3 ms·
Most of the techniques he describes for competing in a commodity business make you a non-commodity business, by definition. A commodity business with a network
by nostrademons 8y ago
Most of the techniques he describes for competing in a commodity business make you a non-commodity business, by definition. A commodity business with a network effect isn't a commodity; it's a business whose key differentiator is the network. Same goes for a commodity business with an exclusive partnership; its differentiator is the partnership. Branding is a way to differentiate in consumer's minds, user experience is a way to differentiate in consumer's hands, access is a way to differentiate by consumer's feet.
A commodity business is usually defined as one where products are essentially interchangeable between producers and the price is set by supply & demand in the market as a whole rather than for any one manufacturer's product. And therefore, there is only one way to compete: be the low-cost producer. That way, no matter what the price is, you will still be in business and still be making more than any of your competitors.
Companies use all sorts of techniques to be the low-cost producer. Southwest Airlines did it for many years by turning planes around more quickly, using only 737s (to reduce maintenance and ground crew costs), and flying into smaller airports where they could negotiate lower landing fees. Walmart did it by negotiating heavily with suppliers, taking advantage of economies of scale in their superstores, and investing heavily in logistics. Amazon uses many of the same techniques, plus a heavy investment in automation. Vanguard became the low-cost producer in investments by piggybacking off the price discovery of all other investment firms. GEICO became the low-cost provider in auto insurance by only insuring people who were pretty good bets to begin with (indeed, if you have a clean driving record a number of insurance companies can match GEICO).
The key for all of them is that cost is crucial and quality is secondary, because consumers don't make their purchasing decisions on quality in a commodity market. So if you're going into a commodity market, you need to have that same maniacal focus on controlling costs.
- apabz 8y ago"The more prudent (and profitable) strategy however, is to remember that your ‘offering’ is not the same thing as your ‘product’, so even while the latter’s commoditized, there’s ways to compete, and even stand out with an overall unique offering." That's the difference right? Even when the underlying product is 'interchangeable between producers', it doesn't mean your entire business needs to be. Even in your examples, airline seats and car insurance might be commodities but Southwest and GEICO can (and do) charge a premium to the lowest cost producer all the time- whether it's because of their brand, user experience, customer loyalty etc.
- nostrademons 8y agoWe don't usually call them "commodity" businesses, then. My examples are imperfect - Southwest and GEICO aren't pure commodity businesses, the fact that they even have brands indicates that. It's just that it's hard to point to examples that people have heard of when, by definition, a commodity business is one where you don't care who produces the product. A better example might be sugar, or wheat, or iron ore, or screws, but I have no idea who produces those. Actually, there's a good one: oil. Oil is a pure commodity business (gasoline is the same regardless of where it comes out of the ground), and it has the expected behavior. The low-cost producers (Saudi Aramco) dominates, and they maintain their advantage through a combination of strategic application of technology, economies of scale, and owning natural resources that others can't match. And when Wall Street analysts evaluate the health of an oil company, the #1 metric they look at (besides the price of oil, which affects the whole industry) is the cost per barrel of oil.