5 ms·
> Even knowing statistics, the average doesn't tell me much. Depends on what you're doing. Bill Gates and my wealth averaged won't tell me anything, but takin
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
> Even knowing statistics, the average doesn't tell me much.
Depends on what you're doing. Bill Gates and my wealth averaged won't tell me anything, but taking my average speed on the highway will give me a good estimate on when I'll get to my destination - in this case the 99th percentile is only interesting to highway patrol, and won't help me estimate when I'll get home. It depends on what you want out of the information.
- Armisael16 8y ago(the arithmetic mean is actually pretty bad for estimating travel time unless your speed stays in a tight band)
- lultimouomo 8y ago99th percentile over your average speed across trips it's arguably the most useful number, if you want to make almost sure you're not late.
- coldtea 8y ago>but taking my average speed on the highway will give me a good estimate on when I'll get to my destination Like in the Bill Gates example, if you had a clear highway and went with 100 mph for the first hour, and then hit a busy traffic and are going with 20 mph for the last 5 minutes (with no foreseeable end in sight), the average wont help you much. It's only really useful for this purpose when there is constant speed (as in school math problems), or few extremities (or when any extremities neatly cancel out). See how average can be misleading?
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIf the last 5 minutes of a trip are incredibly slow, there's no chance you'll be able to use estimates to determine when you'll get there anyways, as at that point you're not actually estimating, you're now there.
- coldtea 8y agoWhich is neither here, nor there. This is not about literally seeing into the future, and knowing about unforeseen events. This is about making the best prediction with the data you already have. And if (as per example) you had "1000 miles of 100mph and 100 miles of 5mph in some traffic jam" with 500km left to go, the average will be misleading as it will lose too much info to be able to help you give the best prediction. In that situation I wouldn't reach for the average, to make a prediction to the person waiting for me. Would you?
- dragontamer 8y ago> And if (as per example) you had "1000 miles of 100mph and 100 miles of 5mph in some traffic jam" with 500km left to go, the average will be misleading as it will lose too much info to be able to help you give the best prediction. This is literally the use case of the harmonic mean, a type of average. Harmonic mean gives you the accurate estimate in this case. As I stated before: its about using the correct calculation for the correct reasons. It requires an understanding of statistics, and the 5-different-kinds of average (mode, median, arithmetic mean, geometric mean, harmonic mean) to pick the correct one for any particular use case. The arithmetic mean in this case is simply wrong. Just... wrong. It is meaningless. You have to use the harmonic mean. -------- It takes experience and practice to know which "average" to use. But anybody can learn it if they put forth the effort. It is definitely teachable to high school, and even middle-school children. (Its just not commonly taught in America for some reason).