7 ms·
Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen bandwidth
- brown9-2 16y agoThe discussion of this article over on reddit has uncovered some interesting past articles by the same author, and it seems he has a strong bias on this topic http://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/edxjp/level_3_outbid_akamai_on_netflix_by_reselling/c17dvwd http://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/edxjp/level_3_ou...
- RockyMcNuts 16y agotrue! every one of those 'Digital Society' paid promo links on memeorandum has the strong whiff of incumbent telecom corporate shilling. I have never seen one get popular there, and am quite surprised to see it #1 here. The key to this argument is whether Level 3 will have the same the same terms that Akamai and other CDNs do for non-Netflix content. Comcast claims that is the case, but I am not particularly inclined to believe them.
- wmf 16y agoMy understanding is that Level 3 (and Akamai and Limelight and soon everyone) has to pay Comcast for all traffic.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jerf 16y agoNo. The stolen bandwidth in question is between L3 and Comcast, not between you and Comcast. It's "stolen" because they had a contractual agreement which L3 is breaking, which is perhaps stretching the meaning of "stolen" but is defensible, I think. (Or at least so the story goes, I can't vouch for any element of it.) This is all sausage making details that go on all the time and shouldn't and probably still won't actually involve you.
- oogali 16y agostolen is not a stretch, it's absolutely invalid. in peering agreements, if your ratios are out of whack and you're pushing an uneven traffic distribution, you get a warning, and if it keeps up, you get depeered. in a transit agreement, like what comcast and level3 have. there's nothing to steal, you (comcast) pay for the bandwidth that comes across the pipe your get from your provider (level3).
- EdwardMSmith 16y agoExcept, both L3 and Comcast have said that they had a settlement-free peering agreement, in addition to the transit agreement. And that peering agreement is the one that they're having the spat about.
- zokier 16y agoInternet does not work that way. You have a connection to certain operators network (at certain bandwidth) and that operator may have connections to one or more other operators. There is no "internet" you have bandwidth to, only interconnected networks. The connections between operators can be classified into two classes. If the operators feel that they both get relatively equal mutual benefit, they may connect each other for free. On the other hand, if the other operator is reaping profits by hogging other operators bandwidth, then the operator who's bandwidth is being (ab)used may try to negotiate compensation, or just disconnect the other operator. edit: I think I should add a disclaimer that I'm not involved at this level of operations, so most stuff is just afaik, and may be false.
- jemfinch 16y agoI am involved at this level of operations, and your description is 100% accurate.
- danielnicollet 16y agodid you actually read the post? Consumer or Business ISP bandwidth is not at play at all here. We are talking ISP-to-ISP.
- jws 16y agoI still fail to see why a leaf node internet provider thinks they should be paid for receiving the data their customers have requested. Paying for transits is easy to understand, and in a complicated topology paying for bytes-in as a peer makes sense because they may be transits. For a leaf node network like Comcast, whose customers pay to receive bytes and pay to have their connections installed to then demand payment from producers for supplying those bytes seems unjustified. The author tries to hang this on the relatively higher build out cost per customer Mbps of residential nodes compared large commercial drops, but that is just different businesses. The residential providers already charge many multiples higher for bandwidth, this is just haggling about the multiplier.
- cynicalkane 16y ago? Just because an agreement doesn't make 100% sense to you doesn't mean it can be unilaterally broken!
- jws 16y agoAbove, I'm not speaking of any particular agreement. For the current Level3-Comcast issue, as I read that "article" they didn't break it, but Level 3 would cause operating conditions that made the existing Comcast contract no longer applicable, so they needed a new agreement of some sort.
- cynicalkane 16y agoIt's good that you qualified what you're saying, because the natural assumption is that you are talking about the particular agreement under discussion.
- jws 16y agoYes, especially when I used the companies as an example. HN: not just news, but a lesson in communication.
- tbrownaw 16y ago
- oogali 16y agoutterly stupid. comcast is a customer of level3, not a peer. even though marketing has blurred the lines (i blame overly ambitious hosting companies), there is a very large difference between peering and being a transit customer. what applies here is a transit agreement, even though george ou completely skips over that in his analysis by assuming comcast is not a customer. to be redundant: this is not a peering spat, because comcast and level3 DO NOT PEER, comcast is a level3 customer. customer. customer.
- pilom 16y agoRight, where comcast pays L3 to deliver what comcast has to send. L3 still needs to pay someone (either comcast or someone else) to take the what they have to offer. No one wants traffic, thats why L3 has to pay to send Netflix to customers.
- wmf 16y agoUsually in a transit relationship the customer pays for the whole pipe; there isn't accounting of incoming vs. outgoing.
- tbrownaw 16y ago> comcast is a customer of level3 It sounds to me like they used to be equals, and now Level3 is the customer.
- andrewvc 16y agoThe article does a decent job of introducing the concepts of peering and transit. However, it's pretty long winded and goes through a number of tortured justifications. Here's a much simpler explanation: Comcast is charging Level 3 because they can.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- extension 16y agoSure, but what I am trying to figure out, as a relative layperson on this topic, is this: Is either party making some outrageous and unprecedented demand that will bring about the end of the internet as we know it? Or is this just business as usual?
- blueben 16y agoIt's not business as usual, which is why it's a big deal. Comcast is trying to do something new. They used to get a cut of revenue from Netflix traffic because it was on Akamai, who pay to sit in Comcast's datacenters. Now that traffic is going to come from a peer. It's the same traffic, but Comcast isn't getting the revenue, and they're pissed.
- grav1tas 16y agoThat may be the case, but if the peer made a contractual agreement that limited the peering to symmetrical traffic, then Comcast should be free to renegotiate or straight up sever the peering under the terms of any contractual agreements....if this is what is allowed by what's on the contract. While people can hem and haw about the moral and ethical implications, it seems like this is something that is likely spelled out on paper somewhere. It seems like one or both organizations is fanning the flames in the media to rile up end users.
- gergles 16y agoThere's no technical evidence (you can check, quite easily, who's peering with who and if there's a cost associated) that L3 and Comcast are using a purely-symmetric SFP agreement. It's quite likely they aren't (consumer ISPs would never upload enough to large providers to get a symmetric agreement worth their while.)
- pilom 16y agoLots of people seem to be forgetting that content providers want to connect to customers just as much as the customers want the content. Comcast:"L3 you want to connect to all my cable customers fast and you don't want to pay even more to get to me through AT&T so lets make a deal." It makes perfect sense that Comcast should be paid for access to their customers.
- anonymous246 16y agoEven though Comcast customers already pay Comcast to receive those bytes? As others have pointed out above.
- spindritf 16y agoPaid magazines often still sell advertising space, same is true for paid cable channels, so it's not unheard of to charge both the "broadcaster" and the "receiver".
- jordan0day 16y agoBut that is a model in which the advertises is "subsidizing" the effective cost to the end user. (Whether or not it's an actual subsidy or just a nice bit of profit for the cable network/provider is anyone's guess.) Obviously, without legislation, the internet will end up being no different, with Comcast, AT&T, and ultimately high-traffic sites like espn.com nickel-and-diming each other and end users. Sticking to the principles on which the web was (allegedly?) founded doesn't hold much water in a shareholders meeting. I hate to sound so cynical and resigned to this fate, but left to their own devices this seems like exactly what the big ISP's and sites will do.
- pilom 16y agoI agree that it is very easy for this to lead to a bad situation for customers. But that subsidizing model still applies. You know how much it costs to connect a cable line to a house? That wiring costs 100s-1000s of dollars per house (why FioS went to apartment buildings first). Of course the end users are getting subsidies.
- ck2 16y agoHow exactly could an ISP ever match the upload volume of a downstream contract? It's technically impossible. Even without netflix, the download to upload ratio is huge.
- EdwardMSmith 16y agoMany (most?) large cable providers, such as Comcast, have co-location and hosting businesses. After all, they have significant server facilities and a serious traffic deficit to make up.
- rbranson 16y agoThey can't, which why this article is bullshit. Settlement-free peering agreements exist because they are mutually beneficial, not to directly generate revenue. Both benefit from cost savings and Level3 can deliver better service quality, which is a big competitive advantage in their business.
- rburhum 16y agoPersonally, I would take three extra network hops and a slower internet if it meant Comcast got screwed. Having been practically forced numerous times to use Comcast as a home internet provider because there were no other options, spent days (when you add it all up) on their stupid support line and having been bit by not calling after 3 or 6 months "trial" (or actually them putting you on hold enough - like 1+ hour), I dont care. This article is asking me to be worried/sorry about the equivalent of a child molester of ISPs. Sorry. NO
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- akamaka 16y agoIn case you're wondering who wrote this, they are closely connected to Comcast. From digitalsociety.org: "Digital Society is an independent 501(c)3 non-profit organization, funded by donations from Jon Henke and from Arts+Labs." From artsandlabs.com: "Arts+Labs partners include entertainment companies, software providers, telecommunications providers, artists and creators committed to delivering innovative and creative digital products to consumers." (including NBC Universal) From Wikipedia: "As of August 2010, Comcast's proposed acquisition of a majority stake in NBC Universal is pending government approval."
- RockyMcNuts 16y agoComcast statement - http://blog.comcast.com/2010/11/comcast-comments-on-level-3.html http://blog.comcast.com/2010/11/comcast-comments-on-level-3.... (also crap IMHO - I am not particularly inclined to believe their claim that Level 3 got same terms as Akamai and other CDNs for non-Netflix content)
- akamaka 16y agoThanks for the link. I see that the official statement is using much more measured language. I'm pretty amused by this quote: "what Level 3 wants is to pressure Comcast into accepting more than a twofold increase in the amount of traffic Level 3 delivers onto Comcast's network -- for free." Isn't Comcast paying Level 3 to deliver traffic to them? If Comcast is not happy with the price Level 3 charges them, can't they switch to a different tier 1 network?
- inafewwords 16y agoI'm waiting on Level 3 to call out Comcast on that specifically. That would make the argument of Level 3's accusation against Comcast.
- grav1tas 16y agoIn case your wondering, a funding paper trail for a non-profit doesn't entail bias in a writer for (or employed by) said organization. Bias in a writer doesn't entail factually incorrect information or invalidate a writer's arguments. This statement does not contradict anything explicitly stated by the OP, in case you're wondering.
- ashbrahma 16y agoLevel 3 found itself in Comcast's shoes back in 2005. They felt that Cogent Communications unfairly taxed its network and made the exact same argument that Comcast is making today, and even temporarily pulled the plug on its connection to Cogent, cutting off some parts of the Internet for millions of Cogent customers.
- nikcub 16y ago"Now it makes perfect sense how Level 3 managed to outbid Akamai since no CDN provider operating legally could outbid hot goods." I think he means contractually rather than legally, very big difference and suggests that this story is a beat-up. There is no way in the world that Comcast (a dedicated end user provider) was almost equal with L3 (almost dedicated to providing first-tier backbone to private networks and colo) Peering is interesting in that you can get a lot of free hosting if you find a company that does a lot of inbound but no outbound. We hosted all of the OpenBSD, FreeBSD and 100+ other projects au mirrors for 10+ years for free hitting peaks of gbits+ because of the provider having to make up peering arrangements. I imagine Comcast would be the same (we did it with a similar company - home broadband provider) This is definitely a case of Comcast attempting to double-dip and feeding a story to a journalist to get their side of the argument out (the journalist even put a hit on one of his competing publications for 'getting it wrong')
- netc 16y agoThe article talks about 5 times increase in volume of the traffic. Wouldn't it mean Comcast gets to make extra bucks even though number of Comcast customers who access Netflix will not increase that much? Right or wrong, Comcast wants a cut every time Netflix (or any one else) changes CDN provider.