4 ms·
Our generation of people, millennial, have no hope of having the same retirement as people in their sixties today. Simple arithmetic says that once the taxpaye
by baybal2 8y ago
Our generation of people, millennial, have no hope of having the same retirement as people in their sixties today.
Simple arithmetic says that once the taxpayer/dependent ratio will hit that of Germany, it will be very very hard. Either you have a very strong industrial economy, or you study Greek.
Having some kids, and expecting them to give back one day does not seem to be anything unnatural to me. Though, I hope I will get some humility by then, and not have them bail out me financially by my fifties as my own parents did :(
- neffy 8y agoRight. Because since we're automating all the other jobs, there will be a huge shortage of labour/automation just in this sector. Apropos... I wouldn't worry about retirement per se, I would worry about their being an intact ecosystem to retire in.
- ravenstine 8y agoThat is why it is important not to solely rely on W2 income. Income has to be supplemented by starting side businesses in order to actually save and invest for anything without falling for the illusions of debt. On top of moving to places more affordable, it might be possible for the average person to retire. I just doubt that employment and a 401k are going to do that on their own. All the modestly wealthy people I know have other sources of income besides their main job.
- scarface74 8y agoBecause the majority of businesses don’t fail in 5 years....
- ravenstine 8y agoJust because a lot of people fail at it doesn't mean that those who might want to take the risk shouldn't be made aware of the benefits. I would personally rather deal with failure for the shot at making more income. It's not for everyone, and they can certainly stay on the beaten path and do just fine. (so long as their debt doesn't spiral out of control) I'm not saying that people should dedicate their lives to home businesses, but they can try different things on the side to see what works with a minimal risk of catastrophic failure.
- scarface74 8y agoIf you are a software developer in any major city in the US and you’re just really good at your bog standard enterprise developer type jobs or yet another software as a service CRUD app developer, you’re already probably in the 80th income percentile. If your goal is increasing net worth, it’s quite easy to live a comfortable middle class lifestyle and still put aside enough to have a couple of million and a paid off house in 15 to 20 years just by putting money in an index fund. There is really little risk of being long term unemployed as a software developer if you keep your skills in line with the local market and keep your network strong. This is coming from being a developer for the past 20 years. I’m not talking about how much I have personally saved, just how easy it is to get a job or at least a contract. It’s even easier for dual income earners. You can literally save an entire second income or put it toward net worth building. On second thought, the best “investment” I guess is a working spouse and a happy marriage. Statistics back that up.
- baybal2 8y agoWith all respect, this logic fails to account for the rising taxpayer/dependent ratio. If American tax rates will reach that of Europe, even dual income high earners, will just break the comfortable level — way less what I deserve with my position in society. And even that will worsen further over time. At some t/d ratio, the nation will simply turn into a "transfer economy" — when cash value of all pensions/savings withdrawals/welfare/rents will begin closing on on the total income of working populace. That's something close to what we had in Eastern Europe when Bloc collapsed. You don't realise the severity of issue until you calculate that NPV of an average boomer generation person, might've been higher 40 years ago, than NPV of savings and future contributions of highest earning young people today.
- scarface74 8y agoI’m going to repeat a previous argument in a way that hopefully doesn’t get my hand slapped and my comment flagged: There is an easy answer to that: a pro immigration policy for both high skilled labor that creates a jobs by starting businesses and low skilled labor that can do the work that our native born society is too old to do.
- scarface74 8y agoIf only smart and hardworking people from other countries were willing to come to the US for the opportunities it provides and help fuel another generation of growth.... Nah, that’s a crazy idea. It might “change the culture” of the country. We can’t have those evil brown people coming from the south committing crime and those evil Middle Easterners trying to spread “Sharia Law”. We were already barely rescued in time from a President who wasn’t an American citizen and who was a “secret Muslim”.
- dang 8y agoCould you please stop posting political and ideological battle comments to HN? They're off topic here, and destructive of the curiosity the site exists for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html