19 ms·
Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other transportation modes
- esoterae 8y agoI find interesting that all these analyses of transportation modes generally fail to take into account the bootstrap and maintenance cost of the infrastructure. Roads are absolutely awful in terms of carbon cost, why isn't there more that takes this into account?
- hydrox24 8y ago> fail to take into account the bootstrap and maintenance cost of the infrastructure. Is the bootstrap cost different from the startup cost? Are they just synonymous?
- sooheon 8y agoMaybe if you're talking about a specific type of start up cost where toll revenues from initial infra pays for later construction. Probably just loose usage.
- manigandham 8y agoThis is rather obvious and has always been a major advantage of rail. The problem is the capital costs and real estate requirements of building the rail lines, especially when locations are far apart and there's already existing infrastructure that needs attention.
- AstralStorm 8y agoYes, such as roads, which can be replaced or built over with rail almost always. (Including light rail like trams.) The problem shared between both is lack of walkability. Not insoluble but requires more tunnels or overpasses.
- hannasanarion 8y agoIt's a lot safer to walk over train tracks than to walk across a road. Where walkability is a concern, light rail is an option. I'm moving from NYC to Denver, and their new light rail system seems like such an upgrade from the car-congested streets above a sweaty slow subway.
- laurencerowe 8y agoDon't do this in London or much of south east England, stepping on the electrified third rail will probably kill you.
- perfmode 8y agoNever thought of that. Just replace the roads with rails. Remove redundant links in the highway network. Sounds like a job for a graph algorithm straight out of CS 261.
- philwelch 8y agoI'm not sure you can just replace highways with railroads. Changing modes isn't completely free--you have to have enough parking for passengers, freight handling equipment for freight, and in some cases, you might have to load entire vehicles onto railcars. This cancels out a lot of the benefits of rail. But, you can definitely reuse or expand the same right-of-way you had for some of the trunk highways and run rail alongside it.
- shereadsthenews 8y ago“enough parking for passengers, freight handling equipment for freight, and in some cases, you might have to load entire vehicles onto railcars.” There is no successful rail station anywhere on Earth that has any of that junk.
- philwelch 8y agoWhich is why you can't just replace links in the highway network with rail.
- shereadsthenews 8y agoWhen you think of an American state with a growing population you can take the existing infrastructure as a given and plan for rail for your new capacity. Unless you are willing to say we're just not going to add transportation capacity for our new citizens, you face a choice of road, rail, or air. Rail is often a good choice. As for "far apart" this seems irrelevant. Ohio has a greater population density than does Spain, but Columbus, Ohio's principal city, hasn't had a passenger train in 42 years while Cordoba, with half the population, enjoys ten trains per hour service including a high-speed train to Sevilla, Madrid, and Malaga. Anybody could build a Columbus-Dayton-Indianapolis high-speed rail line but we lack the will to do it.
- philwelch 8y agoI'm curious how long Europe's famous rail infrastructure will continue to be cost-effective in the era of Ryanair.
- shereadsthenews 8y agoVery. Spain’s high-speed service killed the Barcelona-Madrid air route, which had been the world’s busiest.
- pmyteh 8y agoAnd taken the lion's share of London to Paris, which was also huge. But a combination of high-speed day trains and low-cost air has killed off many of the very long distance trains and most of Europe's sleeper services. So it's a bit of a mixed bag.
- sonar_un 8y agoFun anecdote here. Just last month my wife and I were in Barcelona and we needed to go to Madrid. She had her company buy a plane ticket and I took the train. We left at the exact same time and I took 100% public transportation and she had a car service on both ends and a plane ticket. I made it to our destination across the town from the Madrid central 45 minutes before she did.
- wongarsu 8y ago> especially when locations are far apart I don't think distance is a relevant factor: train tracks cost about the same as a two-lane highway while having higher capacity. Stations are fairly expensive, but when locations are far apart that's not a significant factor. The bigger problem is that you can't profitably service low-demand routes with trains. Trains excel on high-demand routes but when you only want to move 20 people per hour a road has much lower operating costs.
- munk-a 8y agoI think this is also a big issue in state optimization of where to build trains. It is impossible[1] to build a speculative train route to try and gauge possibility so expansion tends to be quite conservative and slow, which is well warranted - additionally there are some compounding usage factors that make line placement hard even for buses. If a new bus line is made available users are likely going to slowly convert to using it - and an area with good bus service is going to encourage residents[1] that want to take advantage of that service. [1] In the history of the US, for example, train stations literally grew their own demand in many cases, causing non-existent or tiny towns to grow due to the availability of service.
- manigandham 8y agoThe difference is that roadways allow anyone to stop whenever and wherever they need to, while a railway requires stations to be strategically placed. Two major cities with high traffic between them can seem ideal but still not work out because people need effective last-mile transport too, and they have other places where they want go that requires a car.
- ams6110 8y agoCycling is cleaner than any of them. So what?
- throwawayjava 8y agoHSR is a viable alternative to flights. Similar travel times are possible. Electrified rail is a viable alternative to suburb <-> urban center commutes. Similar/better travel times are possible. And in both cases rail is much more pleasant. E.g., ICE trains are way nicer airplanes -- anyone who thinks otherwise has never been on an ICE train or really enjoys being punished. I also prefer DB trains to being a passenger in a car on an interstate. Trains, when well-done, are much quieter, a much smoother ride, have much more comfortable seats, and offer the option to stand up and stretch if you feel like it. Cycling is never a replacement for either of those two use cases.
- sokoloff 8y ago> HSR is a viable alternative to flights. Similar travel times are possible. It's a viable alternative to short-haul flights. Boston to Las Vegas, San Diego, San Francisco, or Seattle is not really competitive by rail, even if the US had any high-speed rail.
- throwawayjava 8y agoSure.
- haimez 8y agoNot practical in the same space. What train or flight plans will you be canceling in favor of cycling?
- ams6110 8y agoNone. That's the point. Just because something is cleaner does not make it practical. Passenger rail isn't happening in the USA. It would take huge investment, and flying would always win on route flexibility. Once you build a rail line you're pretty committed to it. Flight routes can be changed on demand. Just get over it. We'll never see widespread intercity rail in the USA.
- mamon 8y agoOnce again, Americans are "discovering" things other civilized countries knew and implemented for a long time :)
- fastball 8y agoI don't think anyone is "discovering" this. The US has prioritized other modes of transport because the US had priorities beyond "how clean it is".
- perfmode 8y agoSuch as?
- jdietrich 8y agoAmong other factors, the US motor industry engaged in a criminal conspiracy to undermine urban mass transit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp...
- shereadsthenews 8y agoHow much coal it rolls, how much it ownz the libz, etc.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIndividual independence and convenience were a goal in American culture the middle of the 20th century, until the externalities of that were understand. There's some famous interview - can't remember with who - about how at the time getting a car gave incredible freedom nobody had experienced before. It was a big part of how people saw the American dream in the last century, before the impact was understood.
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoAnd now, having a car is seen as impending your freedom, funnily enough.
- temp-dude-87844 8y agoMost of the US freight rail system isn't electrified because the capital expenditures of doing so would be very large, and its return on investment in terms of direct monetary savings wouldn't materialize for many, many years. Since externalities aren't priced in, diesel-electric locomotives haul most trains in the US. More passenger rail isn't really being built in the US, because the capital expenditures of doing so would be very large, and its return on investment in terms of direct monetary savings wouldn't materialize for many, many years. Since externalities aren't priced in, the responsibility for transportation is largely distributed to individuals, who make daily use of road vehicles on roads that the governments fund, and travel long-distance by commercial airlines that make use of airports that governments support.
- pmart123 8y agoAnother issue is the local public transportation in most US cities isn’t adequate so travelers want to transport their vehicle with them. Although, rideshare services help alleviate this issue.
- PaulHoule 8y agoSome other issues are that high speed rail is not green, and it is not affordable either. So far as adding more passenger rail lines, it isn't easy. For instance, plans for HSR in California are unrealistic because you don't save any time from SF to LA unless you can go from downtown to downtown. Sure you can build track in the Central Valley, but it would be pretty hard to take enough land by eminent domain to build a track into the cities even if these people were not the most feared NIMBYs on the planet.
- melling 8y agoNo mention of China. They built 16,000 miles of high-speed rail in 15 years. They’ll be at 24,000 miles by 2025. The low/medium speed maglevs also seem interesting: https://gbtimes.com/china-tests-new-generation-of-maglev-train https://gbtimes.com/china-tests-new-generation-of-maglev-tra... A 70-100 mph maglev would be useful in a few large cities.
- gruez 8y agoI think it's relevant to mention [1] and [2]. A lot of things can get done if you aren't constrained by economic and political considerations. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19549466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19549466 [2] https://www.ft.com/content/ca28f58a-955d-11e8-b747-fb1e803ee64e https://www.ft.com/content/ca28f58a-955d-11e8-b747-fb1e803ee...
- paxy 8y agoEveryone is constrained by economic considerations. It's not like China has unlimited money. They are just choosing sectors and making bets on what to prioritize and what to ignore, same as everyone else.
- gruez 8y agoYou're right, but it's still relevant to note whether something is successful on its own accord, or whether it's being propped up by the government. If something can't be profitably done in a country as dense as China, there's no hope of it ever working in the US. At that point you might as well go with planes and spend the savings on carbon sequestration methods instead.
- nicoburns 8y agoRail is publically funded pretty much everywhere (i.e. it doesn't make a direct profit if you factor in infrastruture costs). Just because the market won't pay for it doesn't mean that it isn't worthwhile.
- Const-me 8y agoRoads are obviously worse but I’m not sure about airplanes. They’re measuring energy per passenger/km but I think ignoring the cost of building the infrastructure (the “get data” link is down). For roads and railways infrastructure investments are huge, both initial construction and then maintenance. Not only in dollars, in CO2 as well.
- Jedi72 8y agoAlso trains can derail, which takes the whole line out of action.
- hannasanarion 8y agoPlanes operate at the whim of the weather. High winds are way more common than train derailments, and they take out a hub, not a line.
- bdamm 8y agoTrains aren't hurricane proof either so we can take those right off the table. Of the rest, it takes very exceptional storms to blockade an airport for more than a few minutes. Delays that occur because of snow and fog are not because the commercial airliners can't fly in those conditions, but because the ground infrastructure can't clear the snow quickly enough, or because the reduction in visibility means increasing separation requirements on approach to landing and therefore reduces overall throughput. In places where it snows a lot there exists sufficient infrastructure to handle it (Chicago, Denver, Moscow). Even thunderstorms are not typically a big problem for commercial airliners and their airports; the controllers declare holds while the storm passes directly overhead and they're back in business in under an hour. And hubs that systematically are hammered by storms aren't hubs for much longer, a luxury that any railroad executive would kill for. This is particularly impressive if you compare average airliner delays to average Amtrak delays. Modern airliners are remarkably good at handling typical bad weather.
- ocdtrekkie 8y ago
- anarchop 8y agoDeisel freight trains are huge poluters with regard to particulate matter (PM). This actually causes cancer as opposed to CO2. Reducing PM without impacting fuel efficiency significantly is possible but requires investment. https://www.epa.nsw.gov.au/-/media/epa/corporate-site/resources/air/diesel-locomotive-emissions-upgrade-kit.pdf?la=en&hash=5CD9A9D2FE1E77371F10BE7D356DAA8290DBB1B9 https://www.epa.nsw.gov.au/-/media/epa/corporate-site/resour... Same goes for diesel trucks / busses. This type of change throughout the world would really improve people’s lives immediately.
- wongarsu 8y agoHowever PM is a fairly localized pollution that doesn't spread far. I don't think diesel trains that drive through the middle of nowhere are that bad. Near population centers it would be preferable to switch to electric locomotives.
- johnwalkr 8y agoThere's a handful of hybrid trains in Japan that are electric in urban areas and use a diesel generator in rural parts of the route. A quick search didn't reveal any running North America but considering diesel locomotives have mostly used diesel generators and electric motors since the 70s, it's not a stretch to think about implementation there.
- fopen64 8y agoThe question is, how much pollution per tku (tons x kms)? Even if it exhausted nuclear waste, it would be worthwile if it was 1 gram per trillion tku.
- int_19h 8y agoTrains are easier to electrify than any other mode of transport, though.
- dustindiamond 8y agoUnder Siege 2.
- mutt2016 8y agoTrains are a messy, loud and dangerous way of moving stuff. But yes, it's fuel efficient. But so fucking dangerous and primitive in so many ways. Rail needs a lot of technology, and then it will be amazing. I don't think it's thsy far off.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Trains are a messy, loud and dangerous way of moving stuff. How so?
- msla 8y ago> How so? You've obviously never lived next to a railroad. Trains can't stop. I mean, they can eventually stop, but when it comes down to it, the train is not stopping. Trains are relatively clean compared to trucks, but they still burn crap and spew ash and smoke. Trains are loud. That's... I really can't say it any other way. Trains. Are. Loud.
- saagarjha 8y agoYou also need a lot fewer trains than say cars or trucks, so on the whole they might be better off.
- cr1895 8y ago>Trains are relatively clean compared to trucks, but they still burn crap and spew ash and smoke. Electric trains exist, so it's pretty obvious that your rail exposure isn't as universal as you think it is. For example, all the NS trains in the Netherlands are electric and powered sustainably. https://www.ns.nl/en/about-ns/sustainability/energy/sustainable-energy.html https://www.ns.nl/en/about-ns/sustainability/energy/sustaina...
- msla 8y ago> Electric trains exist Not universally, so it's pretty obvious your rail experience isn't as universal as you think it is.
- bronco21016 8y agoI’ve visited Europe many times and I do like how the region is so easily accessible without a car, largely because of trains, but there are many more factors outside of just having trains. European cities are far more walkable and accessible without a car. For decades the US has just not been built up in this way so just dropping trains in doesn’t suddenly make them preferred and thus viable. The reason people drive small/medium city to small/medium city is because once arriving in that city they now need transportation while there. Currently the most convenient and cost effective way to do that is to simply bring the car you already own for moving around in your home small/medium city. If the US is going to move to an environmentally friendly passenger rail system it is going to take a MASSIVE cultural and shift in mindset to reshape cities across the country. Many of which are broke. I’m not saying it’s impossible or an unworthy goal. I simply think it is an extremely unlikely goal until mindsets shift and realize things need to be done differently.
- kikoreis 8y agoInterestingly, the cities are in part broke due to the infrastructure cost of maintaining sprawl — which only cars make possible.
- krferriter 8y agoAlso gas taxes in the US are far lower than in much of Europe. Gas tax is 5.9x higher in Germany than in my state of NC, for example. Gas tax is what funds a lot of infrastructure development.
- dorgo 8y agoThe purpose of gas tax is not bound to infrastructure developement. Germany may spend gas tax money for arbitary purposes. https://www.energie-lexikon.info/energiesteuer.html https://www.energie-lexikon.info/energiesteuer.html
- flo123456 8y agoGermany may spend anytax for arbitrary purposes though.
- jackcosgrove 8y agoRail requires significant investment to overcome the last mile problem, meaning the problem that often you need to walk the last mile from the station to your destination. Some may scoff at this but it is a major deterrent. Combine this with ride sharing apps and rail transit use has actually declined in the US in the past several years.
- reidacdc 8y agoThe last-mile problem is also a significant issue for freight rail. US rail companies have been abandoning low-traffic and branch lines for years, because the revenue from the sparse traffic doesn't cover the infrastructure maintenance costs. Being an efficient user of energy is not the same thing as being an efficient end-to-end mover of goods. The best freight rail money is in "unit trains", long trains with a single type of cargo with a single destination -- the canonical example is coal trains from Wyoming heading for power stations in the midwest, which makes good use of continent-spanning "trunk" infrastructure and avoids the "first mile" collection expense and the "last mile" disbursement expense. Trains are very good at that sort of thing.
- Symmetry 8y agoI really want a ride-sharing app that can plan a trip across transit modes, send me somewhere by train, then have a car waiting to take me that last mile.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoSounds good, but it's hard to see into the details. In the US,cars & light trucks constitute about 18% of energy use. But what percentage of that use is for travel that could move over to rail? (I'd wager that driving around town is the biggest chunk.) Further: should all US cars go renewable electric, that seems preferable to diesel-electric rail emissions. The railroads got hit hard back when autos came along a century ago, something similar might happen here. The article pointed at this 'Transportation Energy Data Book' (PDF) available), which is largely petroleum-oriented. https://cta.ornl.gov/data/download37.shtml https://cta.ornl.gov/data/download37.shtml. Throws a lot of data out, but no big picture in there. It DID note that US rail freight uses about 1.1% of petroleum, which might be impressive?
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoThere's not going to be any one magic bullet that solves all environmental problems forever. 18% of energy use is a colossally huge amount of energy.
- drtillberg 8y agoDevelopment follows transportation, and since the main method of travel in the U.S. has been rubber tires and individual vehicles for the last 80 years, naturally a train can't service a whole suburb or exurb efficiently. Trains have trouble in the U.S. because the technology allows--even requires-- central planning and authority on an active, everyday basis. If the transportation department goes on strike, we in cars keep driving. Not so for trains. Also it's not a fair fight to have a public decentralized asphalt road system compete with a highly regulated centralized private rail system. It's not a pure technology vs. technology battle-- the political aspects dominate.
- jackcosgrove 8y agoThe main reason US cities rely on automobiles is because the "job watershed" of a private automobile exceeds the job watershed of train systems everywhere in the US, even New York City. The job watershed is the number of jobs within commuting distance, whatever your tolerance for a commute is, given a transportation modality. In some cities the automobile job watershed is 100x larger than the transit job watershed. Transit systems, especially train systems, in most US cities are hub and spoke systems, centered around terminals in places like midtown Manhattan and the Chicago Loop. If you superimpose that hub and spoke model on top of an employment "contour map" that seeks a level (due to the desire to minimize rents), you'll see that there's a fundamental mismatch between what employers and residents want and the transit network. Rather than a unipolar peak at the transit hub, both employers and residents want to minimize rents which drives sprawl and transportation webs, as opposed to hub and spoke models. Transit has a future with ride sharing and bus rapid transit since those modes use a cheap, flexible network as opposed to an expensive, rigid rail network. Unfortunately, if you wish rail to become more important, its use is actually declining and has been for decades.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoAll of that is interesting but the article, and GP, were talking about interurban transportation, not commuting to work. The flexibility of bus networks (using road infrastructure that would needed anyway for commerce) is desirable to be sure in metropolitan areas, but not as applicable or useful to inter-city routes.
- jackcosgrove 8y agoYes, rail is suitable for arterial transportation. However intercity transportation by rail is crippled in the US because there are very few intracity rail networks to receive you at your destination, for the reasons I outlined.
- rtpg 8y ago>both employers and residents want to minimize rents which drives sprawl and transportation webs, as opposed to hub and spoke models. I don't think this holds up empirically? The US is home to some of the highest rents in the world. Mid-sized US cities have way higher rents than major cities like Tokyo or Paris. Or maybe this is the idea, but if so it has failed miserably at letting people on the lower end of the spectrum be able to rent stably
- mabbo 8y agoMy wife and I took a trip to the middle of nowhere in Wales last fall. Train to Cardiff from London, then from Cardiff to our little cottage in the Pembrokeshire coast, I drove for 2+ hours in a rental car, learning to drive on the left. The day after we arrived, we learned we could have caught a train to Fishguard, a tiny village nearby, and then the local bus would have gotten us within a ten minute walk from our rental house. It probably would have even been faster and cheaper than the car we rented. It sure would have been less stressful for me. It's not just that the cities are more walkable. It's a whole culture that says cars should not be required to live a full life.
- usaphp 8y ago> learning to drive on the left I guess it depends on a person, but I did not have any issue driving in Thailand, it felt natural after 10 minutes.
- rhizome 8y agoI've driven left-hand automatic and manual in England and I was fine in such locations as Trafalgar Square (within ULEZ now) and BFE Worcestershire. Once I learned the pedals aren't switched it became 300% easier.
- jodrellblank 8y agoAnd perhaps that London to Cardiff is 150 miles, less than New York to Baltimore, and that Wales is about as big as New Jersey. It's a whole culture that says places are really close.
- adrianN 8y agoContrary to popular opinion on Internet forums, almost all car trips in the US are less than thirty miles long and about 80% of all trips are less than ten miles long despite the country being pretty big.
- pjc50 8y agoYes and no; as a Brit I would probably have chosen a car for that trip, because local buses are infrequent and unreliable. Trips other than via London are often easier by car. The UK never really had the space to develop US-style suburban sprawl, even in its designed car-centric new towns like Milton Keynes.
- natch 8y agoFor now, yes. Electric vehicles backed by sustainable power, when we reach that distant but ever-nearing goal, will be pretty good. Not as fast as flying but maybe we’ll get practical commercial passenger electric aircraft at some point. On the delivery of goods side of things, the Tesla Semi should also be a game changer. Efficient and door to door. For trains, I’d love to see how much could be done with, say, a dedicated power (battery) car per pure electric locomotive. I’m not claiming this would be a win; it might be too heavy. But it would be interesting to know.
- baroffoos 8y agoElectric cars are still not good enough because they weigh so much more per passenger than electric trains
- natch 8y agoGood point. Wish we had more electric trains in the US. And you still need a solution for the last few miles after arriving at the train station.
- baroffoos 8y agoI think electric scooters are a valid solution to last mile problems. You can even bring your own on the train to have one on both sides.
- Guereric 8y agoArticle reminded me of this YT video from Wendover Productions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9poImReDFeY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9poImReDFeY. It covers many of the same topics with specific numbers used for comparisons in fares and fuel usage.
- xvilka 8y agoToday US, I believe, is at point of no return. I highly doubt we will see any considerable train system modernization, comparable to the Asian nations, EU, or, maybe, even Africa.
- dejawu 8y agoI bless the trains down in Africa
- selimthegrim 8y agoAh a 30 day NUMTOT refugee
- xupybd 8y agoWhy are they so expensive then? Here in New Zealand, I can drive most places cheaper than I can take a train. That's one person per vehicle vs a train car full of people. I just can't figure that one out.
- phire 8y agoKiwirail is mandated to make a profit. The cost of a train ticket will include the proportional cost of maintaining the rail network, the deprecation cost of the train and the passenger cars, staff to run it, along with a tidy profit. You are most likely comparing it to the cost of petrol, which is not the full costs of driving a car. Everyone always forgets to take into account the deprecation on your car, running costs, fixed costs (WoF, rego). For tax purposes, IRD estimates the true costs per km (including fuel) to be 76c. Using that 76c per km rate, your car trip is suddenly costing way more than the train ticket. Additionally, there is construction and the maintenance cost of the road network itself. That's all paid for by the government out of your rego and income taxes. Kiwirail is required to include that in their ticket costs, but it's hidden from drivers.
- xupybd 8y agoThanks, that actually clears it up very well.
- mettamage 8y agoBicycles are quite the pollutant
- bartimus 8y agoWhat I found interesting is that in the US the government had a huge role with developing the rail network while in the UK it was entirely done by the private sector. I'm from the Netherlands where the rail network started out as a state owned company. It then got privatized by splitting ownership horizontally. Meaning one company owns the rail network while other companies provide train services on top of that network. This in contrast to Japan where ownership is split vertically. Multiple companies owning sections of the network including the train services. It amazes me that the Japanese model is able to achieve their famous punctuality. To see multiple privately owned companies working together in perfect harmony. In the Netherlands the railway system still needs state funding every year. I don't see how we could ever transition to the Japanese model. Which is a shame. I think the optimal solution needn't and shouldn't be government designed. To see countries like Norway where the state is subsidizing electric cars. Then meanwhile it's the state owned company Equinor still extracting huge amounts of oil for export. That oil might not get burned in Norway. But it's going to be burnt somewhere regardless how clean the energy in Norway is. Achieving clean transportation in one country doesn't mean we're solving the CO2 problem if the states are still allowing oil to be extracted and exported to other countries. The problem is perhaps best solved by achieving renewable energy sources. Either through electricity or producing renewable (combustible) fuel sources.
- apexalpha 8y agoYou are now comparing a star-form rail network in the Netherlands that runs in a country of 300km by 400km to a fish-grate network that runs in Japan. Also, the famous punctuality comes from the Japanese High Speed train network, a network purpose built for a single model of train. There are no intersections, road crossings or freight or slow trains on that network. Obviously any Dutch train would also fare well on a purpose built track. But our tracks are shared with trains from the NS (Dutch Rail) as well as trains from the German (Arriva) and French (Veolia) operators, the German (ICE), French (TGV) and British (EuroStar) High Speed trains, thousands of tons of freight from DB Cargo and several other regional players. You're just comparing Apples and Oranges when you compare our open, star shaped rail grid to the Japanese purposebuilt Shinkansen
- 8y ago
- alexis_fr 8y ago...When studying the carbon cycle of trains, they never study the externalities properly. Ground footprint of tracks, maintenance, high-speed, I do grow tired of improper studies.
- contingencies 8y agoNot that they don't make mistakes, but trains are another thing China got right and get very little credit for internationally. 25 year plan, baby. In the words of Bezos: Still day 1. Ha!
- maccard 8y agoMy biggest issue is train costs. I live in Edinburgh, and I can fly to London in 6 weeks for £19, or I can get the train for £160. The overall travel time is roughly the same, but at 6 times the price it can be very hard to justify. Especially when you have to travel with more than one person.
- mostlystatic 8y agoFares 6 weeks in advance seem to be around £50, starting from £30 for a slower train.
- aj_g 8y agoAgreed--I want to take trains, but when I can fly somewhere and buy 10x the carbon offsets for the difference between the plane/train costs, well...I'm going to fly.
- cr1895 8y agoWhy is it so absurdly expensive in the UK? Privatization? Looks like that trip takes almost 4.5 hours. For comparison, a train trip from Groningen to Vlissingen in the Netherlands (about as far as you can go) takes a similar time but costs only 26.50 euros each way, whenever you get a ticket. It's only about 16 euros if you've got one of the discount subscriptions.
- mirekrusin 8y agoHow does it compare to electric cars?
- esotericn 8y agoAs others have stated, the layout of a city presents enormous issues WRT public transport rollout. If you take a train into a major metropolitan city like London you're sorted. You have a plethora of transport options available. For an area of at least five miles around the mainline station you come in to, buses are very frequent, a subway probably exists, other trains will exist, taxis/Uber will be easy, and so on. Contrast that with taking a train to a random Northern town in the UK. You can get there, sure. Now what? You're miles walk from anything, it's all a big car-like suburban layout unless the specific thing you're visiting happens to be in the old town. I generally tend to drive when visiting family for that reason alone, because otherwise it takes four or five times longer (not an exaggeration at all) to get anywhere once you're there. A 10-15 minute drive could be a 50 minute bus journey.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>When journey times are less than four hours, people usually prefer to travel by train instead of alternative options, such as air or road. I'm sure the airport security theater plays no small part in this. Would you rather sit on a train for four hours or spend two hours at an airport, get treated like cattle, get told you can't bring X Y or Z past security, get felt up by a stranger, and in a cramped tube for an hour? I'll take the train every time.
- sunstone 8y agoThis article is irritating in that it doesn't give a balanced and useful view of the transportation trade offs. Very likely the author is aware of them but chooses to sweep under the carpet what doesn't suit his narrative. A few observations to balance things out. First, rail is not the cheapest way to move freight, ships are by far, but rail is a distant second. Rail obviously requires a lot of upkeep on the tracks, in addition to fuel and maintenance, whereas ships and planes have very little cost to maintain the fluids they travel in. Electric transport on highways will quickly become very much cheaper than it is now because electric motors are much more efficient than fuel motors, solar and wind electricity costs are dropping precipitously, maintenance of electric motors is much less than fuel motors. Yes the roads still have to be maintained and heavier trucks mean much more maintenance. Clearly, optimal transportation and shipping requires a hierarchy of trade offs that depend primarily upon scale. Two large cities that are 200 miles apart (eg New York and Boston) can support the overhead of a passenger rail connection. On the other hand San Francisco and New York, while large are too far apart, while another pair of cities might be 200 miles apart but the city populations are too small to support the rain infrastructure. At the other end of the scale, an individual might take their bicycle on a 2 mile trip to the post office but would take their car on a 2 mile trip for the week's groceries. Between these two extremes is a hierarchy of trade offs and there is no "one size fits all". Not even close. Rail is not the solution to all our transport problems. Neither are cars or bicycles. Each has its niche. If ships had legs then they might come close but unfortunately they don't, not to mention they are kind of slow. So it's complicated but some trends might be usefully be predicted. Short haul flights will likely become cheaper as these planes become electrified and both energy and maintenance costs drop significantly. Trucking will become electrified and will compete even more effectively against trains and planes unless there is a labor shortage. Trains will continue to do what they are good at, long haul of heavy commodities and passenger service on intense routes. Electric cars will have lower fuel and maintenance costs so automobile miles will increase. Perhaps the sum total of all this will mean that medium and smaller sized cities will become more competitive vis a vis their larger cousins over the next 50 years.
- hutzlibu 8y agoTrains might be more efficient in terms of energy, but sadly they are much more expensive (here in germany), than going by car. (except for some special fares) And the car goes anywhere, anytime and the train does not. So no wonder, also here, for most people the car is the choice number one.
- jhrmnn 8y agoDoes anyone know a study that would look into all the implicit subsidies? Externalities in terms of environmental impact, building of roads/rails from general taxes, direct subsidies. Maybe cars wouldn’t be as cheap if all these things would be taken into account.
- hutzlibu 8y agoWell ... trains are not free from subsidies either. They are heavily subsidies, but I don't know whether in the end more or less than cars. (btw. carowners pay also a lot of extra taxes, on gas, the car itself, etc.)
- Symmetry 8y agoThe figures given in on the site are taken from actual usage and so include the fact that buses tend to stop and go more than trains, are less likely to be full, etc. That's a useful view but it's good to look at the physics based maximum efficiency when full view too. I really, really recommend Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air[1] for getting a good sense of the numbers right now the chart on vehicle efficiencies[2] [1]https://www.withouthotair.com/ https://www.withouthotair.com/ [2]https://www.withouthotair.com/c20/page_128.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c20/page_128.shtml
- sureaboutthis 8y agoJust as important is the ease of using trains but, in some cases, this just doesn't happen. I would often travel from St. Louis to Chicago for business and would think nothing of taking the train but I quickly realized how unreliable it was. A cold day froze the tracks making my five-hour ride a twelve hour one. When commercial traffic refused to let us pass through a couple of times, waiting for a pass through was the straw that broke that back and no longer think once about taking the train when my car gets me there just as fast at a more convenient time.
- mortdeus 8y agoSince were on the subject of proposing insane and impractical solutions to global warming ive been contemplating ways we could somehow still use up all the oil and yet not contribute to global warming. One crazy idea is that we build a space elevator out of carbon nanotubes, and then make a core component of it act as a pump to suck up oil and water from sea level all the way up into the outer regions of our atmosphere and then we run the steam powered electrical generators up there and send the electricity back down the elevator. Now this might sound crazy but lets seriously consider what we have to gain by this. 1. Physics are totally on our side in space. In a steam powered generator, the steam turns one side of the turbine and then must escape out to ensure too much back pressure doesnt build up and grind things to a halt. Along with this steam we also expel out the greenhouse gases generated from burning the fuel with it. The thing is once we expel the steam and CO2 it goes out in a mixture and we cant really do a whole lot to sustainably trap it, store it until it cools off, and just reuse it, and all the while figure out some way to separate out the greenhouse gases and try to do something with it so we dont have to just release it into the air. The thing is, burning oil to produce steam in space solves a lot of problems like this for us due to the physical properties how things work in the vacuum of space vs where there is no atmospheric pressure. 1. If you expel a mixture of steam and C02 into the cold vacuum space the water vapor will rapidly turn into liquid and then solid while the greenhouse gases remain gaseous. This leads to easier methods of filtration and water recycling. The C02 is forced out into space and the water stays to be sent back down. 2. Wait, sent back down? Yes because to make the pump work up without too much energy being required to suck it up against the power of Earth's gravitational pull (think of this like trying to suck a think milkshake through a straw a mile long) its best to utilize the downward pull of gravity to aide us in the process. Thus creating a vacuum. 3. When we run out of oil we can send up nuclear fuel next and just shoot the spent highly radioactive fuel that's no longer useful to us into space too. 4. The electricity generated can be used to power the electromagnetic elevator up and down. 5. We'll need a space elevator to make solar sails work anyways. We might as well utilize it to generate energy in every we can. 6. If any of this manages to blow up on us the explosion happens hella far away from us. 7. Surface level renewable power sources like wind, hydroelectric, and solar are all things we can utilize effectively assuming we build it in the most optimal place. (my best guess is somewhere in the ocean just south of Alaska)
- beatgammit 8y agoI think one of the biggest issues that prevent making things better for passengers isn't necessarily the cost of building the infrastructure, but the acceptability of the status quo. The benefit to going with rail isn't dramatic enough to inspire urgency. I really think it would be useful to completely eliminate most vehicles from city centers. Only mass transit would be allowed, and walking/cycling would be prioritized over that. People would go to one of the parking lots (which would also be train stations) outside the city and take mass transit to go to some common hub of the city. Since driving directly to your destination is no longer an option, catching a train closer to your house and improving mass transit automatically becomes important, and lower pollution and traffic within cities will improve many aspects of city living. Also, since roads would be much smaller, buildings can be built more densely, which improves walkability and livability of cities. However, people are currently addicted to cars, so the conversation will likely never happen.
- Kaiyou 8y agoTrains solve a different problem. They are no good at transporting more stuff than you can carry. Also, they do an excellent job spreading infections.
- eleitl 8y agoA pedelec (human-electric hybrid) on dirt roads is considerably more energy efficient (Wh/km/passenger) than trains even before factoring in the embedded energy of the vast infrastructure rail needs.