4 ms·
Sometimes, a bad question provokes good answers. I won't upvote bad questions, no matter the result. I will, however, upvote the answers. Good questions get
by wccrawford 16y ago
Sometimes, a bad question provokes good answers. I won't upvote bad questions, no matter the result. I will, however, upvote the answers.
Good questions get upvoted on their own.
- jey 16y agoYeah, it seems to me like the ideal weighting scheme would operate on (sub-)threads rather than individual comments, i.e. take the descendants' karma into account in some way when ranking posts.
- ihodes 16y agoThat's what I was getting at with this quick stab at a weighing scheme: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1854195 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1854195
- robg 16y agoIf a bad question provokes good answers, then I don't see how it could have been bad to begin with. The contrast I think of is in a classroom. If a student asks an ignorant question (is there another instance of "bad"?), isn't that a good thing? For them and for the other students?
- kd0amg 16y agoI've seen plenty of very informative posts which were essentially slapping down a troll.
- toast76 16y agoYou'd think, but in an online forum it doesn't work that way. For an example of this, see below for my intentionally contentious comment "questions aren't a contribution". It evoked some high voted comments, and yet the comment itself has been down-voted as having "no value". The irony of this is that it kind of proves my contention in the first place. The value of a comment is more about the response it generates than the comment itself. As you say, an ignorant student may start a worthwhile discussion, but it doesn't make the student (or their question) any less ignorant. My comment was rightfully down-voted for not contributing value to the discussion, even though the comments that stemmed from it do. The OP contends that if a question generates a vigorous discussion, then it must have it's own intrinsic value....which clearly is not the case. If it did, my worthless comment would have the sum value of it's child comments and therefore be the top rated comment of the thread. Quite the paradox. Every comment is (and should be) treated on its merits. A question with interesting answers doesn't mean the question itself was interesting or worthy of praise. "Why is the sky blue?", "Why do stars sparkle?", "What makes a rainbow" are all pretty dull kiddy questions, but they all have interesting answers.
- scott_s 16y agoSome questions are insightful. Others are important, and should be addresses as part of the discussion. I will often upvote questions that do not yet have an answer, but I would like to have an answer to. I upvote such questions both to attain such answers, and to encourage people to continue asking such questions.