7 ms·
Except these institutions are not paying taxes on the gain?? > Typically, when you sell a stock for more than you paid, you owe tax on the gain. But thanks to
by icedchai 8y ago
Except these institutions are not paying taxes on the gain??
> Typically, when you sell a stock for more than you paid, you owe tax on the gain. But thanks to a quirk in a Nixon-era tax law, funds can avoid that tax if they use the stock to pay off a withdrawing fund investor.
- jayess 8y agoThe person who initially invested does. I don't see at all how this is a tax dodge.
- URSpider94 8y agoThe person who individually invested doesn’t have to pay the tax until they sell their shares in the ETF, perhaps decades later. That’s generally considered a tax dodge because deferral of taxes lets you keep that money and compound it. $10 of taxes deferred for 30 years at a modest interest rate of 2% puts an extra $8 in the investor’s pocket that should have gone to the government.
- sokoloff 8y agoI'm not sure that's a "generally considered" definition. By that definition, I'm dodging taxes every year I don't sell my shares that I hold in my brokerage account.
- URSpider94 8y agoFrom your other comments, I see why you don’t want it to be this way, which is a valid philosophical point. However, this is how the tax code treats any transaction today. You’re right you don’t owe tax if you hold a single company’s stock, but you do if you hold a mutual fund that trades its underlying shares during the year, or if you trade one stock in your portfolio for another. You owe it even if you sell a stock for a net profit and buy it back for exactly the same price ten minutes later. ETF’s are treated differently ...
- icedchai 8y agoPlease explain. Just holding a mutual fund won’t generate any taxable events... except for dividend/distributions... just like a stock. Buying and selling ETFs are also treated just like a stock.
- URSpider94 8y agoNot true. Every year, a mutual fund is required to distribute an amount equal to the capital gains realized by the fund in that year. For a mutual fund that trades actively, that could be a sizeable fraction of the amount you have invested. This is cap gains, not a dividend. Stocks and ETF’s don’t do that. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capitalgainsdistribution.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capitalgainsdistributio...
- icedchai 8y agoGood to know! My funds generate relatively small capital gains distributions (most of what I see on my 1099's is from dividends) so I never noticed it. Edit: Though now that you mention it, I think I must've known this at some point in the past: that ETFs had preferential tax treatment. A while back, I moved my most recent investments to ETFs, even for the "same" fund (example: Vanguard Tech VITAX mutual fund vs VGT ETF) ... Still, how are ETFs treated differently from a stock?
- pertymcpert 8y agoThat's fine.
- DamnYuppie 8y agoAgreed I see this more as a transfer than a dodge.
- vxNsr 8y agoThe underlying investors do when they cash out.
- gph 8y agoYes, but the investor will pay more in taxes when they sell the actual ETF. It's more like deferring taxes than avoiding them. Think of it this way, if the fund paid these taxes when they sell their various holdings, that less tax amount would be baked into the ETF valution, which would carry over to a smaller tax bill when an investor sells their ETF shares and pays taxes. That's still advantageous in many ways, but I think people in this topic are thinking this is some kind of complete tax avoidance. It isn't.
- icedchai 8y agoYes, I do agree the end result is likely beneficial to the average Joe trading ETFs...
- menage 8y agoPresumably the withdrawing investor also gets the fund's cost basis in the stock, so they'll be on the hook for the fund's capital gains themselves when they sell the stock. (The article didn't explicitly mention it, nor does the relevant statute https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/852#b_6 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/852#b_6, but that's the standard way that stock transfers work.)
- zaroth 8y agoI think the basis stays with the fund, and the capital gains are due when the ETF holders sell their shares. The bank does not get hit with any capital gains due to the lower basis of the fund. The bank has their own basis in the shares that they brought into the fund which when traded for the other shares may trigger its own separate capital gain. The shares the bank gets back at the end should have price equal to basis by that point I would think.
- toast0 8y agoI'd like to see details on that part. My guess is each side of the exchange keeps their cost basis and just divides it over the new to them shares -- like in an untaxed merger stock transaction. Otherwise, it would be a competition to send the other party stocks with the lowest cost basis.
- sokoloff 8y agoSuppose you and I take $100K each and mutually invest 50:50 in something together. Maybe we bought two identical houses for $200K total (or even bought a duplex together). Later on, the houses have gone up in value to $300K, even later I decide that I want out, we look things over and decide that the fair thing is for me to take one of the houses. At the moment that we take that action, no tax is (nor ought to be, IMO) due. Later, when/if I sell the house, tax is due on the $50K in gains. Just like in the ETF case. In the alternate treatment seemingly contemplated by the article, we could instead agree to sell one of the houses, jointly pay taxes on $50K in gains, and give me the sum of $150K-taxes, the gains of which I'd pay taxes upon again. You'd also have effectively paid taxes when you hadn't done anything but invest and hold. There's a pretty good argument this is unfair to me (to tax me twice on one gain); there's an almost ironclad argument that it's unfair to you. It's no surprise that the treatment that is both more reasonable and more profitable is the one that ETFs seek to implement. (Fees and other weirdnesses around real-estate ignored above for simplicity.)
- URSpider94 8y agoYou may decide that tax ought not to be due when you take one of the houses, but under the law it IS due. For me to take one of the houses, we would have to change the ownership structure and there would be a transfer price for that.
- credit_guy 8y ago> change the ownership structure and there would be a transfer price for that The transfer price in gp’s example would be zero, wouldn’t it.
- URSpider94 8y agoProbably not. If the transfer price is zero, then that now becomes my tax basis in the property. So assuming again that I put in $100k originally, and now take out one house worth $150k, then sell it, I’m going to pay capital gains on the full $150k, not just my $50k gain. What probably happens is that I sell you my share in the holding entity for $150k, and the entity sells me the house for $150k. There are cases where you could simply dissolve the entity and distribute the assets, which would avoid the sale and resulting taxes, in which case you’re just re-titling it and not selling it. Tl;dr: this gets complicated really quickly.
- vmarsy 8y ago> Except these institutions are not paying taxes on the gain?? Why should they? They are not people. When you buy an item for $50 at a store, as a consumer you would pay sales tax on it. But every transaction made from the buying of raw materials up to the time the store sold you the item is done tax free by the businesses, only at the time of sale to the final consumer, a tax is due. Here ETF is kind of similar, except that the consumer provides the raw materials: A consumer buys the ETF at a share price of $100, and sells it once the ETF reaches $150: $50 should be taxable to the consumer. Instead of it being categorized as "sales tax" it's "income tax" or "LTCG tax", but the principle is the same. If the institution made money off that transaction, by charging someone a $5 fee for instance, then tax should be paid on those $5 by the institution, but I don't see why amount the fund grew should have an impact. It goes both way obviously, if the consumer buys an ETF a $100 but sells it at $75, the institution should not be able to claim a loss on those $25, but that doesn't seem to be something claimed by the article.