3 ms·
I have some problems with that same quote. The "disproportionate price appreciation of housing and the land it sits on" seems to me to be primarily a factor onl
by mcguire 8y ago
I have some problems with that same quote. The "disproportionate price appreciation of housing and the land it sits on" seems to me to be primarily a factor only in some (maybe most) large cities; outside those cities, price appreciation, perhaps excessive price appreciation, has occurred, but it's nothing like that in those few cities. My feeling is that, sure, the effect of real estate prices are large in real terms, but compared to the rest of the economy, they are limited in effect by their limited distribution. (I haven't looked at Rognlie's research; I could be wrong.)
Further, my feeling is that real estate appreciation is an effect, not a cause. Consider the 2008 event ("circumstance?" "shenanigan?"): it was purely driven by the financial industry. It had, really, nothing to do with real estate at its core; it was caused by bad financial behavior, and the failure of the real estate market was simply how it was translated out of the finance world into the rest of the economy.
Likewise, my impression of the situation you describe is a result of the growth and success of the financial industry and the pursuit of a very limited class of real estate assets by that resulting block of money.
Tl;dr: High rents in San Francisco? Caused by the venture capital industry---a purely financial operation---and its insistence on having all of its investments physically co-located with where it wants to live.
- rcpt 8y agoUnless all the startup funding in the valley is going to pitch decks about real estate I don't see how your tldr follows.
- mcguire 8y agoLet's see a hypothetical: Patrick Gonnagle went to Stanford and really likes living in the Bay area. He also invented the idea of facebook for dogs and made a crap-ton of money in the dotcom era. Nowadays, he spends most of his time trying to out-do his peers in the nuevo-crap-ton-o'-money crowd with his extensive collection of Pia Zadora's underpants. The rest of the time, however, P-Gon (as he likes to be called) finds smart, idealistic, entertaining, and attractive young people, mostly from Stanford, and gives them large sums of money in exchange for a significant share of any future large sums of money their idealistic and entertaining activities will bring in. The idealistic and smart people like to get advice, recognition, and affirmation from P-Gon, and he likes to keep an eye on his investments (not to mention the advantage of showing off his cadre of minions to his peer group). So, they all have to live, work, eat, etc. in close proximity. P-Gon lives at the top of the Transamerica pyramid (literally; he built his 12,000 sq ft bedroom on the very pointy top of it). Fortunately, the I&S folks are being showered in cash (well, not literally; P-Gon has a swimming pool full of giant tapioca balls and $1000 bills that he makes them do laps in (hence "funding round")), so they have plenty of money to pay for suitable hovels. Lather, rinse, repeat for a couple of generations and you discover that rents are stupid ridiculous in the area of the giant fountain o' money. Which theoretically could be somewhat remedied, maybe, except that P-Gon doesn't want horrible brutalist high-rise apartment complexes blocking his view of the Tenderloin.
- TheTrotters 8y agoBut then you have to ask yourself why this surge in demand for real estate in urban areas hasn't been met by a corresponding surge in supply? Why aren't developers building new apartment complexes as fast as they can to cash in? The answer is primary that regulation by local governments prevents them from doing that thereby keeping real estate prices high.
- mcguire 8y agoIn the United States, anyway, local governments' regulation is largely driven by noisy or wealthy local residents. In most places, regulation is a minor hurdle for a decent real estate investor, all of whom regard single-family and small multi-family dwellings as a slobber-inducing opportunity when demand is high. (The high rents you can get from a quadplex are pretty small compared to the rents from a 10-story apartment building.) So, the question is really, "if it isn't real-estate developers trying to keep rents high, who has the money and therefore power to convince the government to adopt regulations preventing apartments?"
- epistasis 8y ago> In most places, regulation is a minor hurdle for a decent real estate investor, all of whom regard single-family and small multi-family dwellings as a slobber-inducing opportunity when demand is high. But you're conflating the two types of places: most places aren't "high" demand, and those that do have super inflated costs also have processes by which developers are regularly stopped. California in particular has this problem. In fact reading your post really made it clear to me the dichotomy between places that welcome new people and have governments that try to serve the people (by letting developers build), and places that try to enrich current residents by blocking out newcomers and thereby forcing demand to be far higher than supply.
- sgift 8y agoSpace is limited, demand is not. Physical reality trumps economic wish-thinking every time. Most of the time, the lack of space is the root problem, not some governmental boogeyman.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The "disproportionate price appreciation of housing and the land it sits on" seems to me to be primarily a factor only in some (maybe most) large cities; outside those cities, price appreciation, perhaps excessive price appreciation, has occurred, but it's nothing like that in those few cities. But those cities are where "the 1%" live or own property, so they're the beneficiaries of the price inflation, which is precisely the issue. A rich person bought a house in SF for $500K and now it's worth $5M, a middle income person bought a house in Detroit for $200K and now it's worth $200K, a lower income person rented an apartment in SF and saw the increase as an increase in rent rather than an increase in home value. > Further, my feeling is that real estate appreciation is an effect, not a cause. Consider the 2008 event ("circumstance?" "shenanigan?"): it was purely driven by the financial industry. It had, really, nothing to do with real estate at its core; it was caused by bad financial behavior, and the failure of the real estate market was simply how it was translated out of the finance world into the rest of the economy. It's more like a mechanism rather than a cause or effect. You make money cheap so people borrow and bid up housing costs. This enriches the existing owners who bought before prices increased, which increases wealth inequality because they were already the ones with the most money. The problem now is that you can't roll back the clock because transactions have already happened. Richard bought a house for $80K and sold it to Michael for $800K, because Michael needed a place to live and the bank was willing to loan him the money. If you now raise interest rates, the housing prices start to come back down, but Richard already has his $720K profit and the loss accrues to Michael who still has the $800K mortgage, and may now have to start paying higher interest on it in addition to the loss in home value. As a result the possible solutions start to look weird. Like causing general inflation on purpose to devalue everyone's mortgage debt and allow the price of everything else (including wages) to rise to meet the cost of housing without reducing nominal housing costs which would put too many people underwater on their mortgages, and employing policies like relaxing zoning restrictions to ensure that nominal housing prices don't rise with everything else.
- mcguire 8y agoMaking money cheap for mortgages is the mechanism the financial industry used---they used derivative technology in a largely-failed attempt to reduce the risks[1] of a class of extremely risky loans, loans would would never have been made without the derivatives. I'd argue that this benefited the financial industry much more than even "existing owners." Buying real estate cheap and selling it for great profit, as a rule, only works once. If you use the proceeds to buy back into the same market, you're buying expensive property; you only actually see the profit if you move to East Bumford and buy cheap property that isn't appreciating. Further $750k or even several million isn't enough to get into the 1%. But skimming a few percent in fees off of millions of transactions is nigh unlimited money.
- burlesona 8y agoI agree that real estate appreciation is an effect rather than a cause. What I'm suggesting is: if Rognlie is correct, the root cause of real estate appreciation may also be the root cause of rising inequality. I'll try to explain, giving a US-centric narrative because that's the one I know best, but similar parallel things have happened around the world. - - - - - Mass urbanization started in the 1800s and accelerated in the 20th century as the world transitioned from a rural/agricultural economy to an urban/industrial economy. In the US you can see how this worked as placed like New York boomed, but also smaller cities like Buffalo, Cleveland, and many others. This alarmed a lot of people, notably FDR. They didn't like that people were leaving smaller towns and rural areas and flocking to cities, and he wanted to try and keep the population more spread out. But they were just doing what was economically rational, getting better jobs in the city. And this is still going today -- see China, or the article on HN the other day about entire abandoned Spanish hamlets for sale). A lot of the push back against urbanization happened via regulatory policy and infrastructure investment. A great case of this is the Rural Electrification Act in the US. It's cost-effective to serve electricity to a city cheaply from a central plant, thus cities over a certain size (critical mass) started getting power plants and cheap electricity, whereas places below that threshold did not. There was actually a lot of innovation going on in this area, with "off grid" generation and low-power appliances etc. to serve the large, distributed rural population, but it was lagging behind the "convenience" of city power. So the US embarked on a government led program to mandate electrical service be provided to rural areas. The history of all that is complicated and I won't try to narrate it all here, but you ended up with a ton of messy side effects -- see all the land served by PG&E and the California wildfires today. The same thing happened with roads and bridges and basically every other kind of infrastructure. Without these programs people were trending to concentrating in the larger towns around the countryside (above critical mass) and depopulating rural areas, and the programs slowed that down a lot by providing heavily subsidized infrastructure to make their life more comfortable. At the same time a different movement was going on in cities, motivated for many reasons, to start limiting development. First it was to separate out polluting industrial factories from residential development -- arguably a very good call -- and then it spread to limit development generally and prescribe lower and lower limits to density. This was greatly aided by that same push to bring city utilities to rural areas -- the interstate highway act, for example, meant that suddenly there were vast areas a bit outside the cities that had great road access to the city center and high voltage lines etc. already going out to the farmers. Suburbanization here we come. Well, fast forward a few generations and the economic reality of much of that infrastructure is hitting home. Why don't we build big infrastructure projects like we used to? In part it's because a huge amount of maintenance money goes to keep the rural roads and power lines operating at huge losses, to places that would probably either have been abandoned or have adapted to an alternative "off-grid" set of technologies if not for the massive infrastructure subsidy they receive. But it's more pernicious than that, because the "spread everyone out" policies resulted in a pattern of development where most of the _urban_ areas are also below the critical population density where infrastructure has a positive return on investment. Ie. most suburban development is also an infrastructure money-loser. These policies are becoming increasingly difficult to sustain, resulting in deferred maintenance and generally bad infrastructure across most of the land area, and also a general lack of funding to keep up with the population growth in the major cities. And then at the same time, restrictive development policy - which is mostly concentrated on housing, not commercial development - means that housing in the cities that have the best economic opportunity for people is increasingly scarce and thus increasingly expensive. A final tie-in to your point about financialization and financial engineering -- the increasingly Byzantine development regulations mean that it takes higher and higher skill and more and more patient capital to negotiate the development process. Whereas it used to be quite common for a family to do something like split their lot, sell it, and an individual to buy that lot and build a home on it -- now development activity is increasingly limited to high-capital sophisticated firms that can deal with the regulation and holding cost. You also have the government funding this system via Fannie and Freddie etc., leading to the securitization of mortgages and a shift away from local savings and loan type funding. That, plus a whole generation of individuals and institutional investors believing that "your home is your best investment," so you have a giant coalition with a vested interest in housing prices steadily climbing. So it's not too surprising that you'd get a lot of financial engineering effort to try and keep the system steadily growing and that this could lead to bubbles every so often. - - - - - Whew. That's an attempt to summarize over a decade of reading and observation on my part, so I apologize it's rather long and rambly. But I hope that gives you some better illustrations for how this whole thing seems interconnected to me.
- ericd 8y agoNo, high rents in SF aren’t the fault of Venture Capital, except to the extent that VC has helped the economy boom in SF. That’s one factor, but the core problem is that we can’t build enough inventory to match demand to live in the city, largely due to artificial restrictions.
- Mirioron 8y ago>That’s one factor, but the core problem is that we can’t build enough inventory to match demand to live in the city, largely due to artificial restrictions. Even if you don't consider zoning laws, could we build enough supply to satisfy demand? People want to live in the city, but many are unwilling to live in (small) apartments. Many even want houses, but obviously the density of that type of housing is too low to satisfy demand. The city would sprawl. The outskirts would be far from where people want to live.
- burlesona 8y agoThe "city" is already sprawling, and the outskirts are already far from where people want to live. A lot of my coworkers commute in from places like Fremont, an hour away from the city in good conditions and who knows how long if BART or the Bay Bridge gets backed up. Meanwhile, I understand your point that "many people are unwilling to live in small apartments" but those people are by default not part of the demand in San Francisco itself - they're part of the demand in Gilroy and Freemont, perhaps, but not San Francisco. But "not being willing to live in small apartments" is not the same thing as not being willing to live in medium/large townhomes / row houses, which can accommodate vastly more people than live in most of the suburban expanse of the Bay Area. Just to make a dumbly over-simplified point, you could theoretically convert every ranch house in the bay area to two victorian townhomes and that would add room for more than a million new people, which I'm sure would make some dent in demand. Likewise, most of San Francisco's land area is occupied by 1 and 2 story buildings (Sunset, Richmond, Excelsior, etc.). Just going to an average of 3 stories would add a hundred thousand or more new homes. Regardless, while you may be right that demand is MUCH greater than supply and we'd need to add a million homes to make a dent, that's not a valid reason to do nothing. If we're not going to build more housing here, why not limit employment growth here and create some pretty major programs to move jobs OUT of the city and take some of the housing pressure with it. There's nothing stopping us building a big new city at moderate density between San Francisco and Sacramento, for example, and if the whole corridor was linked by reliable, fast transit service then it doesn't need to be a traffic nightmare either. TLDR; defeatism doesn't help, the economics here aren't THAT complicated we just don't seem to have the political will to do anything about it.