4 ms·
I'm not seeing why this is paying tax on the same thing twice? You'd have a new cost basis, so you'd only pay again if it went up even more. Even if it's on the
by skybrian 8y ago
I'm not seeing why this is paying tax on the same thing twice? You'd have a new cost basis, so you'd only pay again if it went up even more. Even if it's on the same property, that's a separate gain and this is effectively dividing a single large gain into two smaller gains, one of which happens earlier.
It seems like the question here is how long you can delay taxes on a capital gain. It doesn't seem particularly unfair if you can't always delay capital gains tax as long as you like?
- sokoloff 8y agoMy example conflates (or does not clearly distinguish between) partnerships (taxed as passthrough) and companies (taxed twice possibly). In the place I referenced taxed twice (only possible as a company), assume the federal rate on everything is 40% [to make the math forum-calculation-friendly]. Company starts with $200K, held 50:50 by two shareholders, losslessly buys two house for that, those go to $300K, company losslessly sells one of them for $150K, company pays $20K tax on $50K gain, and then owns a $150K house and $130K in cash. Shareholder B sells their 50% share in the company to shareholder A for $140K cash, realizing a $40K capital gain on their original shares investment [incurring $16K in taxes on the gain in their shares]. Shareholder A now owns all the shares with a basis of $240K for a company value of $280K. I argue that Shareholder B’s economic interest in a single gain has been taxed twice.