5 ms·
I reuse every single plastic bag. I live in a tiny studio in Manhattan and they serve as small, free garbage bags. Without plastic bags, I'll have to buy garba
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
I reuse every single plastic bag. I live in a tiny studio in Manhattan and they serve as small, free garbage bags.
Without plastic bags, I'll have to buy garbage bags (which are too large). I'll also have to carry around a reusable bag when I go shopping—which prevents me from going shopping on a whim, since I can't keep bags in the trunk of my nonexistent car—or use the paper bags which are still allowed. Ironically, this will cause me to be more wasteful, since I can't reuse paper bags!
They should just charge 10 cents per plastic bag. Heck, charge 20 cents. Lawmakers seem to have rejected this as a "tax on the poor", but is taking away the option from everybody any better?
- bluntfang 8y agoITT: this person is provided with many alternatives to help not use plastic, but is somehow able to find a problem with all of it. Newsflash: we fucked up. big time. we're all very comfortable with our wasteful lives. It's going to be uncomfortable to change our behavior. It's worth it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 8y agoNewsflash: plastic bags are only wasteful if you don’t reuse them as small garbage bags. If you use paper bags and buy small garbage bags, you are worse than the person using the plastic bags.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoYeah. I do feel a bit like I'm making excuses to everyone's (much appreciated) suggestions, but I also feel like my problems are legitimate when, as far as I can tell, this won't actually reduce my carbon emissions. That's the core issue. Global warming is an urgent problem, and I'm more than okay being inconvenienced to help with that. I don't think this helps, at least not relative to a surcharge. As an aside, all of this stuff is effectively scribbling in the margins. Same with plastic straws and biodegradable utensils. That doesn't make these moves bad or even unnecessary, but I worry they're distracting from what is most urgently needed: major taxes on carbon emissions.
- bluntfang 8y ago> I also feel like my problems are legitimate Listen, refusing to carry a book bag when you know you are a compulsive shopper is not a legitimate problem.
- balfirevic 8y agoYeah, just carry a freaking book bag or backpack everywhere with you that you don't actually need because you might go to the store. WTF is happening here :-D Also, compulsive shopper was probably not what you wanted to say.
- dingaling 8y agoI've noticed that as a difference between Car People and Non-car People. The latter tend to have a backpack or other general-purpose bag with them at all times containing wallet, keys, bottle of water, waterproof jacket, reusable grocery sack etc. After a while it feels naked to go out without it. Whereas Car People leave that stuff in the car or shove it into bulging pockets.
- bluntfang 8y agoIt's called being a human with needs and solving those needs. yes carry a back pack wherever you go. Am empty back pack is light and you won't even notice it. I guarantee there are things that you use everyday that you can put in there. Like a user below me suggested, a water bottle is a great first thing to carry with you everywhere. It's not that you might go to the store either. OP explicitly said they do not know when they are going to shop. It is random, therefore either change your behavior to be more predictable or prepare yourself for your known unknown. Excuses like these are childish unless you have accessibility issues.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoYou're being awfully high and mighty jumping around this thread to criticize what is, on the scale of typical human consumption, really quite minor. Do you own a car? Have you flown in the last year? Do you eat out or get food delivered to you? How often do you get a new laptop? Do you use air conditioning? Apparently it's socially acceptable to look down on someone for using plastic bags, but it would be uncouth to suggest that someone use public transport or vacation domestically. The latter examples would be an actual sacrifice, and we only want to make token gestures to feel good about ourselves and move on with our lives.
- amyjess 8y agoHell, not just as garbage bags. I reuse my grocery-store plastic bags whenever I need to transport a bunch of small objects somewhere. Let's say I have some snacks at home, and I want to bring them to the office. What to do? Grab a Kroger bag and put my snacks in there! (edit: also, since I check my mail infrequently, they come in really handy when I go to the mailbox, especially if I'm doing so on the way to work)
- mac01021 8y agoDoes anyone buy trash bags that small? Either way, I don't generate nearly enough by trash to keep up with the stream of grocery bags I bring home.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> Does anyone buy trash bags that small? This is one of those areas where I think it makes a big difference whether you live in a proper house or a tiny apartment. In a small studio, a large trash bag can take a week or more to fill up, but can start to smell up the small space after only a couple days. So I—and a lot of people I know—use smaller bags and take them out once every couple days.
- pinot 8y agoYou're not the use-case this is trying to solve however.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoWouldn't charging 10 cents per bag (or more) solve the problem and allow for my use case? I also don't think using plastic bags as garbage bags is all that unusual for people in small NYC apartments. A coworker was voicing the same complaint on Friday, for instance.
- Zach_the_Lizard 8y agoIt's definitely not unusual. Source: I do the same thing and I live in New York
- citiguy 8y agoMe too
- hannasanarion 8y agoLucky for you, you can get your plastic trash bags you so adore for exactly the price you suggested: 10¢ per bag https://www.amazon.com/Bathroom-Trash-Bags-Garbage-Products/dp/B078H7XNXD/ref=mp_s_a_1_1_sspa?adgrpid=54480144925&hvadid=274750003102&hvdev=m&hvlocphy=9003535&hvnetw=g&hvpos=1t2&hvqmt=e&hvrand=13337072289946944850&hvtargid=kwd-2785408868&keywords=small+garbage+bags&qid=1554065619&s=gateway&sr=8-1-spons&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/Bathroom-Trash-Bags-Garbage-Products/... And in the meantime, the rest of us don't have to deal with the millions of bags that are bought every week just to be thrown away the same day.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThis helps but doesn't really solve the problem—I don't have a good way to carry a reusable bag around with me, and doing so doesn't help the environment in my case. I understand why a law was needed, I just wish they'd gone with a surcharge, which would likely have solved the core issue.
- kareemm 8y agoTry one of these. They fit on a keychain: https://www.amazon.com/ChicoBag-Original-Reusable-Shopping-Grocery/dp/B006WA9LRA https://www.amazon.com/ChicoBag-Original-Reusable-Shopping-G...
- seltzered_ 8y agoAs another suggestion, i've been using the 'sea to summit ultra-sil sling bag' for years and have gave them as gifts. They compress into a small bag if needed, can be zipped up (if walking back through rain), and tend to double when travelling as a clothes-packing bag. - https://www.amazon.com/Sea-Summit-Ultra-Sil-Sling-16-Liter/dp/B006CG380U https://www.amazon.com/Sea-Summit-Ultra-Sil-Sling-16-Liter/d...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- mft_ 8y ago1. Buy smaller garbage bags. They definitely exist here in Europe; I can't imagine they don't in the US? 2. Why can't you use one of the paper bags provided by the retailers to support your whimsical impromptu shopping trips? Or are you really a very regular whimsical shopper?
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> Or are you really a very regular whimsical shopper? All the time, yeah. I don't usually plan to go shopping, I just walk into the grocery store when I pass by. I probably will use paper bags—but, ironically, I feel crappy about the environmental impact, since I can't reuse them as garbage bags.
- tyre 8y agoWhat do you use for recycling? I use the paper bags for paper and cans
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI use boxes from Amazon or similar. I have far too many of those already.
- jacobolus 8y agoHere in San Francisco, we use a paper shopping bag with a flimsy biodegradable plastic bag wrapped around the bottom as a compost bag (the outer bag keeps in water/grease and keeps the paper bag from falling apart). The SF compost bin accepts a wide variety of material, and as a result we don’t generate much landfill trash.
- mattnewton 8y agoWhat’s wrong with paper bags for your use case?
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI can't use them as garbage bags because they can't hold anything even slightly wet, like food scraps.
- seltzered_ 8y agoFor food scraps, get a bag-free composting bin. I use one that uses one big silicone reversible thing that inverts to push food out and can be thrown in the dishwasher: https://www.amazon.com/Polder-Composter-Flexible-silicone-emptying-cleaning/dp/B0775MPRML/ https://www.amazon.com/Polder-Composter-Flexible-silicone-em... For other things (kids/pets/etc.), purchase biodegradeable bags. There was a recent article on this subject: https://theconversation.com/plastic-bag-bans-can-backfire-if-consumers-just-use-other-plastics-instead-110571?mc_cid=3e3bfe8208&mc_eid=07419f81f0 https://theconversation.com/plastic-bag-bans-can-backfire-if... "Who were the people who reused plastic carryout bags pre-ban, and presumably bore the burden of buying trash bags post-ban? I found that bag reuse was higher for people who purchased pet items and baby items – in other words, who needed to collect and dispose of excrement. In 2017, nearly 6 percent of U.S. households had a child under 5 years old, 44 percent owned a dog, and 35 percent owned a cat." My take on this is that if you express the interest in having a child or a pet, you can afford the burden of buying biodegradable bags to handle waste. Perhaps there could be some assistance program for some low-income affected segment (i.e. adding biodegradable bags to a WIC-friendly item list).
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoSigh, I know I should be composting, but it's difficult. It's not offered in my area, and I don't want the smell in my tiny apartment. > My take on this is that if you express the interest in having a child or a pet, you can afford the burden of buying biodegradable bags to handle waste. If the law said that stores were allowed to give out biodegradable plastic bags (maybe at some small surcharge?) I'd be fine with that. Doubly so if the law actually suggested or incentivized switching to these types of bags. As far as I'm aware this isn't what's happening. The numbers in that article were pretty striking to me, btw: > A shopper would need to reuse a cotton carryout bag 131 times to reduce its global warming potential [...] below that of plastic carryout bags. > To have less impact on the climate than plastic carryout bags also reused as trash bags, consumers would need to use the cotton bag 327 times.
- blondie9x 8y agoI use one garbage bag 5-8 times. I continuously sort what I can to be recycled then dump the rest out of the bag directly into the bin. The bag will last for two months or so before I need to get rid of it and use it when I dump the trash. Try this?
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoWon't work sadly, my building has a garbage shoot. I can't just dump loose trash down that! (Also feels kind of gross? The point of a small bag is so the trash won't stink up my tiny apartment.)
- blondie9x 8y agoGet a little covered bin for under the sink or something then get a mini bag. U will easily be able to dump it into the chute. No excuses!
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThere's actually a sign on the trash chute that says not to dump loose items in there. Has to be in a bag of some kind.
- seltzered_ 8y agoI almost never use garbage bags. The trick is separating out food scraps / recycling / non-recyclable garbage. Most of the actual 'garbage' is...plastic bags from packaged food items and dental floss. Disclaimer: I live in a city where composting / recycling / trash is done in separate containers. Even if one doesn't life in such an area it shouldn't stop one from pre-separating anyway even if it gets merged.
- stephengoodwin 8y agoSeattle permits retailers to charge 5 cents per large paper bag.
- Johnny555 8y agoIf you really want to use this type of bag for trash you can buy 900 of them for $15 on Amazon, 1.7 cents/bag: https://www.amazon.com/Inteplast-THW1VAL-Handled-T-Shirt-Polyethylene/dp/B004MDM6LC https://www.amazon.com/Inteplast-THW1VAL-Handled-T-Shirt-Pol... fold one up and keep it in your wallet when you go out and you always have one ready for impromptu shopping trips. I stopped using shopping bags as garbage bags long ago 'cause too many of them were leaky, and more than once I left a dripping trail on my way to the garbage chute. I just keep a folding reusable shopping bag in my laptop bag (that I always have with me when I'm commuting), so when I stop at the store on my way home it's always ready. If I don't have it handy, then I just pay the 25 cent fee for a paper bag.
- jogjayr 8y ago> Without plastic bags, I'll have to buy garbage bags (which are too large) Use produce bags for trash instead. I don't even bag all of my produce - just delicate leafy greens and things like green beans that's hard to keep together - and even then I have enough bags for my trash. > since I can't reuse paper bags! Why not? Is it because they fall apart or something?