3 ms·
In perhaps the most extreme undertaking, he packed on 34 pounds of muscle while dropping 3 pounds of fat in 28 days. I could probably gain 31 pounds in 28 days
by nostromo 16y ago
In perhaps the most extreme undertaking, he packed on 34 pounds of muscle while dropping 3 pounds of fat in 28 days.
I could probably gain 31 pounds in 28 days if I wanted to too... In all seriousness, I'd like to see how he measured fat vs. muscle here. These self-aggrandizing lifestyle / diet gurus tend to make a lot of claims that fall flat when subjected to any sort of peer review.
... to compete in the kickboxing nationals... I weighed in at 165, and the next day I stepped onto the platform at 193.
So in this instance, he gained over a pound an hour... Is that really possible, even if it's all water?
- joshklein 16y agoNot to defend his actual results, as I am unaware of them, but this can be tracked by measuring your mass and volume (through water displacement), since fat and muscle have different and known densities. You can also use a body fat caliper for more of an eyeballing of body fat percentage.
- hugh3 16y agoSounds rather error-prone. If I wanted to fool myself into thinking that I'd swapped a lot of fat for a lot of muscle, what could I do? I'd try to increase density from one volume measurement to the other -- I could breathe in a lot of air during one measurement, and eat a lot of.. I dunno, fruit cake before the other.
- naner 16y agoHere's the post if you are curious: http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2007/04/29/from-geek-to-freak-how-i-gained-34-lbs-of-muscle-in-4-weeks/ http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2007/04/29/from-geek-to...
- icegreentea 16y agoI use to wrestle (highschool level, and trained with university level). I've heard of people who've dropped and gained 10-15% of their pre-cutting body mass like that. His claim is definately on the top end of things. The rehydration process is every bit as dangerous as the dehydration. You don't do it right, you just end up puking all over the place, which is no good when you're already dehydrated. I'm REALLY suspect one pound of muscle per day. If you want an idea of what that means... look at a 1 pound steak. You're adding that much to your body every day. I'll give him that there are probably genetic freaks of nature out there who can pull this stuff off (maybe he is one), but it's simply not a realistic goal.
- salemh 16y agoMost persons undergoing first-time heavy weight training, or re-training (after a long layoff and losing that muscle mass) have muscle memory kick in. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muscle_memory#Retention http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muscle_memory#Retention "Whether strength or endurance related, it is plausible that the majority of motor movements would require a skilled moving task of some form, whether it be maintaining proper form when paddling a canoe, or bench pressing a heavier weight." http://www.syfit.com/articles05.html http://www.syfit.com/articles05.html http://jap.physiology.org/cgi/content/abstract/70/2/631 http://jap.physiology.org/cgi/content/abstract/70/2/631 "These data suggest that rapid muscular adaptations occur as a result of strength training in previously trained as well as non-previously trained women." I believe he achieved this potential lb's due to previously having those gains in muscle mass. My own personal experience (and training in an amateur / non professional fashion friends and family) were massive gains with proper nutrition and intense weight training, compound movements at the initial onset of training (myself, 30 lbs in 3 months, the first time I ever did weights on a consistent basis, lean muscle though my frame is skinny). However, with a 1-2 month ramp up I can typically add 5-10 lbs in a more lazy fashion (whereas my previous ~30 lbs of mass I was extremely regimented and ate / trained basically full-time), which is muscle memory. This "extreme" undertaking is probably better explained in his book (only because the article does not take the claim to task) and probably involved him slimming down over the years, and revamping an intensive training protocol. Body types will also influence Weight vs Appearance. Tim had a previous article which was much dissected pre-his even stating he was coming out with a fitness book. http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2007/04/29/from-geek-to-freak-how-i-gained-34-lbs-of-muscle-in-4-weeks/ http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2007/04/29/from-geek-to... http://www.healthynewage.com/blog/bull-strong/ http://www.healthynewage.com/blog/bull-strong/ “He could just be a freak of nature, but even the most genetically gifted body builders have NEVER gained this amount of muscle in such a short period. ” This could be another factor on top of all else. I find Tim’s writing refreshing. He does not fluff or sugar coat his “step by steps” and this leads to (another discussion perhaps) arguments over the simplistic validity of his systems. Edit: Note "weight cutting" for professional sports probably relates to his large gains. (MMA Fighters frequently cut between 15-20 lbs, sometimes more, I am not sure how relevant this is to the discussion, so only a Google link :D) http://www.google.com/search?aq=f&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=weight+cutting http://www.google.com/search?aq=f&sourceid=chrome&ie...