2 ms·
As a Scandinavian, I think that makes no sense. Germany introduced modern welfare reforms long before Scandinavia: Bismarck - a far right monarchist - introduce
by vidarh 8y ago
As a Scandinavian, I think that makes no sense. Germany introduced modern welfare reforms long before Scandinavia: Bismarck - a far right monarchist - introduced a pension system and healthcare insurance in the 1880's. His rivals on the right at the time mockingly accused him of being a "state socialist", and he embraced the term, because his intent was to out-flank the socialists of the time by offering limited concessions that went further than even some Marxists. At the same time as he offered the carrot, he applied the stick: dozens of socialist organizations and newspapers were outlawed, their leaders arrested.
Through European history, we've seen universal healthcare and pensions and general welfare reforms come about largely as a result of the combined efforts of two groups: growing labour movements, and Christian democrats. In Germany Bismarck leaned on the Catholic party Zentrum, forerunners of the modern ruling centre-right CDU, and argued heavily from a point of view of Christian morality to get his reforms through.
In Norway, the first welfare reform was introduced in 1894, after Bismarcks model. After World War II, there was broad agreement across the board for welfare reforms, but it was first a broad coalition of centrist and centre-right forces that introduced the first major expansion of welfare: The Borten government, led by the agrarian "Centre Party", in coalition with Left (classic liberals), the Christian Peoples Party (centre right Christian democrats) and Right (classical small-c conservatives, which in Norway makes them the traditional right wing, but relatively moderate). They certainly got the support of the left, and the Labour Party subsequently expanded the welfare system, but the foundation of welfare in Norway like in most of the rest of the developed world was not a unilateral expansion of socialism but reflective of a combination of growing labour movements and Christian morality.
Some notable exceptions: In the UK, the Christian voter groups are split between Labour the Conservatives, for example, with internal factions in both causing tension.
What is unique about the Scandinavian model is not healthcare or higher pay per se, but the compressed pay scale. It's a bit embarrassing to earn "too much" in Norway, for example. Salaries ranges are much flatter.
But that is not just due to Scandinavia changing, but due to the rest of the world changing. Look at pre-Reagan America for example, and executive pays were a far lower multiple of the company averages.