3 ms·
Yes, the patch would be illegal, but the original author still wouldn't have all the rights on it. And it could also be illegal if the original author distribut
by littlestymaar 8y ago
Yes, the patch would be illegal, but the original author still wouldn't have all the rights on it. And it could also be illegal if the original author distributed the amended code elsewhere.
Edit: I edited my comment to say “could” instead of “would” because the original author could argue that the author of the patch implicitly gave him the right to redistribute his patch by contributing it to a public repository. I'm not sure it would stand in court, but I'd say it would have a non-null chance of success.
But If the author, who initially claimed the project was a learning project, decided to use it commercially, he clearly wouldn't be allowed to use the patch. (and again, it could be different if the patch author willingly contributed to a commercial product).