5 ms·
>WTF do you think they do all day? One would hope that they were trying to gain access to someone else's devices, as opposed to turning the guns towards their
by whatshisface 8y ago
>WTF do you think they do all day?
One would hope that they were trying to gain access to someone else's devices, as opposed to turning the guns towards their own citizens and economy. If a soldier showed up at my door and pointed their gun at me, my reaction wouldn't be "of course you're doing that, your job is to point guns."
- penagwin 8y agoSomethings like spying on American phone calls (or just their "metadata") I agree with. But somethings like breaking encryption, exploiting iPhones, etc. while they may be used against Americans can also be used against others. Essentially there's an arms race, and we use our tax money to sponsor our government in this race, with the hopes that they'll side with us. There really isn't another option unless you want to give a private entity this power, or not participate in the race (which I don't advise).
- JustSomeNobody 8y ago> Somethings like spying on American phone calls (or just their "metadata") I agree with. > But somethings like breaking encryption, exploiting iPhones, etc. while they may be used against Americans can also be used against others. Both of these can have a chilling effect on free speech, therefore I'm against the CIA doing this to citizens. The potential threat against citizens nowhere near outweighs the need to uphold our constitution.
- mywittyname 8y agoI think we all agree that they shouldn't do this to American citizens. The problem is we can't isolate their capabilities to just foreign persons.
- saagarjha 8y agoWe could make doing this illegal and enforce it…
- village-idiot 8y agoUnfortunately, other nation states might not care about US laws. Which returns to the above statement that it’s better for the CIA and Apple to be in a security arms war than it is for Apple and the FSB, at least from the perspective of an American.
- TremendousJudge 8y agoAs a "foreign person", I'd rather like for no organization to come and record everything I do just because I wasn't born in a specific place. Ironically though, the average American citizen is probably under more CIA surveillance than the average foreign person such as myself.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoI'd rather we didn't either. If we trust you enough to let you visit, work, whatever, then we should treat you respectfully.
- blattimwind 8y ago> Somethings like spying on American phone calls (or just their "metadata") I agree with. Why keep pretending the CIA is a foreign intelligence service?
- richardwhiuk 8y agoFor some of us, it is.
- yorwba 8y ago> One would hope that they were trying to gain access to someone else's devices, as opposed to turning the guns towards their own citizens and economy. Apple devices are sold all over the world, so there's no way of gaining access to the enemy's devices without that method also being applicable to everyone else. Actually using them on everyone else is a different matter.
- cdf2theworld 8y ago"the enemy's devices" Which enemy?
- Despegar 8y agoStrategic rivals: Russia and China Regional rivals: North Korea and Iran Authoritarian partners/allies: Turkey, Saudi Arabia, a bunch of other Middle Eastern countries A bunch of countries flirting with authoritarianism: Brazil, Hungary, Poland, Israel
- Mirioron 8y agoSeriously? This kind of stuff is exactly why countries are opposed to free trade and globalism. You listed two countries in the EU there, for example.
- apexalpha 8y agoYeah if Poland and Hungary are 'flirting with authoritarianism' then the US with it's current leader is too. If that sounds dumb to you, you should rethink the statement about Poland and Hungary.
- novaleaf 8y agoI don't think it's objectionable that any countries Intelligence Service tries to identify threats before it's too late.
- java-man 8y ago
- everdrive 8y agoNo one outside of America has ever bought an Apple device, obviously.
- soraminazuki 8y agoPeople outside of America also have human rights.
- everdrive 8y agoI never said it was moral or ok, just that it doesn't suggest that the purpose is spy on Americans.
- ilrwbwrkhv 8y agooh trust me... everything is tested at home first...
- ficklepickle 8y agoOr on Canadians. Our government has historically been very willing to let the USA experiment on unwitting civilians.
- rswail 8y agoHuman rights have never excluded foreign intelligence services from engaging in espionage.
- dictum 8y agoI'm yet to see a clear explanation for citizens not being as much of a risk as, say, a random foreigner located far away from your country. If anything, a citizen is more capable of carrying out a terrorist attack, or just doing any action some foreign power wants to perform in that country. The exception for domestic citizens seems to be just a concession for the masses and their representatives, not a pragmatic choice. Edit: a pragmatic reasoning could be compartmentalization — keeping citizens under the watch of a separate entity (e.g. FBI) but it doesn't explain why domestic mass surveillance should be ruled out.
- wefarrell 8y agoDomestic threats are outside of the CIA's scope.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThe constitution and amendments to it give us certain rights. It really doesn't matter if citizens are a much larger risk or not.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nickelcitymario 8y ago> "...it doesn't explain why domestic mass surveillance should be ruled out." It's a matter of who we have a responsibility towards. The government we elect in our own country is responsible to us, and as a people we widely do not want our government spying on us. (This is true in most if not all countries.) But that same government is NOT responsible to the citizens of other nations. The CIA has no responsibility towards Canadians (like myself) or anyone else who isn't American. I'm not arguing that this is ethically right. I'm just saying it's pragmatic. If you're not a citizen of my country, my country has no legal obligations to you outside of international law. And no country, to my knowledge, has ever tried to introduce the right to privacy into international law. Every country hates spies within its own borders, but seeks to have them inside of everyone else's.
- marnett 8y ago
- baddox 8y agoI think it's pretty fair (although naive, obviously) to expect soldiers and intelligence agencies alike to, you know, actually just keep us safe.
- JohnWilcox 8y agoIn a world where the citizenship and nationhood has been intentionally shattered to usher in a new globalist aristocratic feudal type system, where foreign threats are intentionally injected and infested and imposed upon “citizens”, you are going to see ever increasing rationalization and justification and threat events to push ever more authoritarianism to turn on their own “citizens”, more accurately described as human capital, that the elite need to shuffle around until they’re no longer needed when AI and automation and robotics takes over.
- DaggerDagger 8y agoLet's be real. It wouldn't be that surprising given how the world actually works. Assuming you aren't an oligarch.
- rswail 8y agoWell, by law, the CIA aren't allowed to spy on US citizens, that's the FBI's job. However, there's nothing stopping them sharing capabilities with the Five Eyes and asking one of them to spy on a US citizen...