3 ms·
I agree, I made that number up. I’m speculating that the average across the entire country is rather small, and that the primary mode of transport for the avera
by dahart 8y ago
I agree, I made that number up. I’m speculating that the average across the entire country is rather small, and that the primary mode of transport for the average person is a car.
But one question here is whether that matters at all? Even if the distance is much longer and doesn’t involve a car, isn’t a single use bag/carrier still ridiculously wasteful?
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI suspect the average person using a car won't pay 10 cents extra for a plastic bag given the choice, and the data seems to bear this out. A surcharge ensures only the people who need a bag will use one. > But one question here is whether that matters at all? Even if the distance is much longer and doesn’t involve a car, isn’t a single use bag/carrier still ridiculously wasteful? The fact of the matter is that without a car, I need something to carry my groceries. Another commenter posted this article downthread: https://theconversation.com/plastic-bag-bans-can-backfire-if-consumers-just-use-other-plastics-instead-110571?mc_cid=3e3bfe8208&mc_eid=07419f81f0 https://theconversation.com/plastic-bag-bans-can-backfire-if... > A shopper would need to reuse a cotton carryout bag 131 times to reduce its global warming potential [...] below that of plastic carryout bags used once to carry newly purchased goods. To have less impact on the climate than plastic carryout bags also reused as trash bags, consumers would need to use the cotton bag 327 times. I'm legitimately unclear why the second number isn't "infinity". By my estimation, plastic shopping bags + zero trash bags should have the same (or worse) emissions as reusable shopping bags + plastic trash bag. Regardless, I am also unconvinced I'd be able to reuse a cotton bag more than 300 times before it tears, or I somehow lose it, etc.
- dahart 8y agoI can be in favor of a per bag charge or tax or other alternatives, if that’s what needs to happen. I’m not arguing that a ban is the solution, just pointing out that single use plastics do use a crazy amount of resource compared to the benefit they provide. That’s tautologically true regardless of environmental concerns, right? We don’t put on a brand new shirt every single day or buy a new car every time we drive, right? I admit I’m a tad skeptical that there’s ever a true “need” for single use bags & containers. Entire countries are proving this isn’t the case. Once time has passed and everyone expects to have to bring their bags, there’s no problem. This is what already happens outside the U.S. Keep in mind when citing numbers about the environmental offset of cotton bags that plastic single use bags are not offset at all, they’re basically 100% damage. And how many re-uses of a plastic bag would it take to offset them? Estimating the reuse numbers isn’t comparing apples to apples, IMO, it’s using narrative to make reusable bags sound tedious and inconvenient. My wife and I have some reusable bags that we’ve used daily for years, possibly a decade. I’m sure we’ve used them thousands of times, if low hundreds of uses is all it takes, then it’s really not very hard to achieve offset once you get some good bags.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> Keep in mind when citing numbers about the environmental offset of cotton bags that plastic single use bags are not offset at all, they’re 100% damage. And how many re-uses of a plastic bag does it take to offset? I don't understand what you're saying here. Both cotton and plastic bags produce some emissions; which one produces more will vary depending on how often each type is reused. I need some way to carry stuff. > My wife and I have some reusable bags that we’ve used daily for years, possibly a decade. I’m sure we’ve used them thousands of times, it’s really not very hard to achieve offset once you get some good bags. And I'm guessing you have a car. To be clear, my life will continue without plastic bags, so in that sense, there's no "need". But I heavily suspect I'll end up producing more carbon overall, for a bunch of reasons I've explained upthread: I'll be using more paper bags (which I can't reuse), and I'll be buying plastic trash bags.
- dahart 8y ago> I don’t understand what you’re saying here... which one produces more will vary depending on how often each type is reused. Exactly. Free plastic bags at the grocery store are not intended and not build for re-use. They are in fact on average used only once. Cotton bags are designed and intended for re-use. So, there’s very little point to comparing their carbon offsets. Single use plastic bags never achieve carbon offset in practice, as opposed to cotton bags which sometimes do. > And I’m guessing you have a car. We have bikes and use them for grocery as often as possible. I do have a car and I feel the same way about cars as single use plastics; they’re incredibly wasteful and we could really use a cultural behavior change to reduce their use. > I heavily suspect I’ll end up producing more carbon overall ... I’ll be using more paper bags, and I’ll be buying plastic trash bags. Just curious, is buying plastic trash bags a change from what you’re doing now? Replacing plastic grocery bags with paper is carbon positive and renewable, so that doesn’t sound like a larger carbon footprint to me... I’m a bit lost where we’re going, and it feels like we’re talking past each other a little. I’m looking for some things to agree on, not disagree on. A per bag charge is a behavioral incentive, right? And all else being equal, throwing away something that can be used again is wasteful, right? Are you mainly trying to say that you believe free single use plastic bags are the most environmentally friendly thing we can do right now? *EDIT, never mind, I read your other thread, I understand what you’re saying about using more carbon now as a result of the law change. So, I don’t know. You might be right that your footprint is getting worse as a result, and I can see you’re actually worried about it. I’d hope the law was well considered enough that on average it’s a reduction across the New York population, even if it’s forcing some folks like you into bad habits.