have. But there is still a role for government and secrecy. Some random person doesn't have the right to "fix" what he thinks is broken -- because if he can do that, then we all can. And at that point we might as well just go out in the streets with guns to get our way. This is insanity. Well thought-out, for a good cause, well-intentioned, but fundamentally broken. This is like the dozenth time groups of people have been down this road. It doesn't end well -- even if the state is "fixed". It's critically important to separate your opinion of the state of things from the reasons and rules that each individual can take to make a difference. Take the Declaration of Independence. In it, Jefferson doesn't make the case that monarchical rule is broken and therefore we must act militarily -- far from it. He respects the previous state of things but then makes a detailed argument as to how the king broke the social contract with the colonies, thereby releasing governance of the states back to the "natural legislature" of the people. It's a very long list of things we did to try to make things work and how they didn't work out. If you want a revolution, that's the place to go to start understanding what arguments work and what arguments don't work. Move from there to "Letters from a Birmingham Jail". But don't go down the Marx route where you do this huge amount of clever reasoning and then wreak havoc on the rest of us because of what you've proven. That's not so good.
- chaostheory 16y ago"Who are you or anybody else to make a decision like that that effects billions of dollars spent and tens of thousands of lives? I didn't elect Assange. He doesn't represent me. And I have no recourse to remove him from his post if I feel he is acting maliciously or incompetently." This has already been happening for years with our 4th branch of government, our very own government agencies. They aren't elected. How do we know that they are complying with the branches that we elected? "Some random person doesn't have the right to "fix" what he thinks is broken -- because if he can do that, then we all can. And at that point we might as well just go out in the streets with guns to get our way." I don't understand why you are comparing Wikileaks to an armed insurgency. Wikileaks is only doing what the mainstream media either won't or can no longer perform because of their new owners. Wikileaks is not an armed and violent insurgency. It isn't usurping anyone's power if they are acting within the law or within what they were elected to do. It is only releasing information that should be known to the public. Our government is already supposed to make freely available a lot of information that it is still withholding: http://www.aclu.org/accountability/released.html http://www.aclu.org/accountability/released.html What is an alternative to Wikileaks? We've already tried voting, and I'm not keen on supporting revolution. I'm just advocating transparency to help preserve our current government, albeit just making it a little more honest and a little less crazy. Just saw this the other day on The Onion's competitor: http://toofar.tv/blog/?p=7 http://toofar.tv/blog/?p=7
- ErrantX 16y agoThis is common thinking. But there is a problem; outside a national vote you tend to get a massive skew on "voter opinion" because only a minority are involved. This has been observed many times over the years; where the electorate were supposed to think one way but in actual fact voted differently. A recent example is how badly the liberals did in the recent UK elections. Over a large enough population people are generally apathetic - so there is no guarantee that what seems obvious reflects the majority. It's an unfortunate side effect of democracy :-)
- chaostheory 16y agoI'm not very familiar with UK elections, but I am aware of some voting irregularities in the US in recent years. It doesn't help when our electronic voting machines are subject to less scrutiny and transparency than the electronic slots in Las Vegas. From my limited and inexperienced viewpoint, I just feel that less transparency tends to encourage corruption and other unpleasant things. Hence my support for organizations such as wikileaks. "Who watches the watchers?"
- ErrantX 16y agoOh, well that's another issue - voting irregularities due to errors or corruption are a big problem in some areas. But I'm more talking about... here in the UK just before the general elections all of the main commentators and polls were predicting a lot of huge wins for our third party, the liberals. As it turned out, they had a terrible election - and are only "kingmakers" because the public was divided over the lead two parties. The outcome of the election was radically different to what was predicted - because it was only a vocal minority that was making their voice heard before the election. The vast majority of people are either apathetic or prefer to raise their voice via the ballot. Which is why it is always dangerous to quote "public opinion" :)
- blasdel 16y agoIn both of those cases the government was very much listening to the electorate, and giving them exactly what they wanted even if they did not ask for it or even refused it by name. People wanted the government to fix the banking crisis, and they did in the most expedient way, even if the proper medicine was so foul-tasting as to inspire popular revolt. People begged for more security theater to prevent another underwear bomber, and the government threw money at the only potential solution to that attack vector and got it implemented just in time for the next holiday season.