3 ms·
Isolation doesn’t work (as you point out with NK). Integration also doesn’t seem to be working (well, not nearly as fast as those in the Nixon era and since th
by mensetmanusman 8y ago
Isolation doesn’t work (as you point out with NK).
Integration also doesn’t seem to be working (well, not nearly as fast as those in the Nixon era and since then hypothesized).
My view is that isolation is a worse route, because mostly the poor suffer from economic isolation.
I really like the strategy of targeting the powerful politicians/rich benefactors using tools like the magnitsky act. Those people shouldn’t have the privledge of traveling to western countries.
- salawat 8y agoWhich is completely useless unless you also lock them out of the western financial system. The lack of physical presence isn't that big a showstopper anymore. Throw in an inability to exercise financial clout anymore though, and things will rapidly change. There likely isn't much political will for that though, and I'm fairly certain it could only come after a period of weaning the economy off the luxury of cheap as dirt manufacturing/shipping.
- tracker1 8y agoA lot of the mfg costs have been offset by automation. Where China now has the advantage is vertical markets in close proximity. You have chips, boards, cases, plastics all created in proximity which adds value. Not too dissimilar to Detroit in the 50's and 60's, a lot of vertical and related markets had footholds in the area. I think if you isolated China economically, the US and other markets would be able to build their own competitive versions within a couple years. What is concerning to me is an increasing movement under a different name that would lead to similar policies in the US over time. At least comparing the rhetoric to communist theory in the early 1900's.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoWhy restrict it to western countries? The UN is made to form a huge bloc of countries that should be aimed at preventing the atrocities seen in WW2 (and before); so far, given what's happening in NK, China and the US it doesn't seem very effective. (I included the US because it has the highest incarceration rate of the world which disproportionately affects a racial minority; if prisons were relabeled as re-education camps and what happens in there is hidden from the world they would be on par with what China is doing atm)
- azinman2 8y agoRight... except a judicial system not only put people in there, they have the ability to challenge it. This is not an analogous situation.