3 ms·
If life is discovered on Mars, I'm going to be waiting to see if it is obviously Earth-based DNA. If so, then as excited as people will be, it won't actually be
by jerf 8y ago
If life is discovered on Mars, I'm going to be waiting to see if it is obviously Earth-based DNA. If so, then as excited as people will be, it won't actually be any particular sort of evidence for wide-spread life. It'd still probably be a reasonable candidate for discovery of the century, but not the millenium.
(We will be able to determine if it is has the same source as Earth-based life, because Earth-based life has a lot of things that seem like they ought to be free parameters, but are highly conserved across our entire ecosystem. This includes certain basic genes and processes and their exact "spelling" in genes, the mapping of DNA letters to proteins, and probably quite a few other things. Can't disprove a common third source that way, of course.)
- jbattle 8y agoOr ... do we have Mars-based DNA?
- jerf 8y agoI've seen the theory tossed out there, but it's hard to do anything about it. We'd need paleontologists on Mars to really be sure (to prove life that predates Earth, as a step 1), and we're a long way away from that no matter how you slice it. But as I understand it, the time scales work; for the same reason that Mars is basically a dried-up, used up planet now while Earth is flourishing with life, Mars was theoretically possibly habitable much earlier than Earth.