2 ms·
> especially when locations are far apart I don't think distance is a relevant factor: train tracks cost about the same as a two-lane highway while having high
by wongarsu 8y ago
> especially when locations are far apart
I don't think distance is a relevant factor: train tracks cost about the same as a two-lane highway while having higher capacity. Stations are fairly expensive, but when locations are far apart that's not a significant factor.
The bigger problem is that you can't profitably service low-demand routes with trains. Trains excel on high-demand routes but when you only want to move 20 people per hour a road has much lower operating costs.
- munk-a 8y agoI think this is also a big issue in state optimization of where to build trains. It is impossible[1] to build a speculative train route to try and gauge possibility so expansion tends to be quite conservative and slow, which is well warranted - additionally there are some compounding usage factors that make line placement hard even for buses. If a new bus line is made available users are likely going to slowly convert to using it - and an area with good bus service is going to encourage residents[1] that want to take advantage of that service. [1] In the history of the US, for example, train stations literally grew their own demand in many cases, causing non-existent or tiny towns to grow due to the availability of service.
- manigandham 8y agoThe difference is that roadways allow anyone to stop whenever and wherever they need to, while a railway requires stations to be strategically placed. Two major cities with high traffic between them can seem ideal but still not work out because people need effective last-mile transport too, and they have other places where they want go that requires a car.