7 ms·
Whataboutism is “X isn’t bad because Y is worse/also bad”. Parent was saying “X will probably be bad because similar Y was bad in the same dimension (here, ove
by SilasX 8y ago
Whataboutism is “X isn’t bad because Y is worse/also bad”.
Parent was saying “X will probably be bad because similar Y was bad in the same dimension (here, overpromising)”.
Maybe not a solid argument, but it isn’t whataboutism.
Edit: Never mind, it looks like I misread the parent's point, and he was saying that it's no big deal to promise something without being sure you can deliver because the Big Three did it with pensions.
- unityByFreedom 8y agoYou've used different phrasing to say the same thing.
- SilasX 8y agoOn second thought, I misread the argument, and I agree it's whataboutism. See edit. (However, if my misreading had been correct, it wouldn't have been whataboutism, as it would be a prediction that Tesla would also be bad.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]