3 ms·
Bravo! I hope this (and Nike with Kaepernick) is the start of a wave in society calling companies to task over advertising shilling. Personally, and I've expr
by munk-a 8y ago
Bravo!
I hope this (and Nike with Kaepernick) is the start of a wave in society calling companies to task over advertising shilling.
Personally, and I've expressed this numerous times, I find advertising to be absolutely devastating on the efficiency of modern society so... let's de-brand everything wee!
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoIn Soviet utopia, only one toothbrush. Very efficient, yes?
- vkou 8y agoContrary to the misconceptions of many people who have never actually lived in the Soviet Union, there were multiple, competing brands of consumer goods, all the way from radios, to automobiles [1] and refrigerators. [1] Off that list, of course, automobiles were very difficult to obtain.
- marviel 8y agoI see your tongue in your cheek; nonetheless, I have struggled with the very idea you entertain. Marking that a product comes from a particular place allows the non knowledgeable person to find more of that thing. A separate-but-related idea is that of advertising, i.e. putting the idea of a product out there separately from the good itself. Nobody thinks they like it, but I know that some of the more meaningful experiences in my life (finding local improv, for instance) have come as a result of effective advertisement. I suppose the problem is not that advertisement or branding exists at all --- but how it exists today. I don't know if this is the "resting state" of advertisement/branding or not.
- munk-a 8y agoAdvertising, at it's best, informs consumers of choice - if this were the type of advertising we saw in the modern world that's fine - posting a DIY tool shed build and including links to specific tools that might be useful is helpful, and I think that's why we've seen sponsored content come into prominence, briefly be useful, and then get swarmed by BS. We need to find some way, societally, to limit how much of this wave'o'advertising we're exposed to - to place a value on time and remove the "cold call" style of advertising pitches. I was optimistic about ad-words when it first rolled out because, given the context awareness and unobtrusiveness, I thought it might kill advertising dead - and it sort of did. We no longer have the "Shoot the pirate" flash banner ads, nor the popups for v1agr4 since that over the top attention grab ended up being pushed out by more relevant product advertising... but we're backsliding again. If you're an advertiser and I raise my hand and say "I'm looking for a power drill" or even "I'm looking for something to do on saturday" then feel free to make your case - but this unsolicited BS is like the bane that once was door-to-door salesmen, it's actually a hilariously parallel - your time is being taken, something is invading your private space and you're being interrupted from doing something you'd like to do to listen to someone shill.
- dahfizz 8y agoI'm curious why you think ads are so bad for efficiency. By and large, I only encounter ads in my "free time" and I'm consuming content, i.e. not while at work. Annoying to be sure, but not something that wastes my productive time.
- caf 8y agoNot my comment, but possibly they were thinking around the idea of modern advertising causing overall less rational economic decisions to be made by polluting the market with more objectively false information than true (resulting in products and services being purchased where the utility gained for the price is not maximised). As a hypothetical example, if a particularly effective marketing campaign resulted in the market preferring a particular poor quality lightbulb over an equally priced but better quality alternative, there would be an economy-wide misallocation of resources into building poor quality lightbulbs.
- munk-a 8y agoActually I was more referring to the effect that constant advertising has on our attention span and possibly even our society at large. We know we are constantly being fed B.S. so reading something with an open mind is difficult in the modern world, chances are there's some sort of sponsored content push in there somewhere - so we skim read before reading to check for ads, then we stop doing that second step and just take a surface scan of data. Our brains are so constantly bombarded with advertising that we're now receiving advertising, occasionally, for retreats where we can get away from all the advertising and noise of the modern world. I have a personal, lovely example for this which is so beautifully clear - sandwich boards. Sandwich boards are those tilted sidewalk signs that shops put out for anyone who isn't aware, they can cause a moderate increase in traffic to a store because they're annoying - specifically. Signs that are hung from an awning above a shop don't obstruct people so their attention doesn't catch them as often, while as sandwich boards are more than happy to block half the sidewalk and force you to walk around them in an effort to be noticed - their usage is valid when indicating a temporary state, since the cost of hanging an awning sign to let people know that the ping-pong tournament has been moved down the street is silly and often not an option - but when that board is just advertising an establishment (even if doing that advertising by letting you know about a sale) then they can often be seen below an awning sign that is perfectly visible from the same angle (window painting and displays tend to be less visible to pedestrians so there is a valid reason to have some angled description of your business) So, let's do away with all these sandwich boards - they exist for no reason other than to annoy us and get in our way. They occasionally make narrow sidewalks difficult to traverse for people with walkers or wheelchairs and what, as a society, are we getting for that cost? Nothing. Sandwich boards are a beautiful example of this since so many of us encounter them daily, but lots of other advertising goes out of it's way to be obtrusive, to steal some of your mind's attention (jingles) or to be visually distracting (flashy banner ads). This shit has costs that we all pay, and the value we, as a society, reap for paying that cost is dwarfed by the cost - people are already spending almost all their money constantly so this advertising war isn't to make sure people make informed choices, it's to steal the sale away from a different product.
- msla 8y agoAnd now that Colin Kavanaugh has made waves, others can tag along, and force still more companies to de-brand.
- noobermin 8y agoHow would you want such a wave to form, in the form of regulation?