4 ms·
That sounds really terrible from a privacy point of view. That reminds me of the technology SeeChange at the core of the dystopian novel The Circle.
by dgellow 8y ago
That sounds really terrible from a privacy point of view. That reminds me of the technology SeeChange at the core of the dystopian novel The Circle.
- david_at 8y agoPlease see my answer to jaredmsmith -> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19532560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19532560 In addition to that, and I'm going to approach this delicately because some people are uncomfortable with facing this fact. But since you're on here I'm sure you know this. If you have a cell phone, used a credit reporting agency (Equifax?) or used almost any website in the past 10 years, you're already being tracked and your data has already been stolen in, on average, one data breach a month to advertise or politically manipulate you. The horse has already left the barn. Your life is right now being sold and resold every millisecond. But I'm doing you a favour. Because I'm giving your life away for free. And that data is freely disseminated to everyone not just because it stands as unassailable proof an AI performed a difficult computation on human behaviour and earned those coins but because it's important that everyone knows the truth about events in the natural world for science, democracy, health, justice and all rational decision making. An embargo on stupidity and ignorance in that node's corner of the world at least. Advantage must then come from helpful innovation not parasites rent seeking on people's data.
- cmroanirgo 8y agoTo keep up with your analogy: I'm here mending the fences of my farm to keep the horses from running, and you are using a bolt cutter on my gates. It's without my permission, and goes directly against my wishes. Some of us are still actively working on making the world a secure place. It can be done... but not with a project like this. It certainly doesn't help that this style of thinking plays right into the Mr Zuckerberg's hands. > But I'm doing you a favour. Because I'm giving your life away for free. I think I'm going to be sick...
- GordonS 8y agoYou're obviously a very intelligent and talented individual to have created this, frankly amazing, system, and to articulate your reasons for doing so. But I fundamentally disagree with the notion of total surveillance as a remedy to asymmetric surveillance. You obviously think this would benefit the world, but the endgame looks like a dystopian nightmare to me. I really wish you would have used your talents for "good rather than evil", looking at ways to prevent surveillance rather than increase it.
- cmroanirgo 8y agoWell said, particularly: > I really wish you would have used your talents for "good rather than evil", looking at ways to prevent surveillance rather than increase it. It just takes a little more thought on the problem to understand that removing all privacy is an instant and irreversible one way ticket to a dystopian outcome. OP suggests privacy is dead? Lol. I bet there are curtains on their house. I bet they goes to work wearing clothes. I bet they have sex behind closed doors... All of these are basic indicators that we have parts of ourselves and our lives that we like to keep private. Ask any woman whose private parts have been published on the internet without their consent and they'll mention the shame and the violation they feel.
- david_at 8y agoYou're looking at something and calling it 'surveillance' because you don't yet have a word to describe the entire thing. It's too new so you see it through your 'old eyes'. You noticed there was a camera involved and you knew what that was so you ran with it. It's the proverbial blind man whose hand has happened to land on the tusk and he tells his companions, "It's a spear!". You're not seeing the whole elephant because you've never seen one. It benefits you when other people have knowledge about the world. It benefits you if other people have the knowledge to drive safely. It benefits you that your neighbours have a basic knowledge of germ theory and don't throw their sewage in the streets like medieval peasants. It benefits you that your fellow voters have at least a basic education and can make somewhat informed decisions. It benefits you that medical knowledge isn't locked away in some vault in Alexandria but it's in the mind of the doctor whose preventing an outbreak of some disease you happen to be susceptible to. Did you not read the things I was able to learn just from my first node? We can give so many people free access to information that would push back darkness, fear and superstition just a little further. And these people would do and build things that would make your life better. So instead of channelling the Archbishop of Canterbury telling Bible translator John Wycliffe that too much knowledge will corrupt the commoners, open your eyes.
- arcticfox 8y agoDavid Brin also touched on the idea in his 1989 novel Earth, where police bodycams were required, but citizens ubiquitously chose to wear bodycams as well to keep everyone honest. I always thought the idea felt rather inevitable. https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-0411-cameras-everywhere-20150412-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-0411-cameras-everywhe...
- david_at 8y agoThe words you guys use, "dystopian", "doomsday", etc. etc. are all from fiction. These are literally categories of genre-fiction. You're seriously trying to make straight faced predictions about the future using what is literally in the book store under "Fiction". Something that is by definition not real, a fabrication, a lie. How can you possibly expect me to take you seriously or grasp what it is that I'm doing? You've taken stories you know are fake and mapped them to the real world. How is that any different from religion? I'm giving you guys mathematical arguments and you're giving me Dr. Seuss. And you've put words in my mouth to suit your narrative. The story you want to believe. A story that's fake by defintion. Don't you see how messed up that is? Well, Hitchen's Razor says that, "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence". Here's my razor, "What can be asserted with fiction can be dismissed with fiction". This is a bulwark against those who insist on living in a world of fantasy and superstition. But for the rest of us, those who want to live in reality, I'm giving you the real world.