2 ms·
> You have the right to license public domain images. Anyone does. Huh? If it's in the public domain, you don't own it, because nobody owns it. And if you don'
by pdonis 8y ago
> You have the right to license public domain images. Anyone does.
Huh? If it's in the public domain, you don't own it, because nobody owns it. And if you don't own it, and don't have permission to sublicense from the owner (which you can't since there is no owner), how can you have the right to license it?
I agree that you have the right to sell public domain content, if you can convince anyone to buy it (and apparently lots of people can indeed be so convinced). But I don't think anyone has the right to license public domain content.
> What might be illegal is if they said that you can't make a copy of this image without their license. However, I don't believe that they say this
From what I can gather, they have sent demand letters to people who originally created public domain content they claim to license, telling those people that they can't use the content on their website.
- mikekchar 8y agoIn copyright law, nobody owns the text. What you own is the right to make a copy. If you have a copyright, it is an exclusive right to make a copy. You can sell a license for someone else to make a copy. If the text is in the public domain, you also have the right to make a copy. You do not have an exclusive right. You can sell the right to make a copy, just like you can sell the right to jump up and down. Nobody needs that right because they already have it, but nothing is stopping you from selling it. Remember that in all "intellectual property", the "property" is a right, not the thing itself.