4 ms·
I think they are making an argument about the efficiency of the modern economy more than they are making an argument that people should be able to live on $15 g
by maxerickson 8y ago
I think they are making an argument about the efficiency of the modern economy more than they are making an argument that people should be able to live on $15 given current prices.
Looking at what it costs to produce the material goods required to maintain a decent (but minimal) standard of living, $15 an hour probably should be enough.
That $15 isn't sufficient can then be taken as a prompt to look at the impacts of existing policies and who they benefit and so on.
- Mirioron 8y agoIf you look at other countries then $15 an hour is a crazy high amount for a minimum wage. 6 years ago I had a full time software development job where I made $600 a month net. If you look at countries like Ukraine or Bulgaria you'll see even lower earnings. And it's not like average people in those countries are starving or dirt poor. They have cars, homes, computers, smartphones etc.
- sdenton4 8y agoComputers and smartphones don't really matter when looking at a total-cost-of-living calculation in today's economy. In the US, they are vanishingly cheap compared to housing, health care and education (aka, servicing student debt). Cars cost a bit more (last I checked, some years ago, about $6k/year - base cost + gas + insurance). Rent is >$500 just about everywhere these days... https://www.rentcafe.com/average-rent-market-trends/us/mo/saint-louis/ https://www.rentcafe.com/average-rent-market-trends/us/mo/sa... ). The US relies on employer-provided health insurance, but, as a result, employers keep people working multiple part time jobs to avoid footing the insurance costs. And since most people pay for education with loans, the lowest wage workers are often also left paying for years for failed attempts to get out of the lowest economic class.
- mjevans 8y agoAlso, lets say we wave a want and everyone making less than 15 USD suddenly does. What would happen in today's climate? What has happened where I live as that has come closer to reality? The cost of __everything__ but particularly rent and other less elastic items have risen to match and overtake any gains. The true effect is to decrease the wealth of the middle class and only the "nobles" who own more than their own living abodes benefit.
- sdenton4 8y agoI would argue that only the most inelastic items (aka, rent) would see a long-term price increase. Production of other things can increase to meet the demand, and, in fact, you'll end up with a more vibrant economy overall. One can argue that this is the post WW2 US boom in a nutshell.
- maxerickson 8y agoThere's no fundamental reason that housing is inelastic. It's relatively inelastic, but not over medium terms, especially in a place like the United States that mostly has lots of room to build things.