3 ms·
> Am I wrong to conclude that this result itself is an argument for the existence of dark matter? Only if competing arguments that account for the rotational
by dnautics 8y ago
> Am I wrong to conclude that this result itself is an argument for the existence of dark matter?
Only if competing arguments that account for the rotational speed discrepancy in galaxies fail to explain "galaxies without dark matter", which... I think they do? (I am not 100% sure on this).
Of course occam's razor is only a heuristic, and not a law, but we would prefer a theory that is simpler, and if we have to add an extra level of indirection explaining why some galaxies lack dark matter, then that is less desirable in a theory. Repeating myself, science doesn't necessarily do what we desire.