3 ms·
Far as I can tell he's also off by a factor of 4. Tesla 85hw battery pack 1200 lbs. 3000 kw X 4 hours = 1200 kwh. 1200kwh/85kw*1200 = 170,000 lbs. A GE/NS D
by Gibbon1 8y ago
Far as I can tell he's also off by a factor of 4.
Tesla 85hw battery pack 1200 lbs.
3000 kw X 4 hours = 1200 kwh.
1200kwh/85kw*1200 = 170,000 lbs.
A GE/NS Dash 8 weighs in at about 390,000lbs
- stickfigure 8y ago210kwh for 3575 lbs comes from the tesla powepack specs: https://www.tesla.com/powerpack https://www.tesla.com/powerpack Furthermore, it makes zero sense to compare "3000kw x 4 hours" since diesel electric locomotives can run for N>>>4 hours. Furthermore, you're comparing the weight of batteries alone compared to the weight of a whole locomotive.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> Furthermore, it makes zero sense to compare "3000kw x 4 hours" since diesel electric locomotives can run for N>>>4 hours. This is simply you reframing the conversation from using batteries to allow hybrid electric trains to use short sections of non-electrified tracks to hybrid electric trains won't work because they don't have the range of a diesel locomotive. I'm going to put this down as you're unwilling to argue fairly and thus lost this argument.
- stickfigure 8y agoYou're not comparing hybrid against diesel-electric, you're comparing hybrid against fully electric. The cost of putting batteries in your rolling stock might or might not be higher than electrifying the last 5%. Either way, it's small compared to the cost of electrifying the 95%. Note that the eastern seaboard (with its bridges and tunnels and topography) is getting electrified; the long and flat midwest is not.