3 ms·
A lot of people in this thread giving their personal experience, but failing to realise they're doing exactly the same as people who promote crystal healing or
by DanBC 8y ago
A lot of people in this thread giving their personal experience, but failing to realise they're doing exactly the same as people who promote crystal healing or homeopathy.
Depression is an umbrella term and it covers a wide range of experience. Some people will recover even if you do nothing to treat them; others will recover if you do anything (such as providing homeopathy) to treat them. Correcting for this is difficult, which is why respected organisations disagree about whether exercise works or not.
Felipe suggest that publication bias explains why other analyses don't show benefit of exercise as a treatment, but that doesn't make much sense. The only reason he sees such large effect sizes is because he includes huge amounts of low quality research.
When you restrict the analysis to good quality research the effect reduces and it's much harder to see any difference between no treatment and depression as treatment.
It's not particularly suprising that physiotherapists and sports therapists think what they do works. What is somewhat suprising is that HN routinely falls for it.
- EForEndeavour 8y ago> they're doing exactly the same as people who promote crystal healing or homeopathy. It's only exactly the same if you consider their formal argument in a vacuum, neglecting everything you know and reasonably believe about the world. An intervention with a plausible mechanism has a greater chance of being effective than an intervention with no conceivable scientific mechanism (healing crystals; homeopathy). Anecdotal evidence isn't high-quality scientific evidence, but it does work as a decision support method to think about what to study more carefully -- or what to stick with because it works for some reason and you don't have the resources to scientifically validate the effect. Furthermore, and this does overlap with the placebo effect as well as fraudulent medicine: if a specific person tests a mood-elevating intervention on themselves and perceives a benefit, nobody can contradict them. Not to defend ardent believers of nonsensical cures, but if it's stupid and it works, it's not stupid.
- your-nanny 8y agothis is a reasonable point. we know exercise does lots of things. we don't know that about homeopathy. hence it is more reasonable to suspect that exercise has an effect on depression than it would be for crystals and homeopathy.
- DanBC 8y agoSure, but we have the research and the only research that shows significant effect size for exercise would, if were done on homeopathy, show similar effect sizes. Since we know homeopathy is bullshit we can conclude that these low quality trials should be removed from our meta analysis. And when you do that the effect for exercise as a treatment for depression almost disappears.