3 ms·
Very clever and well put. I have to let this one stew. That said, still in the camp of "nothing is wrong," I think. It is a tough pill to swallow that companie
by jchw 8y ago
Very clever and well put. I have to let this one stew.
That said, still in the camp of "nothing is wrong," I think. It is a tough pill to swallow that companies that build around open source software are fundamentally vulnerable, but perhaps it's time to swallow. Open Source has never been healthier even ignoring those contributions.
If X manages to corner Y into a proprietary license, does open source win or lose? I won't name names but I used to use a project that went open core and the "open core" part of it became gradually more useless over time to the point where many users just switched off. I think what needs to be established is that what's good for companies trying to monetize OSS is not good for OSS.
There's plenty of other models for OSS that work. I'm fond of Patreon as a new monetization model, for example. Won't exactly get you rich, but if that's ever the point of OSS, then it really is dead.
We probably won't live in a future where everything is OSS, but we live in a present with an amazing amount of excellent OSS and I'm willing to take that personally.
I think the certification idea is interesting, but I definitely need to think about it a lot more. While I personally don't mind where OSS is, I also would not mind new movements, either.
- steveklabnik 8y agoI didn't really get into what aspects of production that developers are thinking about today in the post, because I didn't think it was necessary to make my point. My point is to get some people thinking about this, not decree exactly what I think the issue is. I do think that open source is working. The question is more of, who is it working for, and why? Could it be made to work for more people? Is it working in the way we want it to work? For example, your comment is framed about the health of Open Source itself. I see a lot more developers concerned about the health (in many senses) of the developers who are working on open source, over the health of the idea of open source in and of itself. They're also concerned about corporate control (in a steering sense more than a "total control" sense) over open source and platforms that are open source. Can today's open source sustain itself? Sure, probably. Lots of things that are not fundamentally sustainable manage to last for quite a while. But I do think people are wanting something better, even if they're not totally sure what that is or how to get it. I mean, I don't fully know either :)
- jchw 8y agoFair point: open source isn't really my day job. But, I do ask, what qualifies as an open source developer? I definitely work on open source, even if it's not my primary work. If you only count people who work for OSS companies specifically... Isn't that a bit selection-bias-y?
- steveklabnik 8y agoI think that, in and of itself, is an interesting question!