5 ms·
VPNs are "trust me" security, and Cloudflare certainly has a better reputation than many VPN services, so, in that regard, Cloudflare's entry is welcome, but...
by neilv 8y ago
VPNs are "trust me" security, and Cloudflare certainly has a better reputation than many VPN services, so, in that regard, Cloudflare's entry is welcome, but...
I've been using Tor as a privacy-friendly VPN, so Cloudflare getting into this business will make it feel a bit different, every time I see an error Web page that says Cloudflare is blocking a Tor exit node from viewing a page that Cloudflare hosts.
Perhaps Cloudflare could figure out how to block competitor Tor less (even if there's abuse coming in through Tor)? That might be difficult, but an excellent show of good faith.
- rrix2 8y ago> Perhaps Cloudflare could figure out how to block competitor Tor less (even if there's abuse coming in through Tor)? That might be difficult, but an excellent show of good faith. they are: https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-onion-service/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-onion-service/
- xxdesmus 8y agoIndeed, we've gone to great lengths already to make the experience over Tor less painful -- for example supporting Proxy Pass: https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-supports-privacy-pass/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-supports-privacy-pass... in addition to the onion service that rrix20 mentioned.
- gpm 8y agoAn interesting trick - if Cloudflare allows it - would be Device -> Tor -> This -> Internet. Tor provides anonymity, this provides protection against exit nodes maliciously modifying traffic (you can find a number of examples of this just by searching).
- mirimir 8y agoYes! Routing VPNs through Tor is a great way to avoid site discrimination against Tor users. But there are two key problems. One is that you degrade Tor anonymity, because Tor can't switch circuits (normally at ~10 minute interval). And also because you typically must pay for VPN services. The other problem is that Tor only routes TCP traffic. So when you use TCP-based VPNs routed through Tor, and are using HTTPS or some other TCP flavor, you get the TCP-in-TCP horrors. There's too much error correction. So yes, Cloudflare would need to allow Warp via Tor. Or maybe even better, Warp via Tor via Warp. And also it would need to protect Tor anonymity. Cool idea, though :)
- marshray 8y ago> Warp via Tor via Warp Warp would see all your incoming packets and all your outgoing packets, so why bother with Tor?
- mirimir 8y agoGood point. I was getting carried away, there. But still, if it were done right, that's not necessarily true. I mean, I can have two accounts with some VPN service. I connect to server1.vpn.com using one account. Then I connect to the Tor network via that VPN tunnel. And then I connect to server2.vpn.com via Tor, using the other account. Even better, I connect to server2.onion, using the other account. Even then, Cloudflare could easily do traffic correlation. But as it is now, the NSA can easily do traffic correlation. So hey.
- caprese 8y agoBasically run Tails as the host OS then setup a computer at various data centers/locations around the world that you can route your traffic through (its a VPN now) and then either 1) run a Virtual Machine in that which connects through VPN 2) run a remote machine which connects to the outside through VPN