17 ms·
The main lesson I learned in my mandatory ethics class was that formal ethics can be used to justify anything. I'm not sure if the teacher we had was just not
by grawprog 8y ago
The main lesson I learned in my mandatory ethics class was that formal ethics can be used to justify anything.
I'm not sure if the teacher we had was just not very good or if ethics classes are just like this. But, we ended up arguing with her a lot, we were all in ecological restoration and a whole lot of the case study examples we were given were to show how various corporations were ethically correct in doing some pretty terrible things.
As you can imagine, this is pretty much in direct opposition for everything we had been going to school for for the previous three years and we'd recently come back from a trip involving some wetlands, a copper mine and a golf course that had jaded us pretty heavily towards any kind of ethical reasoning to the actions of industry.
There was one evening(we were forced to take this in the evening) she ended up screaming at us to shut the fuck up we just didn't understand and sat in her desk and didn't speak for the rest of the class.
Ethics was by far my least favourite course in university.
- Mirioron 8y agoI think the reason you can end up justifying anything you want in ethics is because you're trying to explain something that's undecidable. You need to pit different interests of people against one another and then find out which one is more important. It's like comparing apples and oranges - you can do it, but the result is going to be colored by the biases you think are important to compare. It's not going to be a fully objective comparison. The real world is a highly complex system. So complex in fact that the basic principles get lost in the noise of everything going on in the world.