8 ms·
All of these types of "hey, give us your password to this other system" are just training users to get phished. IMO the worst offender in this is Plaid, which
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
All of these types of "hey, give us your password to this other system" are just training users to get phished.
IMO the worst offender in this is Plaid, which has created a service where millions of people are giving their banking credentials so some random startup can mine your transaction data. And people think FB has privacy implications...
- slouch 8y agoThat's exactly how mint.com works, owned by Intuit/QuickBooks.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoYeah back when ING still had a retail presence in the US they were notorious for not working well with Mint… because they required a mint specific access key and not your master credentials.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYeah, but the difference (at least I think so, as I'm not a mint user) is that Plaid is building an API for other startups to use. It's somewhat amazing to me how little is needed for folks to gleefully hand over their bank passwords to anyone who asks for it.
- nemothekid 8y agoMint legitmatized that authorization flow years before Plaid came around and the banks decided that was the best way to move forward instead of adopting something like an oauth2 flow.
- VoiceOfWisdom 8y agoI remember Quicken doing it back in the early 2000s.
- anoncake 8y agoThat is a program though, not a website.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThat's the problem now though. We've made it so apps have to be approved by gatekeepers, and are highly discouraged by the gatekeepers from sharing state with other apps on the same device. Then the recommendation if that's a problem for you is to use the web. But sometimes the web doesn't work, as is the case here, because it requires the user to trust third party code in real time and give sensitive data to third party servers they don't control. So we have everything pushing the user to put their most sensitive information into some third party service that should be an app, but isn't, because cloud.
- tantalor 8y ago> highly discouraged by the gatekeepers from sharing state Source? My understanding is the app permission model never asks for network access, so all "apps" are effectively web clients with a fancy UI.
- icebraining 8y ago> My understanding is the app permission model never asks for network access, so all "apps" are effectively web clients with a fancy UI. At least for Android, not exactly: they still have to require network access (android.permission.INTERNET), and you can check if they have done that in the Play Store (description → Read More → App permissions). What changed is that the Store won't explicitly ask you to confirm you're OK with it when installing. In any case, typical native applications didn't have to ask for network access either, that didn't make them all effectively web clients. Many of the mobile apps I have installed don't rely on a central service.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Source? Example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19521211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19521211 I'm not talking about sharing state with your webserver, I'm talking about two apps on your phone sharing state directly with each other without ever leaving the device or becoming accessible to a third party. Desktop operating systems have a slew of ways to facilitate this, and the mobile gatekeepers keep eroding them. They're also terrible at dependency management (a completely solved problem in real package managers), which discourages creating apps that depend on other apps. There are still ways to do any given thing, but if you make it harder then you make it rarer.
- dylan604 8y agoI remember when Mint first came around, and a coworker was telling me about how cool it was. I started completing the the signup process, but I stopped cold once I realized they needed to be provided account credentials from my bank. Never completed it, and never went back to it. I never thought it would last as long as it had. I guess I gave the public too much credit.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThe general public is extremely myopic and lazy. They will hand over anything you ask for if it means they have to do less work in the short-term. Convenience trumps all. It's how we've ended up with people voluntarily purchasing, maintaining, carrying around at all times, keeping charged and powered on, their own personal surveillance devices running heaps of software they have no control over.
- csallen 8y agoCounterpoint: Many people of the "general public" are at least vaguely aware of the fact that they're making risky decisions, but proceed regardless in order to reap the short-term rewards that you mention, calculating that the benefits are worth the hypothetical costs, and many of them will live and die having been right about making that tradeoff.
- UweSchmidt 8y agoYou would use an old bridge, trusting that someone somewhere is responsible for inspecting that bridge and guaranteeing that it holds. In the same way, "we" are responsible that our software fundamentally works to a certain standard so that other people can trust using it.
- Loughla 8y agoCounterpoint to your counterpoint: Living in flyover country surrounded by people with at best a high school education has taught me MANY things about how the public consumes tech. They have no idea what is possible with technology. They literally do not and cannot comprehend what can be done with their information online. To the folks I interact with, it's almost magical how it works. They trust, as another comment points out here, that someone is taking care of whatever trail they leave (if they even understand that's a thing). They trust that tech companies are acting in their best interests. Maybe that's just anecdotal data from my experience, but it's my experience.
- matz1 8y agoI've been using mint for years,it's been very useful for me. Adopting other mechanism like oauth will be slow they wouldn't be able to support that many financial institution. Its all boil down to risk vs benefit.
- ramraj07 8y agoI use mint even now. I'm generally technically paranoid, and have just concluded mint is not actually that risky. Here's why: 1. Most banking companies seem to have a much better security landscape than other places, including tracking where you're logging in from. Even with a password it won't be easy for a hacker to do stuff with my accounts. Almost any change or transaction triggers an email and sms alert too. 2. The main bank I have my money in, doesn't let you do transactions larger than 2000 in a day online, and even that is insured against fraud. 3. For credit card accounts, I have noticed that you actually can't do much with just an online account, except to pay the bill. 4. Mint is owned by Intuit and they know my tax details, most of which are far more important and guard-worthy anyways. 5. Also till now I've been a fairly poor guy with not much in my bank accounts. So I didn't worry too much about losing my cash since I didn't have much. If you have a lot of it, perhaps you need to be careful with such services.
- propogandist 8y agoMints privacy policy includes this language "we may prepare and share information about our customers with third parties, such as advertisers or partners, for research, academic, marketing and/or promotional purposes." - where any usage of "may" can be substituted with "will". They say they will anonymize data, but advertisers have no interest in data if they can't action on it -- i.e. use the data they buy for targeted advertising.
- astura 8y agoTo some of us (me) the service Mint provides is well worth letting some marketer know I spent $50 at Walmart yesterday, that's not sensitive information to me, and if it were I'd be paying in cash. I even gave the transaction history of all my credit cards directly to Drop (https://www.earnwithdrop.com https://www.earnwithdrop.com) in exchange for a few dollars, that's how little it means to me. (So far around $30)
- hopler 8y agoMint was a copy of Yodlee. This stuff is old.
- temp19281 8y agoPlaid might be my least favorite company ever. It's such a privacy nightmare and they do not even tell you basic information about what you are sharing (or how to revoke sharing rights) going through their typical flow on some random fintech app. If you look at their website, you could be giving away just the bank and routing number, or potentially your entire bank transaction history, balance, identity information, etc. and have no idea. It's terrible and could never recommend ever using an app that forced you through that flow. They need to be exposed. Or sued.
- nemothekid 8y agoI alluded to this in my other comment, but I don't blame Plaid. Blame the banks - Plaid isn't doing this behind their banks, but with their blessings. Again, Mint was doing this for years. When it comes to Credit Card Fraud, the banks are buying all sorts of AI based solutions - after all it's their money. When it comes to customer cash, then its the wild west. I recently found out that my Wells Fargo password isn't even case sensitive. There is clearly a market need for easier information exchange. Authorizing ACH withdrawals shouldn't require me depositing 2 random values in your account. The Banks could have done the work here, but they didn't and then Plaid came along and did the work for them. I hope they take data security more seriously than Wells Fargo.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> I hope they take data security more seriously than Wells Fargo. But it doesn't really matter how seriously Plaid takes data security, as their whole business is around providing your account data (including your transaction data) to other companies. What matters is if the thousands of business customers of Plaid take data security seriously.
- temp19281 8y agoWhy not blame Plaid? Plaid's value is providing the SDK that developers can plug into their app to connect user bank accounts with their app. They have purposefully decided not to show a very common step in the user-facing bank link/onboarding flow of displaying exactly what information you are providing the developer with (e.g. think about FB Connect, Twitter, and Google and how each requires developers to show exactly what permission is being asked of the user). Plaid has several endpoints you can hit. It could be as little as the bank number/routing number (to pull/push funds), but it can be years of bank transaction history and/or all identifying information about you from your bank (e.g. names, emails, phone numbers, addresses) and/or your current bank balance as well. An app that doesn't even provide mint-like functionality (e.g. showing your spending habits) could be pulling years of bank transaction history and you would not even know. That's horrifying. Again, Plaid can and should take responsibility for not showing a simple permissions page. There is no way this is just an "oversight" on their part. It's a deliberate decision because they know it would be a conversion killer if people actually consciously understood how much information they are granting to random apps.
- billdybas 8y agoYes. Mint also does this. From what I've heard, there are a lot of banks without APIs, so the next best approach is to login on behalf of users and scrape the data.
- dullgiulio 8y agoIt also implies saving passwords without hashing... Not good.
- billdybas 8y agoSure, but is that not what an online password manager is? :P
- baroffoos 8y agoThe data is encrypted with a key that you have not one that the server has which is much much better. If someone breaks in to the server they are not able to very quickly grab all the data. They have to be able to deploy some malware on the server and allow it to run for a while to collect passwords.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIf the on-line component goes anywhere beyond the ability to sync an opaque binary blob that only your local machines can decrypt and reencrypt, there's a problem there.
- hopler 8y agoHow does my secret key get from my phone to my tablet?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThe devices could exchange their keys through a secure connection - be it direct (Bluetooth, LAN) or routed by a third-party service. It could also be transferred physically (through removable storage, or through retyping a bunch of numbers shown on one device into another device).
- Abishek_Muthian 8y agoDuring demonetisation in India (2016), Mobile wallet startups threw the privacy out of window. Paytm (India's largest e-Wallet), asked customers to enter their credit card details on their app on merchant's smartphone. I reported the security risk to them with a POC to their bounty hunting[1], they asked me to wait, removed the feature & the CEO told media that I was lying, there was never a security risk. Mobiwik, read customer's SMS of bank transactions to inform its users which ATMs had cash. [1]:https://abishekmuthian.com/paytm-says-to-me-that-its-pos-feature-didn-t-have-a-security-risk-8fd7c3849e54 https://abishekmuthian.com/paytm-says-to-me-that-its-pos-fea...
- tapland 8y agoSwedish payment processor Klarna does something similar to this as well. If bying something through the platform by direct bank transfer you are asked to sign to your bank to accept the payment using BankID [0], which is normal. What is not normal is that they grab your personal identification number and send a login request using BankID before you open your app. When authenticating the login you authorize one of Klarnas third parties to log into your bank account as you, allowing them to pull records of all your financial transactions, account statements etc. Most users just authenticate the login without reading where the request is coming from on the login prompt. I don't understand how that can be legal, but they are relying on recent court cases where scammers would call old people asking them to log on to check their retirement accounts. The scammers would then send a login request before the user sent theirs, log on to the accounts and change what funds received the victims pension payments. The scammers were ruled in the wrong, but the logins themselves were ruled to be an ok way of doing business. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_identification#Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_identification#Swed...
- jks 8y agoKlarna tried to ask for people's bank access codes in Finland until Finland's Financial Supervisory Authority ruled it illegal. Seems like a shady business to me.
- thesimon 8y agoWill probably be legal again due to the PSD2.
- jks 8y agoThe Finnish authority’s stance is that asking for passwords and screen scraping the bank pages is not acceptable. I only have a source in Finnish but Google Translate seems to work: https://www.finanssivalvonta.fi/saantely/kannanotot-ja-tulkinnat/01_2018/ https://www.finanssivalvonta.fi/saantely/kannanotot-ja-tulki... https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.finanssivalvonta.fi%2Fsaantely%2Fkannanotot-ja-tulkinnat%2F01_2018%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...
- 55555 8y agowait, Plaid mines my transaction history? I assumed they made all their money from API customers paying fees. Is this true?
- eshyong 8y agoI haven't heard any reports of Plaid doing bad stuff with user transaction data, so I suspect there's a bit of paranoia in the comments here. On the other hand, there's an underlying (and valid) concern that handing over bank credentials to a third party is risky and, even assuming good faith from Plaid, they have to store passwords on their servers somehow (probably encrypted). Since they make money from integrations with startups/big banks, there is definitely a conflict of interest between keeping user credentials safe and growing their revenue. I think as a whole, relying on a modern company which specializes in authentication is better than trusting that thousands of app developers, some of which might big legacy banks with woefully understaffed IT departments, will keep your credentials safe. I'm aware that I'm more optimistic than most people in this thread (and on HN) though. Here's a stackexchange question with some good discussion about Plaid security: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/198005/is-plaid-a-service-which-collects-user-s-banking-login-information-safe-to-use https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/198005/is-plaid... Here's a github issue on Plaid's repo, showing that they are at least considering oauth on their roadmap: https://github.com/plaid/link/issues/68 https://github.com/plaid/link/issues/68 And here's Plaid's page on security, which is frankly short and a bit vague: https://plaid.com/security/ https://plaid.com/security/
- chrismorgan 8y agoIn Australia, there’s POLi Payments, now owned by Australia Post, which gets you to enter your bank username and password, then impersonates you (https://www.polipayments.com/Security https://www.polipayments.com/Security is their statement about it, and a substantial fraction of the text on that page is just flat-out lies). Naturally, doing so is entirely against the ToS of all the banks (including you now being liable for literally anything), and a few banks have publicly said “don’t use that” or similar, but they evidently tacitly support it, because I don’t imagine it would be hard for them to block. I was incredulous when I first tried to use POLi Payments and realised how it worked—I ran away screaming, naturally. That entire business should be shut down with prejudice.
- davb 8y agoMonzo in the UK recently added a beta ("labs") feature in their app to check your Barclaycard balance from within the app. Sounded ideal as the Monzo app is the best banking app I've ever used. I figured they'd be using Open Banking (the new OAuth style authentication system rolling out across banks here). I went to turn it on only to find that they use a third party who ask for all of your Barclaycard credentials (including your full "secret word", which you normally only enter a few characters from at login time). I've no idea why they'd go this route, but exactly as you say - it just trains users to get phished. It also wasn't clear what this third party would do with the transaction information they scrape from your account. Overall a terrible idea.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoDegiro, an investment platform, do the same for your initial £100 deposit: you enter your bank's auth info and they do the wire transfer for you. It uses a 3rd party system called "SOFORT". Thereby training the public that passwords to a bank account should be given to random third parties, undoing years of pain staking training efforts. If they asked for your PIN code, people would clearly balk. But somehow, passwords to a bank account are fair game. It's exasperating.
- thesimon 8y ago> It uses a 3rd party system called "SOFORT" Which is Klarna. > Thereby training the public that passwords to a bank account should be given to random third parties, undoing years of pain staking training efforts. Accounts details are relatively fine to enter on other sites, just entering 2FA tokens should be limited for transactions that you really want to confirm.
- thinkingemote 8y agoAccount details are different than passwords to your online banking account.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoThere are three reasons I disagree: 1. You train end users that entering banking credentials on 3rd party sites is Okay. This makes educating against phishing an impossible task. 2. Many banks require (a form of) 2FA to log in. Perhaps it’s a “2 letters from a secret code” system (see sibling post). You’re now educating users that entering 2FA on 3rd party sites is ok. This is the end of educating users about any security at all, really. 3. This 3rd party gets access to my full transaction history, everything I ever spent on anything, using this account. That is an unconscionable overreach in personal data access. “But we don’t use it / read it / store it / we only send it to trusted partners / .....” I’ve heard that song too many times. If someone asked for email account passwords and 2FA login, people would scream bloody murder. What makes this different? Note that none of this is about money. If someone defrauds me, the bank will refund me. It’s the least of my worries, really. Sure, rather not. But the bank can’t refund my privacy if someone exfiltrates purchase history. Based on any data leak ever, I think we all know what’s the most valuable thing in my bank account .. it’s not the money. It’s the data.
- cesarb 8y ago> a service where millions of people are giving their banking credentials so some random startup can mine your transaction data Wow, that's insane. I didn't think I'd ever be happy that all banks here in Brazil require you to install an invasive piece of software to validate your computer before allowing you to use online banking, which as far as I can see makes that sort of business model non-viable here.
- spacesuitman2 8y agoThat's equally as bad for the consumer.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThey do this because banks refuse to implement a properly-secured read-only API for granting access to transaction data. (I think maybe Chase now finally has one) Maybe if the banks realize their customers are handing over their credentials in large numbers, it will light a fire under them to build a real solution.
- usrusr 8y ago> Maybe if the banks realize their customers are handing over their credentials in large numbers Or they might pop a bottle of Champaign over that, in jurisdictions where the bank is by default responsible for all the account abuse risk unless they can prove that the user has shared credentials.
- daemin 8y agoProbably not, because liability for non-credit accounts is up to the customer, not the bank. If people give up access credentials then they only have themselves to blame.
- contravariant 8y agoThis is by far my biggest concern with the new PSD2 system that's about to be launched. Even though I can understand why it might help break up monopolies, I still worry that easier access to banking details is going to end disastrously for people's privacy.
- hopler 8y agoBefore Plaid there was Yodlee which coordinated password harvesting from all the major financial institutions with their active partnership.
- nathan_long 8y agoArguably, giving up your email login is worse than giving up your banking login, since attackers could use your email to reset the password on other accounts, possibly including bank accounts. For banking, a better system would allow you to generate some kind of token in your banking site which would allow the kinds of permissions you want to grant to a third party, and which you could unilaterally revoke at any time.
- niij 8y agoTransfund does this now. I tried complaining to their support and they just don't get it. Account/routing number should be enough, they don't need access to my transactions, etc. Add that on top of increasing fees and I'm seeking alternatives.
- niij 8y ago*Sorry, I meant Transferwise.com