4 ms·
The obvious theory for different pain sensitivity between men and women is that women need to handle childbirth. Since that is unique to our species, animal te
by BurningFrog 8y ago
The obvious theory for different pain sensitivity between men and women is that women need to handle childbirth.
Since that is unique to our species, animal testing probably won't be helpful there.
- reallydude 8y ago> Since that is unique to our species, Much of the animal kingdom has the same issue of painful childbirth. What you mean by "handle", I can only guess. Perhaps something about recovery and a desire repeat.
- Foober223 8y agoDo you even science bro? Child birth is unique to humans. Animals lay eggs, like dinosaurs and Easter rabbits.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Much of the animal kingdom has the same issue of painful childbirth Do they? As far as I was aware, humans have a uniquely awkward childbirth due to our cranial size.
- mcv 8y agoNot only that. No other animal menstruates quite like humans do either; there's been an arms race between the placenta and the womb, and rather than a safe place to protect the fetus, the womb is more of a safe place to isolate the fetus and manage its access to the mother's resources while keeping the mother safe. Human pregnancy is messed up beyond the obvious issue of squeezing our large brain through out narrow running hips.
- black-tea 8y agoYeah, a baby is literally a parasite. Fortunately it's quite easy for women to avoid accidental pregnancy these days.
- fifnir 8y ago> an arms race between the placenta and the womb, and rather than a safe place to protect the fetus, the womb is more of a safe place to isolate the fetus and manage its access to the mother's resources while keeping the mother safe. I don't see anything human-specific here, this would have been true for all placental animals no?
- mcv 8y agoIt doesn't sound inherently human-specific, but somehow it is. Well, other primates have it to a lesser extent, but other placental mammals don't, and we have it worse than other primates. Why only primates have this arms race between placenta and womb, and why humans have it worse than any primate, I don't know. But it's definitely a thing. It's the reason why humans menstruate while non-primate mammals don't.
- hadlock 8y agoGoogle "hyena birth"... I do not recommend doing this at work, or during lunch.
- SigmundA 8y agoProbably referring to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstetrical_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstetrical_dilemma
- wahern 8y agoI would think it's much more indirect than that. We know women have much more robust immune systems than men do, presumably partly because of the rigors of pregnancy, dangers of child birth, and demands of child rearing. And this is true across species. What was immediately fascinating to me about this article was the relationship between the immune system and pain sensitivity. Women suffer from autoimmune disorders much more than men because of their stronger immune systems. Makes one wonder if differences in the pain pathways are adaptive to the stronger immune system. Regarding painful child birth, from an evolutionary perspective it would only matter if the pain itself resulted in less reproduction. The pain is rather fleeting, all things considered, and worst for the first child. And there are many ways for natural selection to mitigate any negative impact on reproduction, such as flooding the woman with hormones that make her forget it, increasing sexual desire, etc.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYou only need minor differences in women's pain sensitivity resulting in minor changes of rates of second children, to have real evolutionary impact. The interesting part is why this wouldn't result in changes for both men and women. I think the answer is that pain sensitivity is useful, so the evolutionary pressure for men kept it up. I should say that this is my private speculation. I'm not aware of any established science supporting this, though it might exist.