5 ms·
I am somewhat sceptical of any easy chemical ‘enhancement’ treatments. If there was a simple chemical treatment that could enhance human performance with no dow
by simonh 8y ago
I am somewhat sceptical of any easy chemical ‘enhancement’ treatments. If there was a simple chemical treatment that could enhance human performance with no down sides, given millions of years of evolution you’d think out bodies would have figured it out by now. Especially if it’s an enzyme our bodies already produce. If it were a simple as produce more enzyme in the right place = better performance, why aren’t our bodies already doing it?
Of course performance enhancing drugs of various kinds do exist, but there’s always a risk or down side to go with it. The benefits are usually fairly marginal too. Maybe enough to bump the third best athlete in the world to being the best athlete in the world, but that doesn’t actually take much in objective terms. Furthermore the greater the potential benefits from a drug like this, in order for our bodies not to have already exploited it presumably the down sides must be commensurately bad otherwise the tradeoff would be worthwhile.
So ok, such a treatment might work and might be useful in certain circumstances but I think a very healthy dose of caution and scepticism about easy medical fixes is in order.
- empath75 8y agoEvolution doesn’t optimize for intelligence or lifespan, it optimizes for reproduction
- simonh 8y agoAnd therefore for those attributes which make one more likely to survive and reproduce in a given environment. On it's own, being stronger could be expected to make one more likely to have surviving offspring, but if it's at the cost of other detrimental effects like paranoia, excessive resource usage, shorter life span, etc then it might not be worth it. Similarly higher intelligence would be an advantage to survival and reproduction, but only if it doesn't come with excessive mitigating costs.
- dragonsngoblins 8y agoSee you say that, but evolution is a slow process and is ongoing, and is a blind idiot god dancing to a tune which has no consistent time signature. Unless a mutation is heritable enough/commonly occurring enough, and useful enough when it is only a minor change it won't be selected for. It might continue on and become useful eventually anyway if it isn't a detriment and that genetic line just happens to continue. Why do our bodies age? Because a collection of little mutations that are only detrimental years after reproductive maturity it turns out don't have a huge impact on the survival of those genes. Why can't we see as many colours as bees? Evolution figured that out for them. Why hasn't evolution figured out how to give us night vision or an extra set of clear eyelids like camels have? Those would be useful. Animals exist with all those traits so they are entirely possible. If you're objection is "evolution would have figured it out" you only need look to the animal kingdom and see how crappy humans are in lots of ways to realize that is a pretty crappy objection