2 ms·
Certification isn't going to work for the very reasons Klabnik revealed in this same post. > Even if you are the kind of person who thinks boycotts work, there
by jrochkind1 8y ago
Certification isn't going to work for the very reasons Klabnik revealed in this same post.
> Even if you are the kind of person who thinks boycotts work, there just aren’t enough free software diehards to form a large enough boycott. And even then, you’d want to do the boycott together, simultaneously, to send the message.
A licensing regime is the only way I know to _prevent_ someone else from taking your software and doing whatever they want with it. So without a licensing regime, they'd do that, it just wouldn't be certified.
The whole idea of certification relies on enough people insisting on using certified software. And I think the same reasons that didn't work, as Klabnik explained, for Libre vs OSI, it's not going to work for certification. In the end, people will use whatever is cheapest/easiest (and legal, or perceived-to-be-low-risk-for-them illegal) regardless.
I do see the issue's he's talking about and think they are real. I don't see any solutions. (I also think he conveniently avoided one of the reasons we're seeing license/open source splintering -- because of attempts to find ways to _make a profit_ off open source. See the Amazon/ElasticSearch dispute. This is a real thing going on in the landscape he's talking about, with maybe more impact than the ideological concerns he talks about, but is inconvenient for what he wants to talk about. I still have no solutions to it.)
- steveklabnik 8y ago> (I also think he conveniently avoided one of the reasons we're seeing license/open source splintering -- because of attempts to find ways to _make a profit_ off open source. See the Amazon/ElasticSearch dispute. This is a real thing going on in the landscape he's talking about, with maybe more impact than the ideological concerns he talks about, but is inconvenient for what he wants to talk about. I still have no solutions to it.) Yep, I didn't want to get into the details of what people are caring about here, because I don't think it's necessary to make the broader point. And I also mostly want to get people thinking about this, and priming them on specific things isn't as useful as just providing broad strokes. I do think that the relationship between capital and labor is a huge aspect here, along with the cycle of "thick client, thin client, thick client" that we currently see with the move to the cloud. As you say, those are other essays :)
- jrochkind1 8y agoRight on. I think it's probably as much of what's going on with open source as ideology (including beliefs about 'fairness') though. (Or maybe I'm just a Marxist who thinks material conditions usually are primary to ideology :) ). There were ways people made a living while producing libre/open source for the last 30ish years, that also produced quality, useful, sustainable software. I think those ways have broken down, and no longer do that. I could get into the details of what I think those ways were and why they have broken down (I tried to in an HN comment on one of the posts on ElasticSearch, the comment replies did not express consensus with me :) But it includes that the software we want now is 'more expensive' to produce, as well as increased 'rationality' from employers of developers). But regardless of the details, I think things like the ElasticSearch thing (there are many more examples; the whole variety of "open core" software) suggest it's probably happening. I think that's probably more fundamental to the splits around open source than ideological predilections or beliefs about "fairness", in that any solutions or succesful evolutions of "how open source-ish is done" will have to take account of them, not just ideological predilections. Will have to provide an ecology/economy where people can make a living while producing quality useful sustainable "open source-ish" one way or another. I see no clear solutions regardless.
- steveklabnik 8y agoI can get into some base/superstructure, for sure :)