2 ms·
Pretty much all the TOS says is there's an implicit reproduction license (other users can see & fork the work) and possibly broadcast (the fork itself has the v
by masklinn 8y ago
Pretty much all the TOS says is there's an implicit reproduction license (other users can see & fork the work) and possibly broadcast (the fork itself has the visibility of the original). Not adaptation, not use, not exploitation, …
And that license grant is solely through github as a service, it's unclear that a local clone is even permitted.
- blattimwind 8y ago> And that license grant is solely through github as a service, it's unclear that a local clone is even permitted. That license grant has been added specifically to make GitHub itself waterproof (AIUI), so it makes sense it doesn't extend to user's rights. Look, but don't touch.
- Zarel 8y agoThat's... somewhat true. My main objection is to "the author is the only one holding every rights on the code and every use that is not explicitly allowed is a copyright infringement (unless it's fair use)". The ToS doesn't say there's an implicit reproduction license, though; it says there's an explicit reproduction license. The other licenses can still be argued to be implicit. For instance, you have a decent argument that local clones are an implicit license – GitHub provides a "Clone or download" button directly on the repo page, and it's one of the main use cases of GitHub. (Other arguments exist.)
- littlestymaar 8y ago> The ToS doesn't say there's an implicit reproduction license, though; it says there's an explicit reproduction license. Then it's totally excluded from my claim which aims «every use that is not explicitly allowed». :)